We have taken an engineering approach to extending the lifespan of Caenorhabditis elegans. Aging stands out as a complex trait, because events that occur in old animals are not under strong natural selection. As a result, lifespan can be lengthened rationally using bioengineering to modulate gene expression or to add exogenous components. Here, we engineered longer lifespan by expressing genes from zebrafish encoding molecular functions not normally present in worms. Additionally, we extended lifespan by increasing the activity of four endogenous worm aging pathways. Next, we used a modular approach to extend lifespan by combining components. Finally, we used cell- and worm-based assays to analyze changes in cell physiology and as a rapid means to evaluate whether multi-component transgenic lines were likely to have extended longevity. Using engineering to add novel functions and to tune endogenous functions provides a new framework for lifespan extension that goes beyond the constraints of the worm genome.
We used bioengineering to extend the lifespan of C. elegans by expressing genes acting in critical aging pathways. We overexpressed five genes that act in endogenous worm aging pathways, as well as two genes from zebrafish encoding molecular functions not normally present in worms. For example, we used zebrafish genes to alter mitochondrial function and innate immunity in ways not normally available to C. elegans and extended worm lifespan by ∼40%. Next, we used a modular approach to extend lifespan by 130% by combining up to four components in the same strain. These results provide a platform to build worms having progressively longer lifespans. This project is conceptually similar to using engineering to increase the useful lifespan of a primitive machine (1931 Model T) using both parts from the model T as well as parts from a more advanced machine (2012 Toyota Corolla). Our results open the door to use engineering to go beyond the constraints of the C. elegans genome to extend its lifespan by adding non-native components.
Citation: Sagi D, Kim SK (2012) An Engineering Approach to Extending Lifespan in C. elegans. PLoS Genet 8(6): e1002780. doi:10.1371/journal.pgen.1002780
Editor: Gary Ruvkun, Massachusetts General Hospital and Harvard Medical School, United States of America
Received: February 14, 2012; Accepted: May 8, 2012; Published: June 21, 2012
Copyright: © 2012 Sagi, Kim. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work was funded by R01AG025941 to SKK and the Larry L. Hillblom fellowship to DS. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Recent advances in genome technology and systems biology have made it possible to use engineering approaches to create new biological systems. Examples include the construction of a synthetic genetic oscillator in bacteria , engineering quorum sensing (the ability to respond to population density) in yeast by integrating signaling components from the plant A. thaliana , and creating an artificial bacterial cell using a genome consisting only of chemically-synthesized DNA . Here, we expand bioengineering to a complex phenotype, longevity, in a multicellular animal, C. elegans.
Despite being extremely complex, aging has at least three features that make it an attractive trait to improve by engineering. First, many pathways are involved in aging, such as stress response, repair of oxidative damage, protein quality control, developmental drift and innate immune response to pathogens –. The diverse nature of these aging pathways allows multiple avenues to engineer changes that may extend lifespan. Second, there is a great diversity in lifespan between different species, from two weeks for C. elegans, to 80 years for humans, to over 200 years for whales or clams –. This observation shows the remarkable dynamic range of over a thousand fold in lifespan encoded by different genomes. Third, most animals in the wild (including C. elegans) die from predation and disease rather than old age –. Thus, aging is not under the force of natural selection and represents the system-wide degeneration of processes due to evolutionary neglect. As a result, an engineering approach to slow aging seems more feasible than engineering improvements in other biological processes (e.g. development) because it may be easier to repair damaged processes in old animals rather than to improve highly-functional pathways in young animals.
We chose to use C. elegans because it has a short lifespan of two weeks and a strong genetic toolkit making it a good platform for engineering longer lifespan. We first used a variety of approaches to identify genes with well-characterized roles in critical aging pathways that can be used as components to extend lifespan in transgenic worms. In particular, we were able to extend lifespan by expressing genes from zebrafish with cellular functions that are not normally found in worms. Having created a list of components that each extends lifespan singly, we then used a modular approach to increase lifespan by increments. We generated transgenic worms that contain an increasing number of aging components, and showed that there was a corresponding increase in lifespan.
The framework and goal of our engineering approach to aging are fundamentally different from those in a study of the biology of aging. The main goal of our approach is to add components in order to extend the worm lifespan without a direct need to understand the mechanisms underlying this lifespan extension. For example, our modular approach aims to combine lifespan-extending components without aiming to determine whether these components act in the same or in different pathways. Additionally, in our engineering approach, we are not constrained to genes or pathways derived only from the worm genome. Rather, we can use novel molecular functions derived from long-lived organisms in order to extend worm lifespan.
Four approaches to identifying components that individually extend lifespan
Our goal is to use an engineering approach to generate C. elegans strains that are long-lived but that develop normally, are fertile, and are generally healthy. We began by accumulating a set of genes that individually extend lifespan. The first and easiest way to obtain an aging component is to select genes that have already been shown to extend lifespan when overexpressed; we generated expression vectors for four such genes (hsf-1, activated aakg-2, sod-1, daf-16) –. Transgenic worms were generated by microinjection of the gene of interest, a co-transformation marker (unc-119(+)) and an aging biomarker (sod-3::mCherry). We compared the lifespan for each of the transgenic strains to the lifespan from a control transgenic strain containing unc-119(+) and sod-3::mCherry alone (see Table S1 for complete list of components). In most cases, we generated two separate transgenic strains and measured their lifespan to verify reproducibility.
Three of the genes (hsf-1, activated aakg-2, sod-1) showed extended lifespan. hsf-1 encodes heat shock transcription factor that induces expression of many stress-resistance genes that can extend lifespan . aakg-2 encodes the gamma subunit of AMP-activated protein kinase, a regulatory signaling molecule that responds to low ATP/AMP ratios and plays a key role in the stress response . sod-1 encodes cytosolic superoxide dismutase that catalyzes the dismutation of superoxide radicals (O2−) into hydrogen peroxide , which could reduce damage accumulation and extend lifespan. Consistent with previous results –, we found that overexpression of hsf-1, activated aakg-2 and sod-1 extended lifespan by ∼30%, ∼45%, and 25%, respectively (Figure 1a–1c, Table 1, Table S3).
