The Plasmodium falciparum parasite's ability to adapt to environmental pressures, such as the human immune system and antimalarial drugs, makes malaria an enduring burden to public health. Understanding the genetic basis of these adaptations is critical to intervening successfully against malaria. To that end, we created a high-density genotyping array that assays over 17,000 single nucleotide polymorphisms (∼1 SNP/kb), and applied it to 57 culture-adapted parasites from three continents. We characterized genome-wide genetic diversity within and between populations and identified numerous loci with signals of natural selection, suggesting their role in recent adaptation. In addition, we performed a genome-wide association study (GWAS), searching for loci correlated with resistance to thirteen antimalarials; we detected both known and novel resistance loci, including a new halofantrine resistance locus, PF10_0355. Through functional testing we demonstrated that PF10_0355 overexpression decreases sensitivity to halofantrine, mefloquine, and lumefantrine, but not to structurally unrelated antimalarials, and that increased gene copy number mediates resistance. Our GWAS and follow-on functional validation demonstrate the potential of genome-wide studies to elucidate functionally important loci in the malaria parasite genome.
Malaria infection with the human pathogen Plasmodium falciparum results in almost a million deaths each year, mostly in African children. Efforts to eliminate malaria are underway, but the parasite is adept at eluding both the human immune response and antimalarial treatments. Thus, it is important to understand how the parasite becomes resistant to drugs and to develop strategies to overcome resistance mechanisms. Toward this end, we used population genetic strategies to identify genetic loci that contribute to parasite adaptation and to identify candidate genes involved in drug resistance. We examined over 17,000 genetic variants across the parasite genome in over 50 strains in which we also measured responses to many known antimalarial compounds. We found a number of genetic loci showing signs of recent natural selection and a number of loci potentially involved in modulating the parasite's response to drugs. We further demonstrated that one of the novel candidate genes (PF10_0355) modulates resistance to the antimalarial compounds halofantrine, mefloquine, and lumefantrine. Overall, this study confirms that we can use genome-wide approaches to identify clinically relevant genes and demonstrates through functional testing that at least one of these candidate genes is indeed involved in antimalarial drug resistance.
Citation: Van Tyne D, Park DJ, Schaffner SF, Neafsey DE, Angelino E, Cortese JF, et al. (2011) Identification and Functional Validation of the Novel Antimalarial Resistance Locus PF10_0355 in Plasmodium falciparum. PLoS Genet 7(4): e1001383. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1001383
Editor: Nancy A. Moran, Yale University, United States of America
Received: September 16, 2010; Accepted: March 25, 2011; Published: April 21, 2011
Copyright: © 2011 Van Tyne et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: The study is supported by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, Ellison Medical Foundation, ExxonMobil Foundation, NIH Fogarty, and NIAID. PCS is also supported by fellowships from the Burroughs Wellcome and Packard Foundations. DJP is supported by an NSF Graduate Research Fellowship. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Plasmodium falciparum malaria is a major public health challenge that contributes significantly to global morbidity and mortality. Efforts to control and eliminate malaria combine antimalarial drugs, bed nets and indoor residual spraying, with vaccine development a longer-term goal. Genetic variation in the parasite population threatens to undermine these efforts, as the parasite evolves rapidly to evade host immune systems, drugs and vaccines. Studying genetic variation in parasite populations will expand our understanding of basic parasite biology and its ability to adapt, and will allow us to track parasites as they respond to intervention efforts. Such understanding is increasingly important as countries move towards reducing disease burden and the ultimate elimination of malaria.
Given the potential impact of rapid evolution of P. falciparum in response to control and eradication strategies, discovery and characterization of P. falciparum genetic diversity has accelerated in recent years. Since the first malaria genome was sequenced in 2002 , over 60,000 unique SNPs have been identified by concerted sequencing efforts –, and several genomic tiling arrays – and low-density SNP arrays ,  have been developed to query this genetic variation. Recently the first malaria GWAS was published , in which 189 drug-phenotyped parasites from Asia, Africa and the Americas were genotyped using a low-density array (3,257 SNPs); that study identified loci under positive selection and found several novel drug resistance candidates.
For our study, we adopted two strategies for identifying genes involved in the malaria parasite's adaptive response: searching for signals of recent or ongoing natural selection, and searching for loci associated with one important clinical adaptation—resistance to antimalarial drugs. To make these searches possible, we began by sequencing 9 geographically diverse strains of P. falciparum to identify novel variation, thereby doubling the number of publicly available SNPs to 111,536 (all accessible at plasmodb.org), and used these SNPs to develop a high-density genotyping array assaying 17,582 validated markers. After characterizing linkage disequilibrium and population structure in our samples, we used the arrays to search for evidence of both ongoing balancing selection and recent positive selection, and to carry out a GWAS that sought loci associated with resistance to thirteen antimalarial agents. We then followed up one of the novel loci associated with drug resistance in order to verify that variation there was biologically involved in modulating drug response.
