Severe malaria (SM) is classically associated with Plasmodium falciparum infection. Little information is available on the contribution of P. vivax to severe disease. There are some epidemiological indications that P. vivax or mixed infections protect against complications and deaths. A large morbidity surveillance conducted in an area where the four species coexist allowed us to estimate rates of SM among patients infected with one or several species.
Methods and Findings
This was a prospective cohort study conducted within the framework of the Malaria Vaccine Epidemiology and Evaluation Project. All presumptive malaria cases presenting at two rural health facilities over an 8-y period were investigated with history taking, clinical examination, and laboratory assessment. Case definition of SM was based on the World Health Organization (WHO) criteria adapted for the setting (i.e., clinical diagnosis of malaria associated with asexual blood stage parasitaemia and recent history of fits, or coma, or respiratory distress, or anaemia [haemoglobin < 5 g/dl]). Out of 17,201 presumptive malaria cases, 9,537 (55%) had a confirmed Plasmodium parasitaemia. Among those, 6.2% (95% confidence interval [CI] 5.7%–6.8%) fulfilled the case definition of SM, most of them in children <5 y. In this age group, the proportion of SM was 11.7% (10.4%–13.2%) for P. falciparum, 8.8% (7.1%–10.7%) for P. vivax, and 17.3% (11.7%–24.2%) for mixed P. falciparum and P. vivax infections. P. vivax SM presented more often with respiratory distress than did P. falciparum (60% versus 41%, p = 0.002), but less often with anaemia (19% versus 41%, p = 0.0001).
P. vivax monoinfections as well as mixed Plasmodium infections are associated with SM. There is no indication that mixed infections protected against SM. Interventions targeted toward P. falciparum only might be insufficient to eliminate the overall malaria burden, and especially severe disease, in areas where P. falciparum and P. vivax coexist.
Citation: Genton B, D'Acremont V, Rare L, Baea K, Reeder JC, Alpers MP, et al. (2008) Plasmodium vivax and Mixed Infections Are Associated with Severe Malaria in Children: A Prospective Cohort Study from Papua New Guinea . PLoS Med 5(6): e127. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.0050127
Academic Editor: Stephen Rogerson, Royal Melbourne Hospital, Australia
Received: December 7, 2007; Accepted: May 2, 2008; Published: June 17, 2008
Copyright: © 2008 Genton et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: The morbidity surveillance was established as a component of field site preparation for malaria vaccine trials funded by grant from USAID and AusAID. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Abbreviations: df, degree of freedom; PNG, Papua New Guinea; SM, severe malaria; SP, sulfadoxine-pyrimethamine; UM, uncomplicated malaria; WBC, white blood cells
Malaria is a parasitic infection that is transmitted to people by infected mosquitoes. Four different parasites cause malaria—Plasmodium falciparum, P. vivax, P. ovale, and P. malariae. Of these, P. vivax is the commonest and most widely distributed, whereas P. falciparum causes the most deaths. All these parasites enter their human host when an infected mosquito takes a blood meal. They then migrate to the liver where they replicate without causing any symptoms. Eight to nine days later, mature parasites are released from the liver cells and invade red blood cells. Here, they multiply rapidly before bursting out and infecting more red blood cells. The recurring flu-like symptoms of malaria are caused by this cyclical increase in parasitemia (parasites in the blood) and should be treated promptly with antimalarial drugs to prevent the development of potentially fatal complications. Infections with P. falciparum in particular can cause anemia by destroying the red blood cells and can damage vital organs (including the brain) by blocking the capillaries that supply them with blood.
Why Was This Study Done?
It is generally believed that P. vivax malaria is rarely fatal. There is even some evidence that infection with P. vivax alone (monoinfection) or with other malaria parasites (mixed infection) provides protection against malarial complications. Recently, however, there have been reports of severe disease and deaths associated with infection by P. vivax alone. Most of these reports do not indicate what proportion of severe malaria cases are caused by P. vivax infections, but if P. vivax is responsible for a significant proportion of malarial deaths, efforts to prevent these deaths will need to target P. vivax as well as P. falciparum. In this study, therefore, the researchers estimate the proportion of cases of severe malaria among patients infected with one or several Plasmodium species in Papua New Guinea, a country where all four species coexist.
What Did the Researchers Do and Find?
The researchers enrolled everyone attending two rural health facilities in the Wosera subdistrict of Papua New Guinea over an eight-year period with symptoms indicative of malaria but without symptoms of any other disease (presumptive malaria cases) into their prospective cohort study. They asked each patient about their symptoms, did a standard physical examination, looked for parasites in their blood, and measured their hemoglobin levels to see whether they were anemic. Out of 17,201 presumptive malaria cases, 483 had severe malaria (defined as parasitemia plus a recent history of fits, coma, breathing problems, or anemia). Most of the patients with severe malaria were less than five years old—children have little immunity to Plasmodium parasites. In this age group, 11.7% of patients infected with P. falciparum, 8.8% of patients infected with P. vivax, and 17.3% of patients infected with both parasites had severe malaria. Patients with severe malaria caused by P. vivax presented with breathing difficulties more often than those infected with P. falciparum, whereas anemia was more common among patients with severe malaria caused by P. falciparum than by P. vivax.
