Citation:Fowler MG (2008) Further Evidence that Exclusive Breast-Feeding Reduces Mother-to-Child HIV Transmission Compared With Mixed Feeding. PLoS Med 5(3): e63. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.0050063
Published: March 11, 2008
Copyright: © 2008 Mary Glenn Fowler. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: The author received no specific funding for this article.
Competing interests: The author has declared that no competing interests exist.
Abbreviations: HAART, highly active antiretroviral therapy;WHO, World Health Organization;ZEBS, Zambia Exclusive Breastfeeding Study
The critical role of breast-feeding in improving infant and under-five-year survival in resource-limited settings has been well documented since the mid-1970s. A pooled analysis by the World Health Organization (WHO) of a number of studies on the impact of breast-feeding on child survival showed that the protective effect is strongest in the first six months of life, with a 4–6-fold survival benefit for breast-fed infants . The benefit extends throughout the first year of life, with a 1.4–1.8-fold protective effect against mortality during months six through twelve .
Balancing the Benefits and Risks of Breast-Feeding
With the emergence of the global HIV pandemic, prevention of mother-to-child transmission became an early research focus. The risk of transmission of HIV through breast-feeding was documented by observational studies from both developed and developing countries [2,3]. After the first one to two months of breast-feeding, where the risk of transmission is particularly high, several studies reported a continual sustained risk of infants becoming infected of between 0.6%–0.9% per month [3,4] during later breast-feeding. Studies also reported a cumulative absolute risk of 12%–16% postnatal transmission due to breast milk exposure when breast-feeding is extended to 18–24 months [5,6].
In resource-limited settings, balancing the general benefits of breast-feeding against the low but ongoing risk of HIV transmission has been a major dilemma for perinatal HIV researchers, policy makers, and most importantly, for HIV-infected women. In these settings, breast-feeding is the cultural norm, and to not breast-feed may lead to disclosure of a woman's HIV status. Given these realities, HIV-infected women have to make the difficult choice as to whether to expose their baby to a potentially fatal viral infection or whether to place their infant at risk for early death due to malnutrition and other infectious diseases if they opt not to breast-feed.
Linked Research Article
This Perspective discusses the following study published in PLoS ONE:
Kuhn L, Sinkala M, Kankasa C, Semrau K, Kasonde P, et al. (2007) High uptake of exclusive breastfeeding and reduced early postnatal HIV transmission. PLoS ONE 2(12): e1363. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0001363
Initial research efforts addressing breast milk transmission focused on epidemiologic studies to delineate risk factors for transmission during breast-feeding. A number of these risk factors are now known and include increased maternal viral load and clinical disease status , mastitis and local breast disease [8,9], duration of breast-feeding , and mixed feeding (i.e., adding other foods and liquids to the infant's diet in addition to breast milk) in the first months of life [10–12].
Since the late 1990s, observational studies nested within trials also suggested a protective role for exclusive breast-feeding against HIV transmission. The initial study from South Africa  did not indicate a statistically significant protective effect of early exclusive breast-feeding after controlling for maternal risk factors. Subsequently, however, several other studies have suggested a strong and statistically significant protective effect of exclusive breast-feeding for the first three to six months of life compared with mixed feeding in reducing the risk of postnatal transmission, an effect that was sustained and which translated into a long-term reduction in overall transmission [11,12]. But there were still several limitations in these studies in terms of sample size, the inability to fully control for maternal virologic and immunologic factors, and the difficulty in validating actual infant feeding practices, since most data on infant feeding were based on maternal self-report.
The Zambia Exclusive Breastfeeding Study
The carefully executed, prospective Zambia Exclusive Breastfeeding Study (ZEBS) by Louise Kuhn and colleagues, published recently in PLoS ONE, was carried out in Lusaka, Zambia from 2001–2004 . While the ZEBS data on infant feeding and transmission outcomes are based on observational data, the relatively large sample size and the prospective design helped to address a number of the limitations of the earlier studies. The ZEBS analyses aimed a priori to test the hypothesis that exclusive breast-feeding was related to a reduction in transmission during the first months of life when compared with other types of infant feeding. The study also assessed the feasibility of intensive counseling to achieve high uptake of exclusive breast-feeding throughout the first four to six months of life. The findings add to and strengthen our understanding of the role of exclusive breast-feeding in protecting HIV-exposed infants against early postnatal HIV transmission.