We identified global population structure among malaria parasites using principal components analysis (PCA) of 57 genotyped culture-adapted parasite samples (Figure 1A, Table S1, Figure S1). African, American and Asian samples form three distinct clusters, reflecting the likely independent introduction of P. falciparum from Africa into Asia and the Americas. There was little evidence for structure within Africa, suggesting high gene flow throughout the region (Figure S1). Asian and American parasites however both show substantial internal structure.
(A) Population structure is visualized using the first two principal components of genetic variation for 57 parasites. Solid circles represent individual parasites, with colors assigned by reported origin: Africa in red, America in blue, and Asia in green. The nine strains used for ascertainment sequencing are indicated with (*). (B) Genetic diversity (SNP π) in Senegal versus divergence (FST) between Senegal and Thailand is reported for 688 genes containing >3 successfully genotyped SNPs. Blue diamonds: enzymes, acyl-CoA synthetases (ACS) or transporters; red diamonds: antigens, vars, rifins, stevors or surfins; gray diamonds: all other genes. Gene IDs (PlasmoDB.org) for highlighted genes are listed in Table S7. A gene with unknown function is flagged with (*) to indicate that SNP π is off-scale (0.014).
There are also dramatic differences in linkage disequilibrium (LD) between populations, with substantial LD extending less than 1 kb in Senegal, 10 kb in Thailand, and 100 kb in Brazil (Figure S2). These observations are consistent with previous findings, which showed that LD decays more rapidly in Africa, due either to founder effects in other continents  or to elevated outcrossing frequencies in Africa , , where higher transmission intensity leads to a greater likelihood of sexual outcrossing rather than selfing within the mid-gut of vector mosquitoes.
The short LD in malaria, driven by high levels of recombination, means that a high density of markers is required to identify candidate loci in association studies, since causal variants not on the array can seldom be tagged by neighboring alleles (Table S2). On the other hand, short LD can aid in fine-mapping candidate associations and greatly accelerates the search for causal genes. Short LD also aids in identifying genomic regions under recent positive selection with recombination-based methods, since the increased LD in selected regions should stand out against the short-LD background.
Detecting Signals of Natural Selection
We expect that many parasite proteins that interact with the host immune system will be under balancing selection, because they will be under selective pressure to maintain high levels of diversity. Indeed, previous studies have shown that regions of the P. falciparum genome that are highly polymorphic and appear to be under balancing selection encode antigens that are recognized by the human immune system . We examined evidence for balancing selection in our data by searching for regions with high nucleotide diversity (as measured by SNP π) and low population divergence (as measured by FST) (Figure 1B). When we examined the loci lying in this region of the graph (Figure S3), we found a number of known antigens and vaccine candidates. Loci in the same region with unknown function are thus potential novel antigens that trigger human immune response to malaria, and may prove useful as biomarkers or as candidate vaccine molecules.
We carried out a similar search for loci under positive selection by identifying regions with both low nucleotide diversity within Senegal and Thailand and high population divergence between the two populations (Figure 1B). We observed throughout the genome that nucleotide diversity was lower for nonsynonymous SNPs than for intergenic SNPs (Figure S4), a characteristic result of widespread purifying selection. At the same time, nonsynonymous SNPs exhibited significantly greater divergence than intergenic SNPs in all pairwise population comparisons, suggesting the effect of positive selection in local P. falciparum populations. Nonsynonymous SNPs with low diversity within a population and high divergence between the two populations studied may represent polymorphisms responsible for adaptive evolution.
We also carried out a genome-wide scan for recent positive selection using the long-range haplotype (LRH) test , which identifies common variants that have recently spread to high prevalence using recombination as a clock. Approximately 15 genes were identified as having undergone recent positive selection by this approach, including known drug resistance loci (pfcrt and dhfr) as well as multiple members of the acyl-CoA synthetase (ACS) and ubiquitin protein ligase families (Figures S5 and S6); these latter genes also exhibit high divergence between Senegal and Thailand (Figure 1B), evidence for selection that is recent and population-specific. Taken as a group, the genes identified by the LRH test show a significant enrichment for higher than average population divergence (as measured by FST, Mann-Whitney U = 1583, P = 0.0071). All of these loci (Table S3, Dataset S1), which include genes in the folate metabolism, lipid biosynthesis and ubiquitin pathways, should be viewed as candidates for functional follow-up and further characterization.