What Do These Findings Mean?
The researchers use these results and data on the numbers of infections with each parasite to calculate that, in this rural region of Papua New Guinea, P. vivax is responsible for one-fifth of severe malaria cases, P. falciparum is responsible for three-quarters of cases, and the rest involve mixed P. falciparum/P. vivax infections. Put another way, these findings suggest that about one in ten children under the age of five years infected with either P. vivax or P. falciparum may develop severe malaria. These findings provide no evidence, however, that mixed infections are protective. Because the diagnosis of severe malaria was not confirmed by outcome data (deaths or permanent disability), additional, more detailed studies are needed to confirm these results. Nevertheless, these findings (and those reported separately in a related article published at the same time in PLoS Medicine) suggest that a significant proportion of the illness associated with malaria may be caused by P. vivax infections. Thus, efforts to reduce or eliminate the malarial burden must target P. vivax as well as P. falciparum in regions where these species coexist.
Please access these Web sites via the online version of this summary at http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmed.0050127.
- A PLoS Medicine Research in Translation article by Stephen Rogerson further discusses this study and a related paper on vivax malaria infection in patients attending a regional hospital in Papua, Indonesia
- The MedlinePlus encyclopedia has a page on malaria (in English and Spanish)
- The US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention provides information on malaria (in English and Spanish)
- Information is available from the Roll Back Malaria Partnership on global control of malaria and on malaria in Papua New Guinea
- Vivaxmalaria provides information for the malaria research community on topics related to Plasmodium vivax
- The Malaria Vaccine Initiative also provides a fact sheet on Plasmodium vivax malaria
Most of the research and published literature on malaria focuses on P. falciparum and much less on P. vivax [1,2]. This focus is due to the very high burden of mortality attributed to the falciparum species in Africa . However, there is growing evidence that P. vivax is responsible for a significant burden of disease worldwide accounting for half of all malaria cases in Asia and Latin America . As the term “benign tertian malaria” implies, vivax malaria is usually an uncomplicated disease that runs a benign course and is rarely fatal. This clinical paradigm has been challenged recently  by numerous reports of symptoms and signs of severe disease, and even deaths due to P. vivax monoinfections [6–9]. However, most of the published literature consists of case reports or small descriptive clinical series lacking denominators. The relative contribution of P. vivax versus P. falciparum to severe morbidity has not been properly assessed, except for one study in Thailand that found very little severe disease and no death due to P. vivax . This Thai study suggested, rather, a protecting effect of vivax, as had a study from Vanuatu [11,12]. It is only recently that severe disease due to P. vivax has received more attention with a recent report from a hospital in northeastern Indonesian New Guinea (Papua) where they found 36 severe malaria (SM) cases among 1,135 P. vivax infected patients (3.2%) .
The malaria epidemiology in Papua New Guinea (PNG) offers the opportunity to investigate in the same population the respective contribution of the different Plasmodium species in terms of morbidity, and severe disease in particular. Indeed, it is one of the few countries where all four Plasmodium species coexist at sufficient prevalence to allow proper comparisons. The aim of the present clinico-epidemiological study was to assess the proportion of cases presenting at health facilities with severe manifestations of malaria and associated P. vivax parasitaemia, to compare this proportion to that of P. falciparum in the same setting, and to investigate the potential of mixed P. falciparum and P. vivax infection to protect against severe disease.
Study Area and Population
The Wosera lies in the East Sepik Province of PNG. Transmission of malaria is perennial, but the distribution of rainfall shows some seasonality with 65% falling during the so-called wet season occurring from October to April. Malariometric surveys conducted in the area showed an overall Plasmodium prevalence rate of 60% in the early 1990s decreasing to 35% by 2002. The reduction was from 38% to 22% for P. falciparum, 20% to 10% for P. vivax, 16% to 4% for P. malariae [14,15], and was probably related to a gradual increase in the use of insecticide treated nets and a change in treatment policy.
The morbidity surveillance was conducted in two health facilities, Kunjigini Health Subcentre in the South Wosera and Kaugia Health Subcentre in the North Wosera, within the framework of the Malaria Vaccine Epidemiology and Evaluation Project . Both health facilities are staffed with nurses and have beds to admit severe cases for a short period of time. Limited laboratory tests are available (light microscopy for malaria, haemoglobin photometer, and urine dipstick). The local referral centre is Maprik Hospital, a 110-bed government hospital. Recourse to health services is usual in case of fever, especially in children, but referral is very uncommon, due to transport problems and lack of qualified staff in the hospital. First-line treatment policy for uncomplicated malaria (UM) was a 3-d regimen of oral amodiaquine in children < 20 kg, or chloroquine in those > 20 kg; treatment for severe or resistant malaria included a 5-d regimen of intramuscular quinine combined with a single dose of oral sulfadoxine-pyrimethamine (SP). In 2000, the first-line treatment changed to a combination of amodiaquine or chloroquine (3 d) plus SP (single dose) for UM, and the second-line to artesunate (7 d) plus SP (single dose on day 3). The 28-d failure rates with the regimens used in the area during the study were ∼20% for P. falciparum and ∼0% for P. vivax [17,18].