The analyses used infant feeding and infant outcome data on 958 infants born to HIV-infected women who were encouraged to exclusively breast-feed for four months. The data were gathered as part of a randomized clinical trial assessing infant HIV infection and HIV-free survival outcomes in the first 24 months among infants born to HIV-infected mothers. In this trial, mothers were randomly assigned either to early cessation of exclusive breast-feeding by four months or to continued breast-feeding generally into the second year of life and gradual introduction of other foods. Serial maternal immunologic markers (CD4 and CD8 counts) were collected, together with hemoglobin and viral load.
Infant feeding data included frequent gathering of detailed infant dietary history questionnaires and home observations. Infant real-time HIV testing by polymerase chain reaction was also done at frequent intervals, allowing close ascertainment of the timing of transmission. Statistical analyses were robust (Kaplan-Meier time-to-event survival analyses as well as Cox proportional hazards models), which allowed the investigators to assess the independent role of early exclusive breast-feeding on transmission risk while also controlling for key independent variables known to be associated with mother-to-child HIV transmission. Age-specific hazard ratios were generated from months four to 24 based on infant feeding patterns.
The ZEBS findings on early infant feeding patterns and HIV outcomes are informative both for health programmers and researchers. First, the study shows that extremely high levels of exclusive breast-feeding (84%) in the first four to six months of life can be achieved with effective counseling of mothers. Second, the study documents a substantial early protective role for exclusive breast-feeding against early HIV transmission: there was a 3.5–4-fold increased hazard of infant infection by age four months among those infants who were not exclusively breast-fed compared with those who were. Third, the study found that the vast majority (86%) of early transmissions occurred among women who had lower CD4 counts. These findings would suggest that more liberal use of highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART) among lactating women with CD4 counts less than 350 cells/mm3 should substantially reduce early transmissions through breast milk.
Implications of the New Study
There are a number of implications of these findings for clinical practitioners, researchers, and policy makers alike.
1. Exclusive breast-feeding in the first four to six months of life is feasible for most women and can be achieved by providing strong and consistent counseling messages.
2. Given its early protective overall health benefit, in addition to providing protection against HIV transmission compared to mixed feeding, exclusive breast-feeding should be strongly promoted by policy makers as part of baby-friendly maternal and child health services. Such promotion should be aimed both at HIV negative-women and those HIV-positive women in resource-limited settings for whom alternatives to breast-feeding (e.g., use of formula feeding) are not safe, feasible, or culturally acceptable.
3. To achieve this goal, adequate resources must be allocated for training of maternal child health staff to provide counseling messages that promote exclusive breast-feeding throughout the first six months of life. There needs to be sufficient funding for adequate staffing given the high volumes using such services.
4. More liberal treatment guidelines supporting sustained maternal HAART for women with CD4 counts under 350 cells/mm3 throughout lactation could potentially both improve maternal health and also significantly reduce the risk of transmission during breast-feeding.
For programs aimed at preventing mother-to-child transmission of HIV, the encouraging data from the ZEBS on the protective role of exclusive breast-feeding reaffirm the need to promote exclusive breast-feeding for the majority of HIV-infected women in resource-limited settings throughout the first six months. This recommendation is based on 2001 guidance from WHO and UNICEF that exclusive breast-feeding should be supported in the first months of life unless “AFASS” criteria are met for replacement feeding: i.e., unless replacement feeding is “acceptable, feasible, affordable, sustainable, and safe” . Counseling on infant feeding for newly delivered HIV-infected women should emphasize the importance of exclusive breast-feeding for at least six months unless the AFASS criteria are met. Women should be reassessed at six months after delivery to see if they can safely cease breast-feeding or whether instead they should continue breast-feeding with introduction of complementary foods. WHO has recently come out with updated HIV and Infant Feeding Guidelines that consider the ZEBS data as well as other new findings .
For researchers, one key question is how to make breast-feeding safer for HIV-exposed infants while preserving the protective infant survival benefits of breast-feeding. Several clinical trials are underway addressing the possible role of antiretrovirals used either for infant prophylaxis or given to HIV-infected women during pregnancy as well as postpartum during the first six months of lactation. Future clinical trials being planned will assess extended prophylaxis throughout the entire breast-feeding period. Another area for research would be the development of an efficacious prophylactic infant HIV vaccine that could allow HIV-exposed infants to receive the nutritional and immunologic benefits of breast-feeding while effectively reducing their risk of acquiring HIV through prolonged breast-feeding.