Genome-Wide Associations with Drug Resistance
In order to directly assess the genetic basis for one important response to antimalarial intervention, we carried out a GWAS to identify loci associated with drug resistance in parasites. This same approach can potentially be applied to many other clinically relevant malaria phenotypes, e.g. host response, invasion, and gametocyte formation. Our first step was to measure drug resistance (IC50 values) to 13 antimalarial drugs (amodiaquine, artemether, artesunate, artemisinin, atovaquone, chloroquine, dihydroartemisinin, halofuginone, halofantrine, lumefantrine, mefloquine, piperaquine and quinine) in 50 culture-adapted parasites using a high-throughput assay (Tables S4 and S5, Text S1, Dataset S1).
We performed the genome-wide association analysis using two statistical tests: efficient mixed-model association (EMMA) and a haplotype likelihood ratio (HLR) test (Figures S7, S8, S9, S10, Methods). EMMA identifies quantitative trait associations in individuals with complex population structure and hidden relatedness; it has previously been shown to outperform both PCA-based and λGC-based correction approaches in highly inbred and structured mouse, maize, and Arabidopsis populations . EMMA is particularly applicable for small and structured sample sets: one of its first applications was in a study of 24 diploid mouse strains , essentially the same sample size as in our study (50 haploid strains). The HLR test is a multi-marker test designed to detect the association of a single haplotype with a phenotype, and is particularly powerful when the associated haplotype experienced recent strong selection (and is therefore long) and occurs on a low-LD background ; it is therefore particularly appropriate for this study. We addressed the effect of population structure in the HLR test using population-specific permutation (Methods). When used together, these two complementary approaches provide a highly sensitive screen for association signals within the P. falciparum genome.
The well-characterized chloroquine resistance locus, pfcrt, served as a positive control for our GWAS methods (Figure 2A and 2C, Table S2), an important test given our small sample size and the limited LD present in P. falciparum. As expected, we found evidence for association with resistance to chloroquine using both tests, consistent with previous studies ; EMMA yielded evidence for association with genome-wide signficance, while the signal from the HLR test fell just short of genome-wide significance (Figure 2C).
(A) Genome-wide significant associations were found for five antimalarials (out of thirteen tested) using EMMA and HLR tests. They include pfcrt (chromosome 7) associated with chloroquine resistance and eleven novel associations with resistance to several drugs, listed in Table 1. (B) Quantile-quantile plots for the P-value distributions in (A) show no significant confounding from population structure. Bonferroni-corrected genome-wide significance is marked with a dashed line; Benjamini-Hochberg significance is marked with a dotted line. (C-D) Close-ups are shown of the GWAS signal (top) and haplotypes (bottom) for resistance to (C) chloroquine (CQ) around the gene pfcrt and (D) halofantrine (HFN) around the gene PF10_0355. Yellow: sensitive allele; red: resistant allele; Blue: no data. Isolates are ordered by IC50, with the highest IC50 on the bottom.
Applying the same tests to the other drug phenotypes, we detected numerous novel loci showing significant associations with drug resistance (Figure 2A and 2D, Table 1). Quantile-quantile plots for each test demonstrate that we were able to effectively control for population structure (Figure 2B). Despite our small sample size and the low LD in P. falciparum, in total eleven loci achieved genome-wide significance for association with resistance to five different drugs: amodiaquine, artemisinin, atovaquone, chloroquine and halofantrine. In most cases, the short extent of LD allowed localization to individual genes. Among the loci identified were various transporters and membrane proteins, as well as five conserved genes with unknown function (Table 1, Dataset S1).
Functional Validation of a Novel Resistance Candidate
Demonstrating that a signal of association actually reflects a causal molecular process requires functional testing and validation of the candidate locus, both because of concerns about power and reproducibility of genetic association tests, and because even a robust statistical correlation need not imply biological causation. To confirm the ability of GWAS to identify functionally relevant candidates, we investigated one of our association findings, PF10_0355, in greater depth. This gene contains multiple SNPs associated with halofantrine resistance (Figure 2D), and encodes a putative erythrocyte membrane protein (PlasmoDB.org) characterized by high genetic diversity.
We set out to determine the role of PF10_0355 in halofantrine resistance by transfecting halofantrine-sensitive Dd2 parasites with episomal plasmids containing the PF10_0355 gene from a halofantrine-resistant parasite (SenP08.04), a technique that is used routinely for stable transgene expression . Two independent transfectants overexpressing the PF10_0355 gene from SenP08.04 both showed reduced susceptibility to halofantrine when compared with the Dd2 parent or a transfection control (Figure 3A), suggesting that this gene is indeed involved in modulating parasite drug response.