Patients were prospectively recruited if they were diagnosed on clinical grounds only as having malaria (presumptive diagnosis). The diagnosis was based on a history of fever without obvious symptoms or signs of another disease. These presumptive malaria cases were further investigated by a research nurse. After recording demographical information, closed questions were asked on the characteristics of the morbid episode (history of fever, headache, cough, dyspnea, vomiting, diarrhoea, abdominal pain, and convulsions). A standardized physical examination was then performed (axillary temperature, level of consciousness, respiratory rate, chest indrawing, and Hackett's grading of spleen). A blood sample was taken for parasitological examination by microscopy and haemoglobin measurement (for details see Genton et al. ).
Blood films were stained with 4% Giemsa and examined for 100 microscopic thick film fields prior to being declared negative. In positive films, parasite species were identified and densities were recorded as the number of parasites per 200 white blood cells (WBC). This procedure was followed for each species. Densities were converted to parasites per microliter of blood, assuming 8,000 WBC per microliter. A routine quality control procedure was performed . Briefly, 10% of randomly selected slides and all those that had a density between 1 and 5 parasites per 200 WBC (for any of the four species) were reread, in a blinded fashion, by a supervisor microscopist. When the results on a batch of ∼1,000 slides did not reach 75% agreement on positivity/negativity, species, and density (including a margin of error that increased with increasing density), the entire batch was reread and the same quality control applied again.
Ethical approval and informed consent
The morbidity surveillance in the Wosera area received ethical approval from the Medical Research Advisory Committee (MRAC) within the framework of the larger Malaria Vaccine Epidemiology and Evaluation Project . Patients or patients' guardians were asked for oral informed consent by the research nurse. This mode of consent was approved by the MRAC, and considered appropriate for this setting where many people cannot read and write. Moreover, the procedures performed (systematic history taking, clinical examination, and diagnostic test for malaria) provided patients with a laboratory-confirmed diagnosis of malaria and consequently with better management of the illness.
A UM case was defined as a presumptive malaria patient (see above) associated with documented Plasmodium asexual blood-stage parasitaemia by light microscopy.
A SM case was defined using the standard criteria established by the World Health Organization (WHO), except that we also included species other than P. falciparum, and we did not take into account a parasite density >250,000/μl since we expected lower densities in P. vivax than in P. falciparum infections . Because clinical and laboratory facilities were limited in the setting we were working in, we could only assess a subset of criteria defining SM. Thus, our definition included a patient with presumptive malaria associated with documented Plasmodium asexual blood-stage parasitaemia, and with at least one of the following: history of more than one convulsion in the last 24 h; coma (patient unable to localize a painful stimulus); respiratory distress (high respiratory rate [> 50 for children 0 to < 2 mo of age and > 40 for others including adults] and chest indrawing or shortness of breath); and haemoglobin < 5 g/dl. Since there is ongoing debate about whether it is appropriate or not to include patients with associated symptoms or signs (comorbidity), we also report on a more restricted definition excluding patients with associated cough and/or diarrhoea, two features that may or may not be related to malaria . The latter symptoms were usually mild since, if significant, the patients would not have been diagnosed as presumptive malaria.
We analysed the proportion of SM cases by species (P. falciparum monoinfection, P. vivax monoinfection, and mixed P. falciparum and P. vivax infections) among all malaria cases (UM and SM) recorded in the morbidity surveillance from 1997 to 2004. We stratified our analysis by age group, since we expected different effects in individuals with different level of pre-existing immunity. We focused most of the analyses in the 0- to 5-y age group, since in highly endemic areas of PNG vivax malaria and SM, in particular, are encountered mainly in young children [23,24].
The chi square test was used (i) to compare rates of SM between the groups of malaria cases infected with P. falciparum, P. vivax, or mixed species; (ii) to investigate seasonal variation of SM rates; and (iii) to compare the distribution of clinical and laboratory features defining SM between groups of SM patients infected with P. falciparum, P. vivax, or mixed species. The proportions of cases with each of these features among P. falciparum, P. vivax, or mixed species SM are illustrated by Venn diagrams (created using free software that draws three set area proportional graphs) . A chi square for trend was used to investigate the pattern of SM over the 8-y period.
Parasite densities were compared between severe and uncomplicated malaria as well as between species using log-transformed data and t-tests.
Data management was performed using the Foxpro software and data analysis Stata version 6. Since only a subsample of our patients in the morbidity surveillance were also included in the demography surveillance database (different villages), no systematic follow-up was possible.