a. Worm hsf-1. x-axis shows lifespan in days of adulthood. y-axis shows fraction of worms alive. Control refers to transgenic worms expressing unc-119(+); sod-3::mCherry. Worms overexpressing C. elegans hsf-1 live 35% longer than controls (p<0.01, log-rank). b. C. elegans expressing aakg-2(sta2) live 45% longer than controls (p<0.01, log-rank). c. Worms overexpressing C. elegans sod-1 live 25% longer than the control strain (p<0.01, log rank). d. Worms overexpressing C. elegans lmp-2 live 34% longer than controls (p<0.01, log-rank). e. Expression of zebrafish sod1 results in 25% lifespan extension relative to control strain (p<0.01, log rank). f. Expression of zebrafish ucp2 results in 40% lifespan extension relative to control strain (p<0.01, log rank). Overexpression of C. elegans ucp-4 does not show longer lifespan (p>0.05, log-rank). g. Worms expressing zebrafish lyz live 30% longer than control (p<0.01, log rank), whereas expression of C. elegans lys-1 does not result in longer lifespan (p>0.05, log rank). The median lifespan of the control is 18 days. Each experiment was repeated at least three times and representative data from one experiment is shown. Additional data are listed in Table S3.
The second way to obtain an aging component is a candidate gene approach using C. elegans genes that act in known aging pathways. One such aging pathway is proteostasis, which counteracts damage accumulation to proteins by removing old, damaged proteins –. Increasing the rate of protein turnover should lower accumulation of damaged proteins and may extend lifespan . We overexpressed a gene involved in chaperone-mediated autophagy (lmp-2)  and a gene involved in proteostasis (uba-1). We found that that lmp-2 but not uba-1 resulted in extended lifespan compared to a control strain (Figure 1d, Table 1, Table S3). lmp-2 is the ortholog of mammalian lamp2A, which encodes the lysosome-associated membrane protein type 2A receptor involved in chaperone-mediated autophagy that is responsible for the degradation of approximately 30% of cytosolic proteins in conditions of stress . Overexpression of lamp2A in old mice results in lower intracellular accumulation of damaged proteins and improved organ function .
The third approach was expressing orthologous genes from either the zebrafish or the human genome that act in known aging pathways. We selected genes from zebrafish and humans as they have much longer lifespans than worms (4 years or 80 years vs 2 weeks, respectively) , , . We expected that vertebrate genes from aging pathways may be more efficient at delaying aging than orthologous genes from worms. Furthermore, zebrafish live at a similar range of temperatures as C. elegans and therefore zebrafish proteins should be capable of functioning at the ambient temperature used to grow worms (20°C).
We selected four zebrafish and one human gene that are orthologous to C. elegans genes that act in known aging pathways: D. rerio sod1, D. rerio msra, D. rerio foxo3A, D. rerio psmb1 and human aldh2. We used upstream regions from C. elegans genes that were homologous to the zebrafish gene to drive expression of zebrafish cDNAs. For each construct, we generated transgenic worms and measured their lifespan under normal growth conditions. Of the five genes tested, only expression of D. rerio sod1 in transgenic worms resulted in longer lifespan than a control strain (Figure 1e, Table 1, Table S3). D. rerio sod1 encodes superoxide dismutase and is the ortholog of C. elegans sod-1. D. rerio sod1 and C. elegans sod-1 extended lifespan to a similar extent.
The fourth approach to find an aging component was to select zebrafish genes with functions that are absent from the worm genome, and test whether adding them to worms can have a beneficial effect. One such function is mitochondrial uncoupling, which allows protons to leak into mitochondria without producing ATP . According to the uncoupling to survive hypothesis, mitochondrial proton leakage may be beneficial because reduction of the proton motive force should reduce production of reactive oxygen species and thereby reduce damage accumulation during aging . We chose to introduce mitochondrial uncoupling activity into worms using the zebrafish ucp2 gene, which encodes one of the mitochondrial uncoupling proteins. A similar experiment to add human ucp2 to Drosophila has been done previously, although it is not clear whether Drosophila has endogenous uncoupling activity and thus it is unclear if this previous experiment involves adding a new function to Drosophila .
The evolutionary tree for ucp genes shows that ucp-4 is the most ancient, contained in the genomes of all animals (Figure S1a). Worms contain only a single related gene (ucp-4) that encodes a protein that does not have mitochondrial uncoupling activity but rather is a transporter for succinate –.
We generated transgenic worms that express zebrafish ucp2 from the worm ucp-4 promoter. As a control, we also generated worms that overexpress worm ucp-4. We found that expression of zebrafish ucp2 extended the median lifespan of worms by about 40% (Figure 1f, Table 1, Table S3). In contrast, overexpression of worm ucp-4 did not extend lifespan in two independent transgenic strains (Figure 1f, Table S2).
Another example of new functionality added to the worm is the addition of vertebrate lysozyme activity. Worm lifespan is limited by mild pathogenic effects from E. coli, which is used as a standard food source –. All lysozymes have bacterial cell wall hydrolase activity that degrades peptidoglycans and thus are key players of the innate immune defense system providing protection against bacterial pathogens . There are ten lysozyme genes in C. elegans, all belonging to a clade shared with microbes such as D. discoideum and E. histolytica (Figure S1b). Vertebrates contain a large number of lysozyme genes, including a second clade that is derived solely from metazoans. Lysozyme genes from this clade contain a distinct anti-bacterial activity besides cell wall hydolase activity, which involves direct interaction of lysozyme with the bacterial cell membrane resulting in membrane leakage .
We generated transgenic worms expressing a zebrafish lysozyme gene from the second clade (lyz). We found that zebrafish lyz extended the median lifespan of worms by about 30% (Figure 1g, Table 1, Table S3). In contrast to D. rerio lyz, overexpression of worm lys-1 did not extend lifespan in two independent transgenic strains (Figure 1g, Table S2), consistent with previously published results .
Effects of aging components on worm and cell physiology
We used various worm- and cell-based assays to validate that the aging components were expressed and to determine what changes in cell physiology and stress were induced. One reason for this is to provide evidence that the aging components extended lifespan by the expected mechanism. Since we tested each of the seven aging components with each of the assays, another reason is to also determine whether the aging component induced unexpected changes in cell physiology, which might indicate indirect activation of secondary aging pathways. A third reason is that the cellular assays could be used as a rapid and practical means to identify transgenic worms that are likely to have extended lifespan.