Parasite susceptibility to six antimalarials was measured by 3H-hypoxanthine incorporation. Comparisons were made between Dd2 (HFN-sensitive strain) and SenP08.04 (HFN-resistant strain), as well as 4 transfected lines. “Dd2+Dd2”: Dd2 parasites overexpressing PF10_0355 from Dd2; “Dd2+P08”: Dd2 parasites overexpressing PF10_0355 from SenP08.04. Overexpression of PF10_0355 decreases parasite susceptibility to (A) HFN and structurally related (B) mefloquine (MFQ) and (C) lumefantrine (LUM). Overexpression of PF10_0355 does not alter parasite susceptibility to (D) chloroquine (CQ), (E) artemisinin (ARTS) or (F) atovaquone (ATV). Mean IC50 ± standard error is shown. Significance levels: *: p<0.05, **: p<0.01, ***: p<0.001.
Two independent transfectants overexpressing the endogenous PF10_0355 gene from halofantrine-sensitive Dd2 also showed reduced susceptibility to halofantrine (Figure 3A), however, pointing to a role of overexpression in the observed resistance. Because PF10_0355 is annotated as a putative erythrocyte membrane protein and belongs to the merozoite surface protein 3/6 family, we tested the hypothesis that the observed effect was the by-product of a growth or invasion-related process, rather than resistance due to a direct interaction with the antimalarial itself. To that end, we expanded our drug testing in the transfectant lines to include other antimalarials, some structurally related and some unrelated to halofantrine.
Overexpression of PF10_0355 from either the Dd2 or the SenP08.04 parent caused increased resistance to the structurally related antimalarials mefloquine and lumefantrine (Figure 3B and 3C), but had no effect on parasite susceptibility to the structurally unrelated antimalarials chloroquine, artemisinin or atovaquone (Figure 3D and 3E). Indeed, we found evidence of cross-resistance between halofantrine and both mefloquine and lumefantrine (Figure 4). We also observed cross-resistance between halofantrine and artemisinin, which is expected as cross-resistance between aminoquinolines and artemisinin compounds has been previously demonstrated ,  and resistance to all these drugs has been shown to be mediated by changes in pfmdr1 copy number , . Overexpression of PF10_0355, however, alters parasite susceptibility to the aminoquinolines but not to artemisinin, suggesting that this effect is specific for that set of structurally related compounds and distinct from the effect of pfmdr1, which seems to exert a global effect of resistance to unrelated compounds (i.e. both aminoquinolines and artemisinins). Using the Dd2 parasite line, which has amplified pfmdr1 copy number, as a background for PF10_0355 overexpression allowed us to distinguish between cross-resistance to a structurally related class of compounds (mediated by PF10_0355 overexpression) and pan-resistance to multiple classes of drugs.
(A) Pearson correlation values (r) between log10(IC50) values are rendered as a color in a symmetric correlation matrix (red: correlated; white-uncorrelated, blue: inversely correlated). Thirteen antimalarials are measured: artemether (ARTM), artesunate (ARTN), artemisinin (ARTS), dihydroartemisinin (DHA), halofantrine (HFN), lumefantrine (LUM), mefloquine (MFQ), quinine (QN), chloroquine (CQ), amodiaquine (ADQ), atovaquone (ATV), piperaquine (PIP), and halofuginone (HFG). Drugs are grouped by structural relatedness. (B–F) Correlation plots are given with a linear regression line for HFN compared to the 5 other drugs tested for antimalarial resistance with PF10_0355 overexpression: (B) LUM, (C) MFQ, (D) ATV, (E) CQ, and (F) ARTS.
Given that overexpression of the PF10_0355 gene both from a halofantrine-resistant and from a sensitive parasite conferred resistance to halofantrine-related drugs, we investigated whether gene amplification might be driving the observed resistance, as it often does for antimalarial drugs –. We quantified PF10_0355 copy number in our transfectants and found that the transfectant with the highest IC50 for all three drugs (Dd2+P08B) also had the highest PF10_0355 copy number, as measured by quantitative PCR (qPCR) (Figure 5A). Furthermore, when we examined the PF10_0355 gene on our SNP array, we detected a substantial increase in hybridization intensity at the PF10_0355 locus compared to the genome average, suggesting that this gene is amplified in some parasites (Figure 5B). The amplified region appears only to contain the PF10_0355 gene itself and not surrounding loci. We observed a similar pattern at pfmdr1 on chromosome 5, where copy number variation is well established (Figure S11). Follow-up qPCR analysis of 38 parasite lines confirmed that parasites with amplified PF10_0355 have a greater mean halofantrine IC50. (Figure 5C, Table S6, Dataset S1). Copy number variation was further confirmed in a number of parasites by quantitative Southern blotting (Figure S12).