A total of 73,620 patients were registered in the 8-y period of the morbidity surveillance from 1997 to 2004. Among those, 17,201 cases were diagnosed as presumptive malaria cases and investigated further by the research nurse. A total of 9,537 of those patients (55%) had asexual Plasmodium parasitaemia. Among those, 6,886 (72%) had pure P. falciparum, 1,946 (20%) P. vivax, 328 (3%) P. malariae, 27 (0.3%) P. ovale, and 350 (4%) mixed infections (314 P. falciparum and P. vivax; 21 P. falciparum and P. malariae; ten P. vivax and P. malariae; three P. falciparum and P. ovale; one P. malariae and P. ovale; and one P. falciparum, P. vivax, and P. malariae). The age-specific parasite prevalence and species distribution among all presumptive malaria cases is shown in Figure 1. The highest parasite prevalence was found in children aged 5 to < 10 y (peak age 7 y). On the other hand, the highest proportion of P. vivax was seen in children 2 to < 5 y (peak age 2 y), with up to 20% parasitaemic.
Among parasitaemic individuals with all data available (7,759), 6.2% (95% confidence interval [CI] 5.7%–6.8%) fulfilled the case definition of SM. Table 1 details the proportion of SM cases associated with P. falciparum, P. vivax, and mixed P. falciparum and P. vivax infections by age group using two different case definitions: standard and restricted (excluding patients with cough or diarrhoea). Children aged < 2 y were more likely to have SM (standard definition) than those aged 2 to < 5 y (odds ratio [OR] 2.2, 95% CI 1.8–2.7) and those aged 5 to < 10 y (OR 6.4, 95% CI 4.7–8.6); for individuals infected with P. vivax, the ORs were of 2.8 (95% CI 1.8–4.4) and 7.5 (95% CI 3.5–15.7), respectively; for individuals infected with P. falciparum, the ORs were of 2.0 (95% CI 1.5–2.6) and 6.0 (95% CI 4.2–8.5); for individuals with mixed infections, the ORs were of 3.2 (95% 95% CI 1.3–8.0) and 32.1 (95% 95% CI 3.2–319, Fisher's exact < 0.001). The decrease in risk of severe disease was linear with age for all patients with P. falciparum, P. vivax, or mixed infections (Figure 2). The decrease in risk was significantly more pronounced for mixed (OR 0.52/y, CI 0.38–0.72) compared to single infections (OR 0.72/y, 95% CI 0.68–0.76, likelihood ratio [LR] χ2 = 4.7, degree of freedom [df] = 1, p = 0.03), but similar for P. falciparum (OR 0.73/y, 95% CI 0.68–0.74) and P. vivax single infections (OR 0.65/y, CI 0.56–0.77, likelihood ratio [LR] χ2 = 2.5, df = 1, p = 0.11).
Proportion of SM Cases Associated with P. falciparum, P. vivax, and Mixed P. falciparum and P. vivax Infections by Age Group Using Two Case Definitions: Standard and Restricted (Excluding Patients with Cough or Diarrhoea)
Figure 3 shows the proportion of SM in children < 5 y infected with any species (except P. ovale because cases were too few) or mixed infections. Children < 5 y infected with both P. falciparum and P. vivax infections (mixed) were more likely to present with SM than those who were infected with P. falciparum only (17% versus 12%, OR 1.5, 95% CI 1.0–2.4), or P. vivax only (17% versus 9%, respectively, OR 2.1, 95% CI 1.3–3.5). In children < 2 y, almost one-third (29%) with mixed infections had SM. In this age group, the proportion of SM among P. vivax infections was close to that among P. falciparum infections (14% versus 18%, respectively, for the standard definition, 4% versus 6% for the restricted definition) (see Table 1).
Horizontal, species; vertical, proportion of SM.
The proportion of SM cases (< 5 y) presenting with each type of clinical manifestation or laboratory feature defining SM is shown schematically in Figure 4 by Venn diagrams for the group of SM infected with P. vivax, P. falciparum, or mixed species. P. vivax SM and mixed SM presented more often with respiratory distress than did P. falciparum SM (61% versus 41%, χ2 = 9.85, p = 0.002 and 67% versus 41%, χ2 = 5.88, p = 0.015, respectively), but less often with anaemia; the latter being only significant for the comparison between P. vivax and P. falciparum (19% versus 41%, χ2 = 14.57, p = 0.0001 and 29% versus 41%, χ2 = 1.36, p = 0.2). Neurological manifestations tended to be less frequent in mixed SM than in P. falciparum or P. vivax SM (8% versus 23% and 26%, respectively), but none of the differences were significant, probably due to the small numbers. Comparing the rate of each neurological sign between P. vivax and P. falciparum SM, fits were as frequent in both species (22% for both, χ2 = 0, p = 0.96); as well as coma (4% versus 2%, respectively, χ2 = 1.25, p = 0.26).
More generally, among all children < 5 y with parasitaemia, the prevalence of anaemia was 5.1% in patients infected with P. falciparum, 1.6% in those with P. vivax, and 5.3% in those with mixed infections; respiratory distress was found in 5.5% of P. falciparum patients, 5.1% of P. vivax patients, and 10.3% of those with mixed infections; and repeated convulsions were encountered in 2.5% and coma in 0.2% of P. falciparum patients, in 2% and 0.3%, respectively, of P. vivax individuals, and in 1.1% and 0%, respectively, of those with mixed infections.