To examine expression of the transgenes, we performed RT-PCR experiments using RNA extracted from fourth larval stage hermaphrodites. We found that the three vertebrate genes were expressed and that the four worm aging genes were over-expressed 5–18 fold in the transgenic strains compared to the endogenous gene in the control strain (Table S4).
ATP production by the mitochondria is directly related to the production of reactive oxygen species and damage accumulation. Furthermore, ATP levels is thought to be associated with dietary restriction and the subsequent induction of protective pathways –. We measured ATP levels in extracts from fourth larval stage worms for each of the transgenic worms and found that worms expressing ucp2 or aakg-2(sta2) had lower overall levels of ATP compared to controls (Figure 2a). Uncoupling protein would be expected to lower ATP levels by lowering the proton gradient in mitochondria, and thus lowering ATP production. Our results are consistent with previous experiments showing that vertebrate ucp2 genes have mitochondrial uncoupling activity when expressed in yeast and in flies , –. Activation of AMPK is thought to increase catabolic pathways that generate ATP while decreasing ATP-consuming processes . Thus, aakg-2(sta2) transgenic worms were expected to have increased ATP levels, opposite to the observed result.
a. Levels of total ATP in extracts from L4 stage hermaphrodites. ATP levels were measured using a luciferase bioluminescent assay. y-axis shows ATP levels (nmoles per mg of protein). * indicates p<0.01, t-test. Error bars are SEM of three independent experiments. Red bar indicates transgenic line expected to show decreased level of ATP. b. B. subtilis does not extend the lifespan of worms expressing D. rerio lyz. Worms expressing D. rerio lyz live longer than control strains when grown on E. coli (p<0.01, log-rank) but not when they are grown on B. subtilis (p>0.05, log rank). Shown are representative data from one of six experiments. At least 80 worms were score in each experiment. Additional data are in Table S4. c. Induction of hsp-16.2 and hsp-16.11 in worms expressing either C. elegans hsf-1 or C. elegans aakg-2(sta2). y-axis shows normalized RNA levels of either hsp-16.11 or hsp-16.2 relative to control, measured by qPCR. Error bars are SEM of three independent experiments. Each bar represents transgenic worms expressing the corresponding gene. * indicates p<0.01 (t-test) for both hsps . Red text indicates transgenic line expected to show increased expression of hsp-16.2 and hsp-16.11. d. Oxidative damage to proteins in long-lived transgenic worms. Oxidative damage levels in worm extracts increase about five fold from young adult (day 1) to old adult (day 14). At 14 days of adulthood, transgenic worms expressing D. rerio ucp2 or C. elegans hsf-1 have less damage (*, p<0.05, t-test). Oxidative damage to proteins was measured by the Oxiblot method, and is expressed relative to oxidative damage in a control strain in arbitrary units. Each bar represents transgenic worms expressing the corresponding gene. Error bars are SEM of three independent experiments. Red bars indicate transgenic lines expected to show decreased levels of oxidative protein damage. e. Expression of sod-3::mCherry. Worms expressing C. elegans hsf-1 or C. elegans aakg-2(sta2) show higher expression (p<0.01, t-test) and worms expressing D. rerio lyz show lower expression (p<0.01, t-test) of sod-3::mCherry. y-axis show fluorescence in arbitrary units. Error bars are SEM of three independent experiments. Each bar represents transgenic worms expressing the corresponding gene. Red bar indicates transgenic line expected to show increased expression of sod-3::mCherry. Ce – C. elegans, Dr – D. rerio.
Lysozymes are anti-bacterial enzymes that could extend lifespan by combating bacterial pathogenicity. If lysozyme acts by combating mild pathogenicity stemming from E. coli, then it should not be able to extend lifespan when worms are grown on non-pathogenic B. subtilis. We determined the lifespan of control and lyz transgenic worms when grown on B. subtilis, and found no difference (Figure 2b, Table S5). This result strongly indicates that the mechanism of lifespan extension by zebrafish lysozyme involves combating mild pathogenicity from E. coli.
Mild stress can extend lifespan by inducing protective pathways, a phenomenon referred to as hormesis. We tested for induction of the stress-responsive genes hsp-16.2 and hsp-16.11 using RT-PCR. We found that hsf-1 and aakg-2(sta2) transgenic worms showed higher expression of hsp-16.2 and hsp-16.11 than controls (Figure 2c). hsf-1 but not aakg-2(sta2) was expected to induce expression of stress response genes.
Next, we examined resistance to oxidative damage, which accumulates with age. One way to measure susceptibility to oxidative damage is to measure resistance to oxidative stress from paraquat, a chemical that generates superoxide ions. We found that C. elegans sod-1, zebrafish sod1, aakg-2(sta1) and hsf-1 conferred resistance to paraquat (Table 2). C. elegans sod-1 and zebrafish sod1 encode superoxide dismutase, an enzyme that reduces levels of oxygen free radicals that could directly counteract the effects of paraquat. aakg-2(sta2) and hsf-1 were not expected to affect oxidative damage directly.
Another way to examine oxidative damage in worms is to directly detect oxidized residues in proteins from a whole worm extract in a Western blotting assay. In old worms, ucp2 and hsf-1 worms showed lower levels of oxidative damage compared to controls (Figure 2d). ucp2 could decrease levels of oxidative damage by decreasing the proton motive force in mitochondria and reducing production of reactive oxygen species. Reduced levels of oxidative damage in hsf-1 transgenic worms was not anticipated. C. elegans sod-1 and D. rerio sod1 might be expected to reduce oxidative damage by reducing levels of reactive oxygen species, but neither showed an effect in this assay. Tallying the results from both assays for oxidative damage, we found expected evidence for reduced oxidative damage in three strains (ucp2 and C. elegans sod-1, D. rerio sod1) as well as unanticipated results for two strains (hsf-1 and aakg-2(sta2)).
We next examined activation of the FOXO transcription factor DAF-16, which is a key regulator of aging . Activation of DAF-16 can be measured by expression of a sod-3 reporter gene, which is one of its downstream targets . We compared the level of expression of a sod-3::mCherry reporter in each of the seven long-lived worms to control worms in middle-aged hermaphrodites. We observed that aakg-2(sta2) and hsf-1 transgenic worms showed increased expression of sod-3::mCherry whereas zebrafish lyz showed decreased expression (Figure 2e). aakg-2 encodes a kinase that phosphorylates DAF-16, and would be expected to induce sod-3 expression , . For zebrafish lyz, one possibility is that lysozyme could reduce pathogenicity from E. coli used as food. Mild pathogenicity is known to activate DAF-16 and induce expression of the downstream target sod-3.