(A) Mean PF10_0355 copy number (± standard deviation for three replicates) in the parent Dd2 and transfected lines from qPCR analysis. Dd2+Dd2: Dd2 parasites overexpressing PF10_0355 from HFN-sensitive Dd2; Dd2+P08: Dd2 parasites overexpressing PF10_0355 from HFN-resistant SenP08.04. Copy number was compared to the reference locus PF07_0076. (B) Increased hybridization intensity at PF10_0355 on the high-density SNP array, measured by Z-scores for normalized and background-corrected data, for the HFN-resistant isolate SenP19.04. (C) Strains with increased copy number of PF10_0355 (as measured by qPCR >1.2x 3D7) show a significantly higher resistance to HFN (p = 0.02, Student t-test).
In this study we used natural selection and genome-wide association methods to probe the genetic basis of adaptation in P. falciparum. These approaches are complementary: scanning for selected loci permits an unbiased search for unknown adaptive changes, but provides little information about the processes at work, while GWAS gives a focused look at one easily identified (and clinically critical) adaptive phenotype. Results from both approaches open up new avenues for study, as we seek to understand the biological significance of the findings.
The specifics of our strategy were designed to cope with two potential limitations in applying genome-wide population genetic approaches to malaria: small sample sizes, due to the difficulty in adapting parasites to culture and assessing drug and other phenotypes; and a lack of correlation (LD) between nearby variants in the parasite genome, which limits our ability to infer untyped SNPs from genotyped markers. The second limitation we addressed by developing a high-density genotyping array (based on new sequencing), to increase the fraction of genetic variation that we could directly interrogate, while the effect of the first was mitigated by the phenotype we targeted in our GWAS.
Drug resistance is a phenotype well-suited for GWAS because it is expected to be caused by common alleles of large effect at few genomic loci . If this is the case, associations will be much easier to detect than in a typical human GWAS, in which the phenotype is caused by alleles at many loci that are either rare or of small effect. Additionally, the haploid nature of the intra-erythrocytic stage of P. falciparum further heightens GWAS power by eliminating the issue of allelic dominance. Finally, the increased LD caused by recent selection for drug resistance counteracts the loss of power that comes from short LD, small sample size, and the temporal and geographic stratification of the parasite population that we examined. Thus, despite the potential limitations, we were able to detect a known drug resistance locus (pfcrt), observed little P-value inflation in our GWAS data (Figures S8, S9, S10), and identified a number of genome-wide significant loci associated with drug resistance. Part of this success was likely due to specific tests we used to account for population structure.
Going beyond these statistical tests, we went on to functionally validate one of these loci, demonstrating that increased PF10_0355 copy number confer resistance to three structurally related antimalarial drugs. This demonstrates the feasibility of coupling GWAS and functional testing in the malaria parasite for identifying and validating novel drug resistance loci and illustrates the power of GWAS to find functionally important alleles.
Comparing our results to the recent GWAS described by Mu, et al. , which was also directed at finding drug-resistance loci, we see that, beyond the well-known pfcrt locus, there was no overlap between the associations identified by each study. Differing sets of drugs tested and analytical methods explain much of the disagreement. Of the eleven candidate associations in Table 1, one (that with pfcrt) was found by both studies, eight were associations with drugs not assayed in Mu, et al. (atovaquone and halofantrine), and two were found only with a haplotype-based test, an approach not used by Mu, et al. Our candidate locus at PF10_0355, in fact, would not have been detectable in the Mu study because it was identified only by the multi-marker HLR test, because it involved an association with halofantrine, and because the Mu, et al. genotyping array lacked markers within 4 kb of the gene (plasmoDB.org).
Different parasite populations and marker sets probably explain many of the dihydroartemisinin, mefloquine and quinine associations identified by Mu, et al. but not seen in our data set. The studies used different parasite population sets—theirs was weighted toward southeast Asian strains, and ours toward African strains—and selection pressures and selected alleles can both vary between populations. Our smaller sample size also means that we might lack power to identify some associations accessible to Mu, et al. These difficulties are reflected in human GWAS studies as well, where the ability to replicate associations using multiple tests and in different sample sets has also been challenging to achieve .
Ultimately, the disparities in loci identified point to the role of population analysis as a tool for candidate gene discovery and not as a definitive study. Even within each study, there is little overlap between the signals observed with different methods—our study detects only one gene (pfcrt) by both GWAS tests (EMMA and HLR), while Mu, et al. detected only two genes (unknowns, not pfcrt) by both of their GWAS tests (Eigensoft and PLINK). Even a well-designed GWAS serves only as a hypothesis-generating experiment, and it is vital to empirically validate candidate loci associated with a phenotype of interest. Especially given the small sample sizes and relatively sparse marker density used in both malaria GWAS studies to date, functional validation of candidates is necessary to address concerns about false positive results.