To investigate whether the increased risk of SM in children infected with two species was due to a higher overall parasite burden, we compared densities in mixed infections versus those in monoinfections. As shown in Figure 5 (restricted to children < 5 y), total parasite densities were indeed significantly higher in children with mixed infections than in those with P. falciparum or P. vivax monoinfections, whether all cases (t = −2.41, df = 2,968, p = 0.02 and t = −11.57, df = 1,372, p < 0.01, respectively) or the severe ones only (t = −2.38, df = 283, p = 0.02 and t = −5.39, df = 108, p < 0.01, respectively) were considered. Densities tended to be lower in the severe P. falciparum and P. vivax cases than in the uncomplicated ones; the reverse was true in cases with mixed infections. In the latter, the average proportion of P. falciparum density/total parasite density was 83% in the UM and 87% in SM.
Line is median, boxes are 25th and 75th percentile, and whiskers are upper and lower adjacent values.
Age was the prominent risk factor for presenting with SM, but the season and year of attendance also had a significant effect. Malaria (parasitaemic) patients attending during the wet season were more likely to have SM than those attending during the dry season (OR 1.3, 95% CI 1.1–1.6), and this effect was significant for P. vivax (OR 1.9, 95% CI 1.2–2.9), but not for P. falciparum (OR 1.1, 95% CI 0.9–1.4), or mixed infections (OR 0.8, 0.4–1.9). Over the years, there was a significant decrease in the rate of SM (OR 0.8, 95% CI 0.7–0.8), with a clear step observed from 2000 onward, probably as a consequence of the new treatment policy that was introduced in that year (adding SP to amodiaquine or chloroquine).
The present study shows that in a rural area of PNG where all four species of Plasmodium coexist, P. vivax is responsible for 21% of all SM cases, P. falciparum for 71%, and mixed P. vivax and P. falciparum infections for 5%. A feature of this clinico-epidemiological report is the simultaneous presence of P. falciparum as an internal control for P. vivax, so that the relative proportions of severe disease can be determined, regardless of its definition. The proportion of patients < 5 y who presented with SM among all P. vivax infected children was as high as 9%. The corresponding value for P. falciparum was 12%. Since the evaluators and the defining criteria for uncomplicated and severe malaria were strictly the same, we can be confident that the relative values (P. vivax versus P. falciparum) are correct. Moreover, the absolute value for the proportion of severe cases among all P. falciparum-infected children (12%) was lower than those found in numerous other studies of clinical malaria, the main reason being that our study took place in a peripheral health facility and not in a referral hospital as most, if not all, other studies [26–28]. It is clear that this absolute value depends entirely on the criteria used to define SM and on the population from which the cases are selected. Since we were working in a setting that did not allow us to measure certain parameters included in the WHO definition, such as glycemia or creatininemia, we probably slightly underestimated the true proportion of severe malaria caused by both species. Whichever definition is used, the relative contribution of P. vivax to the overall burden of SM morbidity is considerable in this region, and especially in children <2 y, where the proportion of P. vivax parasitaemic children presenting with severe disease reached a worrying rate of 14% (versus 18% for P. falciparum). These data on severe vivax malaria are in line with those reported in a joint paper from a hospital in Papua, Indonesia, also published in this issue of the journal . In that setting, severe disease was present in 23% of the patients with malaria, with rates similar for P. falciparum and P. vivax (22%), but significantly higher in patients with mixed infections (34%). These two observational studies, although both originating from the same region of the world, add to the growing realization that P. vivax is not benign. They are the first studies, to our knowledge, to incorporate denominators that allow assessing the relative magnitude of the problem when compared to that of P. falciparum.
Although all types of malaria complications observed with P. falciparum were also encountered with P. vivax, their distribution was different: severe cases of P. vivax were less likely than those of P. falciparum to present with anaemia, but more likely to suffer from respiratory distress. These observations are understandable since we know that P. vivax malaria patients have lower densities than P. falciparum patients, and therefore the likelihood of having profound anaemia is less, even if other immunological factors may contribute to red cell destruction. The proportion of severe P. vivax cases with anaemia was much less in our study (19%) than in Tjitra's (86%) . Their hypothesis of P. vivax resistance contributing largely to the high prevalence of anaemia in their setting is plausible since we had 0% P. vivax resistance in the Wosera during the study period [17,18] versus 65%–95% in theirs [29,30]. Our finding of increased risk of respiratory distress in vivax patients when compared to falciparum patients is in line with recent data from Anstey et al. who showed a more severe alveolar-capillary dysfunction in vivax than falciparum malaria . These observations are consistent with a greater inflammatory response to a given parasite burden in P. vivax relative to that in P. falciparum, and suggest that P. vivax infected erythrocytes may sequester within the pulmonary microvasculature . Severe vivax malaria is thus an emerging recognized entity, and the long-standing belief that P. vivax is a nonsequestering parasite might need to be revisited [31,32].