Lastly, lower ATP levels in ucp2 transgenic worms might extend lifespan using mechanisms shared by dietary restriction. If so, then worms that receive both dietary restriction and ucp2 might not live longer than worms receiving either condition alone. We found that dietary restriction alone extended median lifespan 18%, ucp2 alone extended lifespan 40% and that dietary restriction of ucp2 worms extended lifespan 40% compared to controls (Figure 3a, Table S6). Thus, dietary restriction did not further extend the lifespan of ucp2 worms that were fed normally.
(a) D. rerio ucp2, (b) C. elegans aakg-2(sta2), and (c) Dual-1 strains. y-axis shows fraction of worms alive, x-axis shows lifespan of synchronized worms starting from adulthood. Dr – D. rerio. Control refers to an unc-119(+); sod-3::mCherry strain. sDR indicates feeding on plates with 108 CFU. AL indicates feeding on plates seeded with 1011 CFU. Control worms on sDR live 18% longer than control worms on AL (p<0.01, log rank). A second independent assay showed similar results to those shown (Table S5).
Table 3 provides a summary of the results from the seven cell- and worm-based assays using the seven transgenic lines expressing aging components. Except for lmp-2, we obtained either direct or indirect evidence that each of the components was expressed and acting as expected. Furthermore, we also obtained evidence that some aging components produced changes in cell pathways that were indirect, providing evidence for cross-talk between different aging pathways in C. elegans. For example, the aakg-2(sta2) strain also shows induction of the two hsp protein chaperones that function in a protective stress pathway.
Extension of lifespan does not necessarily affect brood size
According to the disposable soma theory, evolution of organisms in the wild requires a balance between allocation of metabolic resources for somatic maintenance or reproduction . We tested whether there was a reduction in brood size in our engineered strains. Five transgenic strains with long lifespan had similar brood size and two showed a decrease in fertility compared to the control strains (Figure S2). These results show that the aging components can extend lifespan without reducing fertility.
Using a modular approach to progressively increase lifespan
The seven aging components are individually capable of extending lifespan 25–50%. Because aging is a complex phenomenon affected by many pathways, our strategy to extend lifespan further was to use a modular approach by combining different aging components in a single transgenic strain to progressively extend lifespan. Additionally, we needed to develop a scheme to rapidly test whether or not combining genes in a new transgenic strain has a beneficial effect. This is because lifespan analysis requires four weeks for normal worms, and becomes even more tedious as lifespan increases. Our approach was to first use the cell- and worm-based assays described above to rapidly test whether worms expressing multiple aging components show a beneficial effect. Results showing that a multi-component strain shows protective changes in several pathways or stronger effects in a single aging pathway compared to single-components lines would be encouraging that it will live a long time.
We started by generating two transgenic worm strains that each contain two components; one combination (dual-1) contains aakg-2(sta2) and zebrafish ucp2 and the other combination (dual-2) contains hsf-1 and zebrafish lyz (Table 4). These four components include two zebrafish genes that add new functionality to the worm (ucp2 and lyz) and two C. elegans genes that showed the largest increase in lifespan (aakg-2(sta2) and hsf-1). We used qRT-PCR to show that the components in the dual-module worms were expressed at levels equivalent to those from the single-module worms (Table S4).
One reason for choosing the two components in dual-1 was that six assays were affected by either aakg-2(sta2) or ucp2 single-expressing worms, suggesting that this combination might be able to affect a large number of aging pathways. We analyzed dual-1 worms with all six assays to examine changes in cell physiology resulting from expression of the two aging components. For four assays (ATP level, paraquat resistance, oxidative damage and sod-3 expression), the change relative to controls seen for the dual-1 strain was greater than the changes seen with either the aakg-2(sta2) or ucp2 single strains (Figure 4a, 4b, 4d; Table 2). For the dietary restriction assay, the results with dual-1 were similar to aakg-2(sta2) and ucp2 single-module worms; specifically, the lifespan of dual-1 was not further extended by dietary restriction (Figure 3a–3c). For induction of the hsp genes, the dual-1 strain showed a smaller change than the aakg-2(sta2) strain by itself (Figure 4c). Thus, the dual-1 strain showed changes in a greater number of assays than in either of the single-expressing lines, and oftentimes the changes were larger in magnitude.
a. ATP levels for double-, triple-and quadruple-expressing transgenic worms. y-axis shows ATP levels (nmoles) normalized to mg of protein (mean and SEM of three independent experiments). * indicates p<0.01, t-test. b. Fluorescence levels of sod-3::mCherry reporter. y-axis shows fluorescence in arbitrary units from quantitative measurement of 10 worm images using ImageJ. Error bars are SEM of three independent experiments. * indicates p<0.01, t-test. c. Induction of expression of hsp genes. y-axis shows normalized RNA levels measured by qPCR of either hsp-16.11 or hsp-16.2 relative to a control strain (unc-119(ed3); gaEx[unc-119(+); sod-3::mCherry]). Error bars are SEM of three independent experiments. In all cases p<0.01, t-test. d. Oxidative damage to proteins. Oxidative damage levels in old worms (day 14). At 14 days of adulthood, all dual-, triple– and quadruple-expressing transgenic worms have less damage than control worms (*, p<0.05, t-test). Oxidative damage to proteins was measured by the Oxiblot method, and is expressed relative to oxidative damage in a control strain in arbitrary units. Each bar represents transgenic worms expressing the corresponding gene. Error bars are SEM of three independent experiments.
The dual-2 strain contains components (hsf-1 and D. rerio lyz) that showed changes in a total of five cell assays when expressed singly (Table 3). We tested dual-2 in four of the cell assays (paraquat resistance, hsp induction, oxidative damage and sod-3 expression), and saw changes in the first three but not sod-3 expression with respect to control worms (Figure 4a–4d, Table 2). Paraquat resistance was greater in dual-2 than in each of the two single lines, but changes in hsp induction and oxidative damage relative to control worms was less or equivalent to the changes found in the hsf-1 and D. rerio lyz single-module lines (Figure 4c, 4d; Table 2). For sod-3, hsf-1 increases but D. rerio lyz decreases its expression. In dual-2, sod-3 expression is not different than in control worms suggesting that the opposite effects from these two genes cancel out (Figure 4b).