Our functional result, that increased PF10_0355 copy number confers decreased susceptibility to halofantrine, mefloquine and lumefantrine, raises additional questions for study. Further work will be needed to determine the precise contributions of copy number variation and gene mutation to the parasite's response to these drugs. The biological function of this gene's product is unknown, but previous work indicates putative localization to the parasite surface , as well as it being a potential target of host immunity and balancing selection . While the protein itself does not appear to be a transporter, it is possible that it directly binds drug or perhaps couples with transport proteins to modulate drug susceptibility; interaction between membrane transporters and non-channel proteins has been demonstrated in cancer, plant and yeast systems –. Additional experiments are certainly required to determine the precise role of PF10_0355 in modulating parasite response to this class of compounds, including assessing its relevance to resistance in natural populations, but it is clear that alteration of this locus can mediate drug resistance in P. falciparum.
Although halofantrine, mefloquine and lumefantrine are not commonly used as primary interventions, widespread halofantrine use has recently been documented in West Africa. Notably, halofantrine was used to treat nearly 18 million patients between 1988 and 2005 , , and it remains in production and use today. Use of halofantrine, mefloquine or lumefantrine as monotherapy may further explain how mutations and copy number variation in the PF10_0355 gene were selected. Lumefantrine is also currently used as a partner drug in the artemisinin-based combination therapy (ACT) Coartem. The shorter half-life of artemether allows lumefantrine to be present as monotherapy, making it vulnerable to selection of drug resistant mutants. As genetic loci associated with drug responses are identified and validated, these provide new molecular biomarkers to evaluate drug use and response in malaria endemic settings. Thus, our findings have implications for defining molecular biomarkers for monitoring partner drug responses as intervention strategies, such as ACTs, are applied.
Beyond identifying a novel drug resistance locus, this study illustrates the general utility of a GWAS approach for the discovery of gene function in P. falciparum. Even with a small and geographically heterogeneous sample of parasites, we identified a number of new loci associated with drug response and validated one of them. Larger samples from a single population will have much greater power to detect additional loci, including those where multiple and low frequency alleles contribute to resistance. Future GWAS have the potential both to provide greater insights into basic parasite biology and to identify biomarkers for drug resistance and other clinically relevant phenotypes like acquired protection, pathogenesis, and placental malaria.
Future GWAS will be able to counteract the loss of power caused by low LD, either by focusing on parasite populations with reduced outcrossing rates, or by studying cases of very strong selective pressure. This issue will soon become moot, however, as the declining cost of whole-genome sequencing makes it practical to assay every nucleotide in the genome on a routine basis. Culture-adapted parasites are amenable to robust and reproducible phenotypic characterization, but their limitations—the potential for artifactual mutations during adaptation and for a biased selection of clones within a given infection—mean that genetic changes identified using them require both functional validation and demonstration that the changes are important during natural infection. As direct sequencing of clinical isolates with demonstrable clinical phenotypes such as ex vivo drug response or invasion properties becomes increasingly feasible, sequencing will enable us to directly identify genetic changes in the parasite associated with clinically relevant phenotypes. In the years ahead, genome analysis of P. falciparum has the potential to identify genetic loci associated with many phenotypes, enhance our understanding of the biology of this important human pathogen, and inform the development of diagnostic and surveillance tools for malaria eradication.
Parasites, Drug Testing, and DNA Isolation
Parasite samples and origins are detailed in Text S1 and Table S1. Parasites were maintained by standard methods  and were tested for their response to amodiaquine, artemether, artesunate, artemisinin, atovaquone, chloroquine, dihydroartemisinin, halofuginone, halofantrine, lumefantrine, mefloquine, piperaquine and quinine according to the methods outlined by Baniecki, et al.  (Table S4, Figure S13, Text S1). Follow-up drug testing was done by measuring uptake of 3H-hypoxanthine . Nucleic acids were obtained from parasite cultures using Qiagen genomic-tips (Qiagen, USA). All DNA samples were evaluated by molecular barcode .