Contrary to the study in Thailand that reported lower frequencies of SM in dual P. vivax and P. falciparum infections [10,33], we found that patients with mixed infections were more likely to present with SM than those infected with a single Plasmodium species. Our data are in line with case series from India , Malaysia , and Indonesia . The mechanism for the higher proportion of SM among patients with mixed infections might be a higher overall parasite load. Indeed we found that severe cases with mixed infections had higher parasite densities than those with single P. falciparum and, even more so, P. vivax infection. This increased severity does not formally contradict the possible protective role of asymptomatic P. vivax infection against a subsequent P. falciparum morbid episode. In a study conducted in the same area as the present one , asymptomatic individuals infected with P. vivax, P. malariae, or mixed infections were less likely to have a morbid episode with P. falciparum during follow-up. This may mean that indeed non-falciparum species could protect against the risk of morbid episode because of P. falciparum, but, once the disease is established, having mixed infection makes the patient sicker, owing to the higher parasite density, as found in our study. This hypothesis must be balanced against the observation that, also in our series, SM cases with single P. falciparum or P. vivax infection did not harbor higher parasite densities than uncomplicated cases. This has been repeatedly found in different settings. Parasite density has not been identified as a risk factor for death in one of the largest series of malaria cases in Africa .
Our study is limited by the fact that parasite species were identified by microscopy, and it is known that this method largely misses minority infections [15,38,39]. Thus, mixed infections may have been largely underestimated, and a more sensitive detection method may have led to different results. While this limitation may be valid, it is believed that, in general, the infections that make the patient sick are those of high density, and that these are the ones that are identified by microscopy, as in the present study; those with very low densities are unlikely to contribute much to the acute phase, and even less to severe manifestations.
Another potential limitation is the accuracy of malaria diagnosis. In a high transmission area, where the prior probability of a young child being parasitaemic is high, the diagnosis of clinical malaria is not straightforward. We know from comparable settings in Africa that sepsis is commonly misdiagnosed as malaria, or that pneumonia can be associated with malaria. Since no blood cultures and no chest radiographs were performed, we cannot be certain that these children did not have a disease other than malaria. However, this potential bias is inherent to all studies of SM, even those that include thorough clinical assessment and sophisticated laboratory procedures. In intervention studies, a parasite density threshold is advised to increase the specificity of the diagnosis. When using a P. falciparum density threshold that should have led to over 90% sensitivity and 90% specificity for a diagnosis of malaria in this area and age group (< 5 y) , we found that 74% of the P. falciparum UM and 71% of the P. falciparum SM were above 4,000 parasites/μl. When applying the same statistical methodology to P. vivax (I. Mueller, personal correspondence), 71% of the P. vivax UM and 66% of the P. vivax SM were above 1,000 parasites per microlitre. We can thus postulate that at least two-thirds of the cases were “true” malaria. Even if some of our cases actually had alternative/additional diagnoses, the finding of severe disease with an associated P. vivax parasitaemia cannot be disregarded, as in P. falciparum cases . These children should still be managed as SM cases, whether illness is due to P. falciparum, to P. vivax, or to another cause indistinguishable from malaria [42,43]. This approach is supported by a recent retrospective analyses of hospital records in Jayapura, West Papua, Indonesia, which found risk of fatal outcomes among SM patients was comparable between those with falciparum versus vivax malaria . Epidemiological studies such as the present one should be used as a notice for clinicians working in areas where P. vivax is present, and as a signal for researchers to further investigate the pathogenesis of P. vivax malaria and the potential associated comorbidities, such as sepsis, in the same way as has been done for P. falciparum .
Why is P. vivax malaria only now recognized as a potential serious threat to life, although the parasite has been present for centuries? One of the reasons may be that SM has always been, and almost exclusively, associated with cerebral complications, and the latter are rare in P. vivax. The prejudice to only consider P. falciparum as potentially severe was therefore difficult to overcome. It is only in the 1990s that other clinical manifestations and laboratory parameters have been identified as indicators of poor outcome . Anaemia and respiratory distress, for example, have been recently included in the case definition of SM, and these signs are encountered frequently in P. vivax malaria. There is therefore increased awareness to recognize manifestations that may be less apparent than coma, but still harbor poor prognosis. Also, the relatively recent establishment of large morbidity surveillance systems in different epidemiological settings has improved the ability of researchers to capture unexpected events or trends.
The finding that a significant proportion of SM morbidity is due to P. vivax calls for interventions that do not target P. falciparum parasites only, at least in areas where several Plasmodium species coexist. In areas with multiple species, new interventions should be assessed for their effectiveness on overall malaria morbidity, so that potential interactions, especially compensatory effects on other species, can be identified early enough, before widespread implementation.
We would like to thank the staff of Kunjingini and Wombisa health centres, who have been assessing these patients with dedication for over ten years, and the microscopists of the PNG IMR for their conscientiousness and accuracy in blood slide reading.
BG designed the study, performed clinical supervision and data checking, and wrote the manuscript. VDA was responsible for data cleaning and analysis. LR was responsible for the demography surveillance system and for the day-to-day activities in the Wosera. KB was the research nurse in charge and on-site microscopist. JCR was the PNG IMR director for the second part of the morbidity surveillance, in charge of overall activities. MPA was the former PNG IMR director; he designed the study and was in charge of overall activities for half of the study period. IM was in charge of data base management and coordinated the malaria activities on site for the second part of the study period.