Finally, we measured the lifespan of the dual-expressing lines, and compared them to the lifespan of the single-expressing lines and controls. Two independent dual-1 lines had an increase in median lifespan of ∼80%, compared to an increase of 35–48% from either of the single components (Figure 5a, Table 4, Table S7). Two independent dual-2 lines had an increase in median lifespan of ∼60%, compared to an increase of 28–37% from either of the single components alone (Figure 5b, Table 4, Table S7). These results show that expression of two components can have an additive effect on lifespan.
(a,b,c) y-axis shows fraction of worms alive, x-axis shows days of adulthood. At least 80 worms were scored for each lifespan curve. Shown is one representative lifespan assay for each strain. Lifespan data from three independent assays are shown in Table S7.
We extended the method by generating transgenic lines that each express three components. Specifically, triple-1 was generated based on dual-1 with the addition of D. rerio lyz, and thus contains aakg-2(sta2), D. rerio ucp2 and D. rerio lyz. Triple-2 was based on dual-2 with the addition of aakg-2(sta2), and thus contains hsf-1, D. rerio lyz and aakg-2(sta2). We examined expression of the components in the triple-expressing lines using qRT-PCR, and found that each of the genes in the triple-expressing lines was expressed at levels comparable to those from the corresponding single-expressing line (Table S4).
For triple-1 and triple-2, the three constituent aging components can affect each of the seven assays when expressed individually. We examined triple-1 and triple-2 using five of the cell assays (ATP level, hsp induction, paraquat resistance, oxidative damage and sod-3 expression). Triple-1 and triple-2 showed changes in all five assays with respect to control worms (Figure 4a–4d, Table 2). We then measured the lifespan of the two triple-expressing lines and found that two independent triple-1 lines showed 97–105% increased lifespan and two independent triple-2 lines showed 84–92% increased lifespan (Figure 5a, 5b; Table S7).
Finally, we generated a quadruple-expressing line containing four different components: hsf-1, D. rerio lyz, aakg-2(sta2) and D. rerio ucp2. We measured expression of these genes in the quadruple line to determine if their expression was as high in the quadruple-expressing as in the single-expressing lines. We found that hsf-1 was expressed at a comparable level but that aakg-2(sta2), Dr ucp2 and Dr lyz, were expressed at about 50% of the previous levels (Table S4). The quadruple-expressing line showed changes in all five cell assays with respect to control worms, and was the most resistant to paraquat among all strains (Table 2 and Figure 4a–4d). The lifespan of this quadruple-expressing line was increased 130% compared to control, and this result was verified in a second quadruple-expressing line (125% increased)(Figure 5c, Table S7). Taken together, our results show a monotonic increase in lifespan: single-expressing lines (28–47%), double-expressing lines (57% to 84%), triple-expressing lines (84–105%) and quadruple-expressing lines (125–130%).
Besides living for the longest time of any of the engineered strains, the quadruple also has a long health span. Quadruple worms reach the L4 larval stage in approximately 72 hours, similar to control worms. Young adult quadruple worms appear and move normally when viewed using a dissecting microscope. For control worms, the median lifespan is about 18 days at which point most of the animals still alive show limited mobility. For quadruple worms, the median lifespan is 40 days but most of the surviving animals move well, similar to 14 day-old control worms (Videos S1, S2, S3). These observations indicate that we have extended the time that quadruple worms are mobile and healthy. This is important for lifespan engineering, as one would optimally want to extend the healthy portion over the morbid time at the end of life.
This paper uses an engineering approach to build healthy and long-lived worms. Our approach was to choose genes from well-studied aging pathways that can be used as components to extend lifespan, and then validate that they are active using a variety of molecular and cellular assays. In this initial study, we used four approaches to find seven aging components. In the first approach, three components (hsf-1, aakg-2(sta2) and sod-1) were obvious choices because they were previously known to extend lifespan when overexpressed in worms –. Future genetic studies of aging are likely to reveal many more genes that extend lifespan when overexpressed, each time providing a new aging component.
Secondly, one component was chosen based on prediction from theory; specifically, lmp-2 was selected because it is involved in chaperone-mediated autophagy . Overexpression of this component is expected to increase protein degradation, reduce steady-state levels of protein damage, and thereby extend lifespan. In this case, not only did we generate an aging component that can be used in our study, but we were also able to validate a prediction made from theory and thus provide support for the role of protein turnover in aging.
In the third approach, we used orthologous genes from zebrafish rather than genes from C. elegans. We found D. rerio sod1 and C. elegans sod-1 extended lifespan to a similar extent. It will be interesting to continue to compare orthologous genes from D. rerio and C. elegans in order to determine whether there may be a systematic advantage to selecting genes from a longer-lived species.
Lastly, we showed that we can extend lifespan by expressing new functions in C. elegans. The first function is mitochondrial uncoupling activity, which is absent from C. elegans . Previous work has shown that human ucp2 extends the lifespan of D. melanogaster, although it is not clear whether this involves adding a new activity to flies because it is not known whether flies have an endogenous mitochondrial uncoupling activity . The second novel function is vertebrate lysozyme, which has an additional anti-bacterial function not found in C. elegans lysozymes . We found that worms expressing either uncoupling protein or lysozyme from D. rerio have a longer lifespan than control worms.
Each of the aging components can extend lifespan about 30–50% by themselves. To extend lifespan beyond this amount, we combined four different aging components in the same line and extended lifespan to 130%. As the number of components increases beyond four, lifespan assays will become more time-consuming and less practical. For practical purposes, we showed that we can rapidly use cell- and worm-based assays to assess whether a multi-component strain is a good candidate for extended longevity, before having to perform the lifespan assay itself. There was generally good agreement between the results from the cell assays and lifespan; e.g, high levels of sod-3 expression correlated well with extended lifespan in the multi-component strains. It will be interesting to determine how much further one can extend lifespan by adding additional components. Previous studies have already shown that daf-2 mutant worms that lack a germline have a five-fold increase in longevity . Future engineering efforts may also be able to achieve extreme longevity.
Although data from our cell assays indicate that a certain aging pathway may be active, it is difficult to formally conclude that the observed activity is the cause for longer lifespan. This is because any of the aging components may have an unknown second activity. For instance, our results show that expression of superoxide dismutase results in paraquat resistance, consistent with a reduction in oxidative damage. However, recent evidence suggests that this enzyme extends lifespan not through an oxidative damage pathway but by another undefined mechanism . Whether or not the precise mechanism is reduction of oxidative damage, superoxide dismutase does indeed extend lifespan and serves our purposes as an aging component to engineer longer-lived worms.