We sequenced nine geographically diverse parasite isolates to 1.25x coverage, nearly doubling the number of publicly available SNPs to 111,536 (Text S1). These parasites had been previously sequenced to 0.25x coverage  and the deeper sequencing allowed for more thorough SNP discovery. Using this combined marker set, we created a high-density Affymetrix-based SNP array for P. falciparum containing 74,656 markers. Arrays were hybridized to 57 independent parasite samples (Table S1), including 17 previously sequenced strains used as a validation set. Genotype calls were produced using the BRLMM-P algorithm . Markers that did not demonstrate perfect concordance between sequence and array data for the 17 strains were removed (Text S1). The remaining 17,582 SNPs constituted the high-confidence marker set used throughout this study (median marker spacing 444 bp, mean spacing 1,316 bp). All genomic positions and translation consequences are listed with respect to the PlasmoDB 5.0 assembly and annotation. SNP genotype data are publicly available on plasmodb.org (release 6.0, July 2009) and dbSNP (Build B134, May 2011), accessible by searching for submission batches Pf_0002 (sequencing of nine isolates) and Pf_0003 (genotyping of 57 isolates) from submitter BROAD-GENOMEBIO. Genotype data is also available as Dataset S2.
Principal Component Analyses
Principal components analysis (PCA) was performed using the program SmartPCA . All single-infection samples were used for the analysis in Figure 1. Samples that tightly clustered with the wrong continental population (A4, Malayan Camp and T2_C6) represented likely cases of contamination and were thus omitted from all other analyses.
We measured diversity using a statistic we term ‘SNP π,’ which quantifies the average number of pair-wise differences among samples from a given population at assayed SNPs. Population divergence was measured using FST, calculated using the method of Hudson, et al. . Statistical evaluation of the significance of differences in SNP π and FST among populations was performed using a bootstrapping approach, where the SNP set was re-sampled with replacement and each statistic recomputed 1000 times.
Linkage Disequilibrium (LD) Analysis
The statistic r2 was calculated within each population for all pairs of SNPs sharing the same chromosome ; pairs were binned by distance and averaged within each bin. The level of LD between unlinked markers was estimated by calculating r2 between all pairs of SNPs on different chromosomes. To determine the bias caused by small sample size, the unlinked calculation was repeated, with the change that for each pair of SNPs, the genotype for one was taken from one strain while the genotype for the second was taken from another strain. This background value of r2 was calculated separately for the possible pairs of different strains and then averaged. Only single infections, as assessed by molecular barcode, were used.
Long Range Haplotype (LRH) Analysis
Because of the small number of samples, LRH results for individual continental populations had a high level of variance. Thus, we pooled together samples from Africa (n = 26) and Asia (n = 18, excluding India), as suggested by our PCA analysis. SNPs included in the analysis had a minor allele frequency of at least 0.05 and a call rate of at least 0.8; missing genotypes were imputed using PHASE. LRH analysis was performed using Sweep. Each SNP defined two core alleles, one base pair in length. We calculated relative extended haplotype homozygosity (REHH) for each core allele, to its left and right , yielding up to four REHH scores per SNP locus. We standardized the REHH scores as a function of core allele frequency, defined on a discrete grid from 0.05 to 0.95 with even spaces of 0.025. This yielded a normally-distributed set of Z-scores for which we calculated corresponding P-values and Q-values.
Genome-Wide Association Study (GWAS)
We performed a GWAS for drug resistance to thirteen antimalarials across 50 of our genotyped samples. 7,437 SNPs that had a minor allele count of five samples as well as an 80% call rate under every phenotype condition were used for GWAS. A Bonferroni significance threshold of –log10(P-value) >5.17 was used for all tests. See Text S1 for more details on GWAS methods.
The Efficient Mixed-Model Association (EMMA) test  models quantitative trait associations to a data set with complex population structure and hidden relatedness. It calculates a genotype similarity matrix instead of discrete categories and does not require a priori specification of populations. The resulting P-value distributions demonstrate little remaining effect from population structure (Figure S8) while retaining power to find a number of associations at genome-wide significance (Figure S8, Figure 2A, Table 1).
The Haplotype Likelihood Ratio (HLR) test  models the likelihood that a single, resistant haplotype rose to dominance while all other haplotypes proportionally decreased. PLINK  is used to produce sliding window haplotypes across the genome and calculate haplotype frequencies for input to the HLR test. We produced input for all 2-, 4- and 6-marker windows. The LOD scores generated by the HLR test were converted to empirical pointwise P-values by performing approximately 370,000 permutations of the null model for each test condition, allowing us to calculate empirical P-values up to a significance of 10−5.6. We preserved population-specific phenotype frequencies by permuting only within each of three populations defined by our PCA analysis (Table S1). Resulting P-value distributions fit expectations well for the vast majority of test conditions (Figures S9, S10) and the test demonstrates power to detect a number of loci at genome-wide significance (Figure 2A, Table 1).
Copy Number Variation (CNV)
Copy number was assessed by evaluating the hybridization intensity at the PF10_0355 locus on the high-density SNP array (Text S1). Follow-up analyses were done by quantitative real-time PCR (qPCR) of the PF10_0355 locus using the Delta Delta Ct method . PF10_0355 was compared to the reference locus PF07_0076 and 3D7 was used as a reference strain. A summary of PF10_0355 copy number for all parasite strains tested is provided in Table S6. Select resistant strains that were found to have multiple copies of PF10_0355 were further analyzed by quantitative Southern blotting and PF10_0355 copy number was compared to the dhps gene from the 3D7 strain .