- 1. Sina B (2002) Focus on Plasmodium vivax. Trends Parasitol 18: 287–289.
- 2. Baird JK (2007) Neglect of Plasmodium vivax malaria. Trends Parasitol 23: 533–539.
- 3. Hay SI, Guerra CA, Tatem AJ, Noor AM, Snow RW (2004) The global distribution and population at risk of malaria: past, present, and future. Lancet Infect Dis 4: 327–336.
- 4. Mendis K, Sina BJ, Marchesini P, Carter R (2001) The neglected burden of Plasmodium vivax malaria. Am J Trop Med Hyg 64(Suppl): 97–106.
- 5. Picot S (2006) [Is Plasmodium vivax still a paradigm for uncomplicated malaria?] Med Mal Infect 36: 406–413.
- 6. Beg MA, Khan R, Baig SM, Gulzar Z, Hussain R, et al. (2002) Cerebral involvement in benign tertian malaria. Am J Trop Med Hyg 67: 230–232.
- 7. Kochar DK, Saxena V, Singh N, Kochar SK, Kumar SV, et al. (2005) Plasmodium vivax malaria. Emerg Infect Dis 11: 132–134.
- 8. Koh KH, Chew PH, Kiyu A (2004) A retrospective study of malaria infections in an intensive care unit of a general hospital in Malaysia. Singapore Med J 45: 28–36.
- 9. Svenson JE, MacLean JD, Gyorkos TW, Keystone J (1995) Imported malaria. Clinical presentation and examination of symptomatic travelers. Arch Intern Med 155: 861–868.
- 10. Luxemburger C, Ricci F, Nosten F, Raimond D, Bathet S, et al. (1997) The epidemiology of severe malaria in an area of low transmission in Thailand. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 91: 256–262.
- 11. Maitland K, Williams TN, Peto TE, Day KP, Clegg JB, et al. (1997) Absence of malaria-specific mortality in children in an area of hyperendemic malaria. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 91: 562–566.
- 12. Maitland K, Williams TN, Newbold CI (1997) Plasmodium vivax and P. falciparum: biological interactions and the possibility of cross-species immunity. Parasitol Today 13: 227–231.
- 13. Barcus MJ, Basri H, Picarima H, Manyakori C, Sekartuti , et al. (2007) Demographic risk factors for severe and fatal vivax and falciparum malaria among hospital admissions in northeastern Indonesian papua. Am J Trop Med Hyg 77: 984–991.
- 14. Genton B, Al-Yaman F, Beck HP, Hii J, Mellor S, et al. (1995) The epidemiology of malaria in the Wosera area, East Sepik Province, Papua New Guinea, in preparation for vaccine trials. I. Malariometric indices and immunity. Ann Trop Med Parasitol 89: 359–376.
- 15. Kasehagen LJ, Mueller I, McNamara DT, Bockarie MJ, Kiniboro B, et al. (2006) Changing patterns of Plasmodium blood-stage infections in the Wosera region of Papua New Guinea monitored by light microscopy and high throughput PCR diagnosis. Am J Trop Med Hyg 75: 588–596.
- 16. Alpers MP, al Yaman F, Beck HP, Bhatia KK, Hii J, et al. (1992) The Malaria Vaccine Epidemiology and Evaluation Project of Papua New Guinea: rationale and baseline studies. P N G Med J 35: 285–297.
- 17. Genton B, Baea K, Lorry K, Ginny M, Wines B, et al. (2005) Parasitological and clinical efficacy of standard treatment regimens against Plasmodium falciparum, P. vivax and P. malariae in Papua New Guinea. P N G Med J 48: 141–150.
- 18. Marfurt J, Mueller I, Sie A, Maku P, Goroti M, et al. (2007) Low efficacy of amodiaquine or chloroquine plus sulfadoxine-pyrimethamine against Plasmodium falciparum and P. vivax malaria in Papua New Guinea. Am J Trop Med Hyg 77: 947–954.
- 19. Genton B, Smith T, Baea K, Narara A, Al-Yaman F, et al. (1994) Malaria: how useful are clinical criteria for improving the diagnosis in a highly endemic area. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 88: 537–541.
- 20. Genton B, Al-Yaman F, Beck HP, Hii J, Mellor S, et al. (1995) The epidemiology of malaria in the Wosera area, East Sepik Province, Papua New Guinea, in preparation for vaccine trials. II. Mortality and morbidity. Ann Trop Med Parasitol 89: 377–390.
- 21. World Health Organization (2000) Severe falciparum malaria. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 94(Supplement 1 and published correction): 1–31.
- 22. Moorthy VS, Reed Z, Smith PG (2007) Measurement of malaria vaccine efficacy in phase III trials: report of a WHO consultation. Vaccine 25: 5115–5123. on behalf of the WHO Group on Measures of Malaria Vaccine Efficacy.