This work provides a proof of principle that one can engineer longer lifespan in C. elegans by adding new components. New technologies in DNA construction, increased knowledge of aging pathways, and improved methods to fine-tuning gene expression will add powerful tools to engineering lifespan. For instance, it will soon be possible to synthesize large stretches of DNA containing many genes from any organism, worm or otherwise, in order to express multiple genes from a genetic pathway. For example, the innate immune system of vertebrates is a source of new anti-bacterial proteins that could significantly improve resistance to pathogenicity in C. elegans . Additionally, expression of vertebrate-specific chaperones and mitochondrial proteins in worms may improve their proteostasis and energy balance pathways, respectively –. Adding exogenous components from vertebrates is a powerful strategy that goes beyond the natural constraints of the C. elegans genome to engineer worms with increased lifespan and healthspan.
Materials and Methods
C. elegans genetics
All C. elegans strains were maintained and handled as previously described . 5-fluoro-2′-deoxyuridine (FUDR, Sigma) plates were made by supplementing NGM agar media with 30 µM of FUDR.
Genes from C. elegans used in this study were amplified by PCR from N2 worm genomic DNA. Generation of constructs containing zebrafish or human cDNA used worm upstream regulatory sequence as defined by the promoterome . If the required promoter was not part of promoterome, all intergenic sequence upstream of the gene of interest was used. cDNA of the gene of interest was obtained from Open Biosystems. The 3′ UTR was from the intron-containing unc-54 gene.
Transgenic strains were made by microinjecting unc-119 worms with the gene of interest at 10 ng/µl and PD4H1 (unc119(+); sod3::mCherry)  at 80 ng/µl. To generate transgenic worms containing two or three genes, each of the genes of interest was injected at 10 ng/µl and PD4H1 at 70 ng/µl. sod-3::mCherry is a reporter for daf-16 activity.
Analysis of life span
Life span analyses were conducted on FUDR plates at 20°C as previously described . At least 80 worms were used for each experiment. Age refers to days following adulthood, and p-values were calculated using the log-rank (Mantel-Cox) method. Individuals were excluded from the analysis if their gonad was extruded or if they desiccated by crawling onto the edge of the plate.
Fourth larval stage worms were washed with M9 buffer and pelleted in a centrifuge. RNA was extracted by addition of 500 µl of Trizol (Invitrogen) to 50 µl of worm pellet, followed by six freeze-thaw cycles in liquid nitrogen. RNA extraction was performed according to the Trizol protocol from the manufacturer. Gene expression was determined by reverse transcription of 0.5 µg total RNA with the Superscript III kit (Invitrogen) followed by quantitative PCR analysis on a Step One Plus real time PCR machine (Applied Biosystems) with iQ SYBR green (Bio-Rad) using act-1 RNA as a control. The experiments were conducted in triplicate. Expression level of a gene of interest relative to act-1 was determined by calculating the difference in the number of cycles between the gene of interest and act-1. The level of expression in a transgenic strain compared to a control strain is the difference in the normalized number of cycles, with one cycle being equivalent to two-fold difference in expression.
Assays were performed in triplicate as previously described . Briefly, four day old adult hermaphrodites were immersed in S-basal media containing 50 mM or 200 mM of paraquat. The number of dead worms was scored every hour by touch-provoked movement until all worms were dead. For each strain, median survival was determined by plotting Kaplan Meier survival curves containing 150 worms.
About 200 L4 hermaphrodites were collected, washed four times with S-basal buffer in an eppendorf tube, boiled for 20 minutes and quickly frozen in −80°C. All samples were processed on the same day. A Roche ATP Bioluminscent HSII kit was used to measure ATP concentrations, which measures bioluminescence emitted by the ATP-dependant oxidation of D-luciferin catalyzed by luciferase. ATP concentrations were determined using a standard curve derived from bioluminescence of known ATP concentrations (HSII kit). A Wallac 1420 multilabel counter luminometer (Victor2, Perkin Elmer) was used to measure levels of bioluminescence. A BioRad protein assay kit was used to measure protein concentrations using a Beckman Coulter DU 640 spectrophotometer. ATP concentrations were normalized to absolute protein concentrations. Each assay was repeated in triplicate, and the average ATP concentration and SD were calculated.
Solid dietary restriction assay
The sDR method was performed as described in  with slight modifications. Overnight cultures of E. coli OP50 were grown at 37°C and collected by centrifugugation at 3,000 rpm for 30 minutes (Sorvall Legend RT) to collect bacterial cells. DR plates were prepared by adding 0.75×108 cfu of OP50 and ad libitum (AL) plates were prepared by adding 0.75×1011 cfu of OP50 to NGM-FUDR plates. Worms were grown on NGM plates and synchronized hermaphrodites were transferred overnight to fresh NGM plates with OP50 and 30 µM of FUdR in order to prevent growth of progeny. Day 1 adult animals were then transferred to DR or AL plates. To maintain bacterial concentration, worms were transferred to fresh DR or AL plates every other day.
Detection of carbonylated proteins
Oxidative damage was assessed using an Oxyblot assay kit (Millipore) to detect carbonylated proteins as previously described . About 100 worms synchronized at day 1 or day 14 of adulthood were collected, washed twice with M9 buffer and boiled for 20 min in lysis buffer . Carbonyl groups were derivatized to 2,4-dinitrophenylhydrazone (DNP-hydrazone), and were then detected by Western blotting with a DNP-specific antibody. Total protein levels in the extract were measured by nanodrop and 9 mg of protein lysate was loaded in each lane. Quantification of carbonylated proteins was achieved by taking the ratio of DNP staining to tubulin staining. Levels of carbonylated protein were compared in three independent samples of one day old and 14 day old adult worms.
Quantification of sod-3::mCherry fluorescence
Fluorescence images of sod-3::mCherry were taken as described . Briefly, 10 age-synchronized worms at day 9 of adulthood were transferred to 1 mM aldicarb-NGM plates for 2–3 hours to induce paralysis . Worms were then photographed using a 20× lens on a Zeiss AxioPlan Fluorescent Microscope. Levels of mCherry expression (in the head and the first two pairs of intestinal cells) were analyzed using ImageJ . For any given comparison, all pictures were taken on the same day with the same microscope settings. Results from three independent sets of 10 worms were used to calculate the average expression level and SD.