Overall, these findings from the ZEBS study are reassuring, and reinforce the earlier results from Zimbabwe and South Africa on the protective effect of exclusive breast-feeding not only on infant survival but also in reducing the risk of postnatal transmission.
- 1. WHO Collaborative Study Team on the Role of Breastfeeding on the Prevention of Infant Mortality (2000) Effect of breastfeeding on infant and child mortality due to infectious disease in less developed countries: A pooled analysis. Lancet 355: 451–455.
- 2. Dunn DT,Newell ML,Ades AE,Peckham CS (1992) Risk of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 transmission through breastfeeding. Lancet 340: 585–588.
- 3. Miotti PG,Taha TE,Kumwenda NI,Broadhead R,Mtimavalye LA,et al. (1999) HIV transmission through breastfeeding: A study in Malawi. JAMA 282: 744–749.
- 4. BHITS: Breastfeeding and HIV International Transmission Study Group (2005) Late postnatal transmission of HIV-1 in breast-fed children: an individual patient data meta-analysis. J Infect Dis 189: 2154–2166.
- 5. Nduati R,John G,Mbori-Ngacha D,Richardson B,Overbaugh J,et al. (2000) Effect of breastfeeding and formula feeding on transmission of HIV-1: A randomized clinical trial. JAMA 283: 1167–1174.
- 6. DeCock KM,Fowler MG,Mercier E,de Vincenzi I,Saba J,et al. (2000) Prevention of mother-to-child HIV transmission in resource-poor countries: Translating research into policy and practice. JAMA 283: 1175–1182.
- 7. John GC,Nduati RW,Mbori-Ngacha DA,Richardson BA,Panteleeff D,et al. (2001) Correlates of mother-to-child human immunodeficiency virus type1 (HIV-1) transmission: Association with maternal plasma HIV-1 RNA load, genital HIV-1 DNA shedding and breast infections. J Infect Dis 183: 206–212.
- 8. Semba RD,Kumwenda N,Hoover DR,Taha TE,Quinn TC,et al. (1999) Human immunodeficiency virus load in breast milk, mastitis, and mother-to-child transmission of human immunodeficiency virus type 1. J Infec Dis 180: 93–98.
- 9. Embree JE,Njenga S,Datta P,Nagelkerke NJ,Ndinya-Achola JO,et al. (2000) Risk factors for postnatal mother-child transmission of HIV-1. AIDS 14: 2535–2541.
- 10. Coutsoudis A,Pillay K,Spooner E,Kuhn L,Coovadia HM (1999) Influence of infant feeding patterns on early mother to child transmission of HIV-1 in Durban, South Africa: A prospective cohort study. South African Vitamin A Study Group. Lancet 354: 471–476.
- 11. Iliff PJ,Piwoz EG,Tavengwa NV,Zunguza CD,Marinda ET,et al. (2005) Early exclusive breast feeding reduces the risk of postnatal HIV transmission and increases HIV-free survival. AIDS 19: 699–708.
- 12. Coovadia HM,Rollins NC,Bland RM,Little K,Coutsoudis A,et al. (2007) Mother-to-child transmission of HIV-1 infection during exclusive breastfeeding in the first 6 months of life: An intervention cohort study. Lancet 369: 1107–1116.
- 13. Kuhn L,Sinkala M,Kankasa C,Semrau K,Kasonde P,et al. (2007) High uptake of exclusive breastfeeding and reduced early post-natal HIV transmission. PLoS ONE 2: e1363. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0001363.
- 14. World Health Organization (2001) New data on the prevention of mother-to-child transmission of HIV and their policy implications. Available: http://www.who.int/reproductive-health/publications/new_data_prevention_mtct_hiv/index.html. Accessed 31 January 2008.
- 15. World Health Organization (2006) HIV and infant feeding. New evidence and programmatic experience. Report of a Technical Consultation held on behalf of the Inter-agency Task Team (IAT) on prevention of HIV infections in pregnant women, mothers and their infants. Geneva, Switzerland 25–27, 2006.