- 23. Allen SJ, O'Donnell A, Alexander ND, Clegg JB (1996) Severe malaria in children in Papua New Guinea. QJM 89: 779–788.
- 24. Michon P, Cole-Tobian JL, Dabod E, Schoepflin S, Igu J, et al. (2007) The risk of malarial infections and disease in Papua New Guinean children. Am J Trop Med Hyg 76: 997–1008.
- 25. Chow S, Rodgers P (2008) Applet For Drawing 3 Set Area-Proportional Venn Diagrams. Available: http://www.cs.kent.ac.uk/people/staff/pjr/EulerVennCircles/EulerVennApplet.html. Accessed 17 May 2008.
- 26. Marsh K, Forster D, Waruiru C, Mwangi I, Winstanley M, et al. (1995) Indicators of life-threatening malaria in African children. N Engl J Med 332: 1399–1404.
- 27. Reyburn H, Mbatia R, Drakeley C, Bruce J, Carneiro I, et al. (2005) Association of transmission intensity and age with clinical manifestations and case fatality of severe Plasmodium falciparum malaria. JAMA 293: 1461–1470.
- 28. Tjitra E, Anstey NM, Sugiarto P, Warikar N, Kenangalem E, et al. (2007) Multidrug-resistant Plasmodium vivax malaria associated with high morbidity and mortality. PLoS Med 5: e128. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.0050128.
- 29. Ratcliff A, Siswantoro H, Kenangalem E, Maristela R, Wuwung RM, et al. (2007) Two fixed-dose artemisinin combinations for drug-resistant falciparum and vivax malaria in Papua, Indonesia: an open-label randomised comparison. Lancet 369: 757–765.
- 30. Tjitra E, Baker J, Suprianto S, Cheng Q, Anstey NM (2002) Therapeutic efficacies of artesunate-sulfadoxine-pyrimethamine and chloroquine-sulfadoxine-pyrimethamine in vivax malaria pilot studies: relationship to Plasmodium vivax dhfr mutations. Antimicrob Agents Chemother 46: 3947–3953.
- 31. Anstey NM, Handojo T, Pain MC, Kenangalem E, Tjitra E, et al. (2007) Lung injury in vivax malaria: pathophysiological evidence for pulmonary vascular sequestration and posttreatment alveolar-capillary inflammation. J Infect Dis 195: 589–596.
- 32. Mackintosh CL, Beeson JG, Marsh K (2004) Clinical features and pathogenesis of severe malaria. Trends Parasitol 20: 597–603.
- 33. Price RN, Simpson JA, Nosten F, Luxemburger C, Hkirjaroen L, et al. (2001) Factors contributing to anemia after uncomplicated falciparum malaria. Am J Trop Med Hyg 65: 614–622.
- 34. Gopinathan VP, Subramanian AR (1986) Vivax and falciparum malaria seen at an Indian service hospital. J Trop Med Hyg 89: 51–55.
- 35. Lyn PC (1987) Cerebral malaria and mixed falciparum-vivax infections. Ann Acad Med Singapore 16: 310–312.
- 36. Smith T, Genton B, Baea K, Gibson N, Narara A, et al. (2001) Prospective risk of morbidity in relation to malaria infection in an area of high endemicity of multiple species of Plasmodium. Am J Trop Med Hyg 64: 262–267.
- 37. Schellenberg D, Menendez C, Kahigwa E, Font F, Galindo C, et al. (1999) African children with malaria in an area of intense Plasmodium falciparum transmission: features on admission to the hospital and risk factors for death. Am J Trop Med Hyg 61: 431–438.
- 38. Felger I, Tavul L, Narara A, Genton B, Alpers M, et al. (1995) The use of the polymerase chain reaction for more sensitive detection of Plasmodium falciparum. P N G Med J 38: 52–56.
- 39. Mehlotra RK, Kasehagen LJ, Baisor M, Lorry K, Kazura JW, et al. (2002) Malaria infections are randomly distributed in diverse holoendemic areas of Papua New Guinea. Am J Trop Med Hyg 67: 555–562.
- 40. Smith T, Genton B, Baea K, Gibson N, Taime J, et al. (1994) Relationships between Plasmodium falciparum infection and morbidity in a highly endemic area. Parasitology 109: 539–549.
- 41. Bronzan RN, Taylor TE, Mwenechanya J, Tembo M, Kayira K, et al. (2007) Bacteremia in Malawian children with severe malaria: prevalence, etiology, HIV coinfection, and outcome. J Infect Dis 195: 895–904.
- 42. Berkley JA, Maitland K, Mwangi I, Ngetsa C, Mwarumba S, et al. (2005) Use of clinical syndromes to target antibiotic prescribing in seriously ill children in malaria endemic area: observational study. BMJ 330: 995.
- 43. Evans JA, Adusei A, Timmann C, May J, Mack D, et al. (2004) High mortality of infant bacteraemia clinically indistinguishable from severe malaria. QJM 97: 591–597.
- 44. Berkley J, Mwarumba S, Bramham K, Lowe B, Marsh K (1999) Bacteraemia complicating severe malaria in children. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 93: 283–286.