Phylogenetic trees of uncoupling protein and lysozyme genes. a. Uncoupling proteins. C. elegans misc-1 is the closest to C. elegans ucp-4 and is shown as a reference. Shown are phyogenetic trees for all uncoupling protein genes from the genomes of C. elegans, D. melanogaster, D. rerio, M. musculus and H. sapiens. C. elegans has one uncoupling protein gene (ucp-4) and the ucp2 family is found only in vertebrates. b. Lysozyme tree. C. elegans uaf-1 is used as a reference, being the gene closest to lys-1. C. elegans lysozyme genes belong to a family termed gh25 found mainly in unicellular microbes. D. rerio lyz (and other animal lysozyme genes in the tree) belong to the lys family which includes only animals but not C. elegans. Phylogenetic trees were generated using Muscle (Multiple Sequence Comparison by Log- Expectation) sequence alignment tool.
Brood size measurements of long-lived transgenic worms. Brood size was determined by counting the total number of progeny from a single hermaphrodite. Shown is the average and SEM for eight animals. y-axis shows the total number of progeny from individual hermaphrodites. Each bar represents transgenic worms expressing the corresponding gene. Control refers to worms expressing unc-119(+); sod-3:mCherry. The control bar represents an average of three independent lines. The brood size is not significantly smaller for worms expressing C. elegans sod-1 or lmp-2 and for worms expressing D. rerio sod1, ucp2 or lyz. Wild type worms (N2) have a brood size of 295±25. Ce – C. elegans, Dr – D. rerio. * indicates strains with smaller brood size (p<0.05).
Genes tested in this study.
Lifespan of transgenic worms generated in this study.
Additional data for genes that extend lifespan.
Verification of transgene expression by RT–PCR.
Summary of data from experiments on B. subtilis.
Summary of sDR experiments.
Lifespan extension is modular—summary of data for engineered strains.
10-day-old control worm.
18-day old-control worm.
40-day-old quadruple longevity mutant.
We thank William Burkholder for the B. subtilis (PY79) clone; Yael Sagi for helping with the Oxiblot assay; Eric Greer for the aakg-2(sta2) clone; and Shana Geffeney, Juan G. Cueva, and Miriam Goodman for using WormTracker. We thank Xiao Xu, Adolfo Sánchez-Blanco, and Andy Nguyen for analysis of mCherry expression. We thank Anne Brunet, Xiao Xu, Adolfo Sánchez-Blanco, Stephanie Zimmerman, Eric Van Nostrand, and other members of the Kim lab for comments and reading of the manuscript.
Conceived and designed the experiments: DS SKK. Performed the experiments: DS. Analyzed the data: DS. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: DS. Wrote the paper: DS SKK.
- 1. Elowitz MB, Leibler S (2000) A synthetic oscillatory network of transcriptional regulators. Nature 403: 335–338.
- 2. Chen MT, Weiss R (2005) Artificial cell-cell communication in yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae using signaling elements from Arabidopsis thaliana. Nat Biotechnol 23: 1551–1555.
- 3. Gibson DG, Glass JI, Lartigue C, Noskov VN, Chuang RY, et al. (2010) Creation of a bacterial cell controlled by a chemically synthesized genome. Science 329: 52–56.
- 4. Kirkwood TB (2005) Understanding the odd science of aging. Cell 120: 437–447.
- 5. Budovskaya YV, Wu K, Southworth LK, Jiang M, Tedesco P, et al. (2008) An elt-3/elt-5/elt-6 GATA transcription circuit guides aging in C. elegans. Cell 134: 291–303.
- 6. Kenyon CJ (2010) The genetics of ageing. Nature 464: 504–512.
- 7. George JC, Bada J, Zeh J, Scott L, Brown SE, et al. (1999) Age and growth estimates of bowhead whales (Balaena mysticetus) via aspartic acid racemization. Canadian Journal of Zoology 77: 571–580.
- 8. U.N. (2007) United Nations World Population Prospects: 2006 revision: United Nations, Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Population Division.
- 9. Ridgway ID, Richardson CA, Austad SN (2011) Maximum shell size, growth rate, and maturation age correlate with longevity in bivalve molluscs. J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci 66: 183–190.
- 10. Kirkwood TB, Austad SN (2000) Why do we age? Nature 408: 233–238.
- 11. Van Voorhies WA, Fuchs J, Thomas S (2005) The longevity of Caenorhabditis elegans in soil. Biol Lett 1: 247–249.
- 12. Hsu AL, Murphy CT, Kenyon C (2003) Regulation of aging and age-related disease by DAF-16 and heat-shock factor. Science 300: 1142–1145.
- 13. Greer EL, Dowlatshahi D, Banko MR, Villen J, Hoang K, et al. (2007) An AMPK-FOXO pathway mediates longevity induced by a novel method of dietary restriction in C. elegans. Curr Biol 17: 1646–1656.
- 14. Doonan R, McElwee JJ, Matthijssens F, Walker GA, Houthoofd K, et al. (2008) Against the oxidative damage theory of aging: superoxide dismutases protect against oxidative stress but have little or no effect on life span in Caenorhabditis elegans. Genes Dev 22: 3236–3241.
- 15. Kwon ES, Narasimhan SD, Yen K, Tissenbaum HA (2010) A new DAF-16 isoform regulates longevity. Nature 466: 498–502.
- 16. Prahlad V, Morimoto RI (2009) Integrating the stress response: lessons for neurodegenerative diseases from C. elegans. Trends Cell Biol 19: 52–61.
- 17. Kahn BB, Alquier T, Carling D, Hardie DG (2005) AMP-activated protein kinase: ancient energy gauge provides clues to modern understanding of metabolism. Cell Metab 1: 15–25.
- 18. Perry JJ, Shin DS, Getzoff ED, Tainer JA (2010) The structural biochemistry of the superoxide dismutases. Biochim Biophys Acta 1804: 245–262.
- 19. Morimoto RI (2008) Proteotoxic stress and inducible chaperone networks in neurodegenerative disease and aging. Genes Dev 22: 1427–1438.
- 20. Rubinsztein DC, Marino G, Kroemer G (2011) Autophagy and aging. Cell 146: 682–695.
- 21. Alavez S, Vantipalli MC, Zucker DJ, Klang IM, Lithgow GJ (2011) Amyloid-binding compounds maintain protein homeostasis during ageing and extend lifespan. Nature 472: 226–229.
- 22. Zhang C, Cuervo AM (2008) Restoration of chaperone-mediated autophagy in aging liver improves cellular maintenance and hepatic function. Nat Med 14: 959–965.
- 23. Cuervo AM (2004) Autophagy: many paths to the same end. Mol Cell Biochem 263: 55–72.
- 24. Spence R, Gerlach G, Lawrence C, Smith C (2008) The behaviour and ecology of the zebrafish, Danio rerio. Biol Rev Camb Philos Soc 83: 13–34.
- 25. Brand MD (2000) Uncoupling to survive? The role of mitochondrial inefficiency in ageing. Exp Gerontol 35: 811–820.
- 26. Fridell YW, Sanchez-Blanco A, Silvia BA, Helfand SL (2005) Targeted expression of the human uncoupling protein 2 (hUCP2) to adult neurons extends life span in the fly. Cell Metab 1: 145–152.
- 27. Iser WB, Kim D, Bachman E, Wolkow C (2005) Examination of the requirement for ucp-4, a putative homolog of mammalian uncoupling proteins, for stress tolerance and longevity in C. elegans. Mech Ageing Dev 126: 1090–1096.
- 28. Pfeiffer M, Kayser EB, Yang X, Abramson E, Kenaston MA, et al. (2011) Caenorhabditis elegans UCP4 controls complex II-mediated oxidative phosphorylation through succinate transport. J Biol Chem.
- 29. Garsin DA, Villanueva JM, Begun J, Kim DH, Sifri CD, et al. (2003) Long-lived C. elegans daf-2 mutants are resistant to bacterial pathogens. Science 300: 1921.
- 30. Sánchez-Blanco A, Kim SK (2011) Variable Pathogenicity Determines Individual Lifespan in Caenorhabditis elegans. PLoS Genet 7: e1002047. doi:10.1371/journal.pgen.1002047.
- 31. Callewaert L, Michiels CW (2010) Lysozymes in the animal kingdom. J Biosci 35: 127–160.
- 32. Mallo GV, Kurz CL, Couillault C, Pujol N, Granjeaud S, et al. (2002) Inducible antibacterial defense system in C. elegans. Curr Biol 12: 1209–1214.
- 33. Houthoofd K, Braeckman BP, De Vreese A, Van Eygen S, Lenaerts I, et al. (2004) Caloric restriction, Ins/IGF-1 signalling and longevity in the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans. Belg J Zool 134: 79–84.
- 34. Fontana L, Partridge L, Longo VD (2010) Extending healthy life span–from yeast to humans. Science 328: 321–326.
- 35. Krauss S, Zhang CY, Lowell BB (2005) The mitochondrial uncoupling-protein homologues. Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol 6: 248–261.
- 36. Chen K, Sun G, Lv Z, Wang C, Jiang X, et al. (2010) Molecular cloning of amphioxus uncoupling protein and assessment of its uncoupling activity using a yeast heterologous expression system. Biochem Biophys Res Commun 400: 701–706.
- 37. Murphy CT, McCarroll SA, Bargmann CI, Fraser A, Kamath RS, et al. (2003) Genes that act downstream of DAF-16 to influence the lifespan of Caenorhabditis elegans. Nature 424: 277–283.
- 38. Greer EL, Oskoui PR, Banko MR, Maniar JM, Gygi MP, et al. (2007) The energy sensor AMP-activated protein kinase directly regulates the mammalian FOXO3 transcription factor. J Biol Chem 282: 30107–30119.
- 39. Arantes-Oliveira N, Berman JR, Kenyon C (2003) Healthy animals with extreme longevity. Science 302: 611.
- 40. Cabreiro F, Ackerman D, Doonan R, Araiz C, Back P, et al. (2011) Increased life span from overexpression of superoxide dismutase in Caenorhabditis elegans is not caused by decreased oxidative damage. Free Radic Biol Med 51: 1575–1582.
- 41. Wiesner J, Vilcinskas A (2010) Antimicrobial peptides: the ancient arm of the human immune system. Virulence 1: 440–464.
- 42. Wada S, Hamada M, Satoh N (2006) A genomewide analysis of genes for the heat shock protein 70 chaperone system in the ascidian Ciona intestinalis. Cell Stress Chaperones 11: 23–33.
- 43. Seo S, Baye LM, Schulz NP, Beck JS, Zhang Q, et al. (2010) BBS6, BBS10, and BBS12 form a complex with CCT/TRiC family chaperonins and mediate BBSome assembly. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 107: 1488–1493.
- 44. Brenner S (1974) The genetics of Caenorhabditis elegans. Genetics 77: 71–94.
- 45. Dupuy D, Li QR, Deplancke B, Boxem M, Hao T, et al. (2004) A first version of the Caenorhabditis elegans Promoterome. Genome Res 14: 2169–2175.
- 46. Liu X, Long F, Peng H, Aerni SJ, Jiang M, et al. (2009) Analysis of cell fate from single-cell gene expression profiles in C. elegans. Cell 139: 623–633.
- 47. Apfeld J, Kenyon C (1999) Regulation of lifespan by sensory perception in Caenorhabditis elegans. Nature 402: 804–809.
- 48. Fisher AL, Lithgow GJ (2006) The nuclear hormone receptor DAF-12 has opposing effects on Caenorhabditis elegans lifespan and regulates genes repressed in multiple long-lived worms. Aging Cell 5: 127–138.
- 49. Chen D, Thomas EL, Kapahi P (2009) HIF-1 modulates dietary restriction-mediated lifespan extension via IRE-1 in Caenorhabditis elegans. PLoS Genet 5: e1000486. doi:10.1371/journal.pgen.1000486.
- 50. Yang W, Li J, Hekimi S (2007) A Measurable increase in oxidative damage due to reduction in superoxide detoxification fails to shorten the life span of long-lived mitochondrial mutants of Caenorhabditis elegans. Genetics 177: 2063–2074.
- 51. Mahoney TR, Luo S, Nonet ML (2006) Analysis of synaptic transmission in Caenorhabditis elegans using an aldicarb-sensitivity assay. Nat Protoc 1: 1772–1777.