The full length ORF of PF10_0355 was amplified from either the Dd2 (HFN sensitive) or SenP08.04 (HFN resistant) parasite isolate and cloned into the pBIC009 plasmid under the expression of the Hsp86 promoter. Plasmid DNA was isolated, tranfected into the Dd2 parasite strain and stable transfectants were selected with 2.5 nM WR99210 . Parasites from two independent experiments for each vector type (Dd2+Dd2 and Dd2+SenP08.04) were isolated and successful transfection was confirmed by plasmid rescue as well as episome-specific PCR and sequencing. Additionally, a vector control strain was made by transfecting Dd2 parasites with the pBIC009 plasmid containing the firefly luciferase gene (EC 18.104.22.168).
Drug data, PF10_0355 copy number data, and top GWAS and LRH hits.
(0.06 MB XLS)
Genotype data. Tab separated text file containing genotype data for 57 isolates across 17,582 SNPs. Additional information such as translation consequences (based on PlasmoDB v5.0 annotations) are also provided.
(3.29 MB TXT)
Principal components analysis of population structure within A) Africa B) the Americas, and C) Asia. Plots of the first two principal components using Eigenstrat  using the Affymetrix array. Each solid circle represents an individual, and the color is assigned according to the reported origin.
(0.56 MB DOC)
Linkage disequilibrium (LD), measured by r2, for each of the three population samples (Senegal, Thailand, Brazil). Plotted are r2 for linked markers (red lines) and for unlinked markers (blue lines), as well as the level of background LD expected because of small sample size (green lines).
(0.06 MB DOC)
Genes were classified by gene ontology (GO) functional categories and stratified by level of nucleotide diversity (π) as estimated by Z-scores. Select categories (highest five and lowest five categories along with categories in between that differ by incremental Z-scores) are shown. The majority of genes in GO categories for molecules found at the cell membrane have high levels of nucleotide diversity, while most of the genes classified into GO categories for conserved molecules lack nucleotide diversity.
(0.51 MB DOC)
SNP diversity and divergence by translation consequence. Diversity at assayed SNPs (SNP π) and Divergence between different populations as assayed by FST, for different classes of SNPs: intergenic (4,263 SNPs), intronic (584 SNPs), synonymous (3,957 SNPs), and nonsynonymous (8,778 SNPs). Intronic SNPs have the widest error bars due to their relative sparseness on the array. Non-synonymous SNPs are generally among the least diverse and most differentiated class of SNPs.
(1.58 MB EPS)
Relative extended haplotype homozygosity (REHH) scores. Relative extended haplotype homozygosity (REHH) scores prior to any normalization, plotted for each core allele, (A) indexed by chromosome and position, and colored by chromosome, and (B) as a function of core allele frequency.
(0.61 MB DOC)
Long-range haplotype (LRH) analysis yields genome-wide significant candidates for recent positive selection. For each core allele, we calculated relative extended haplotype homozygosity (REHH), and from the set of all REHH scores we calculated a corresponding distribution of Q-values. We plotted -log10(Q-value), for all Q-values <1, for each core allele, indexed by chromosome and position, and colored by chromosome. The red dotted line corresponds to the typical Q-value significance threshold of 0.05. Gene annotations from PlasmoDB.org for some significant scores are labeled. For comparison, the well-known sweeps around drug resistance loci pfcrt and dhfr are labeled. This data is also shown in tabular form in Table S3.
(0.23 MB TIF)
GWAS P-value distributions for Fisher's exact test, permuted Fisher's exact test, and Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel (CMH) tests. Quantile-quantile plots (qq-plots) show log P-values for every SNP on the y axis against the null expectation on the x axis. Fisher's exact test results generally show P-value inflation due to confounding effects from population structure for many drugs ("Fish"). As such, no results from this test are reported. To account for population structure, permutations of the null distribution were performed while preserving phenotypic associations to three predefined population clusters ("Fishp"). CMH also performs a stratified association test given predefined population clusters ("CMH"). The permuted Fisher's test and CMH test results show appropriate correction for population structure, but show no hits at genome-wide significance to report.
(0.47 MB TIF)
GWAS results for the Efficient Mixed-Model Association (EMMA) test. QQ-plots show little to no confounding effect from population structure, with the possible exception of artesunate (ARTN). The significant ARTN result is not reported in Table 1 or Figure 2 for this reason. Manhattan plots depict the genomic location of significant hits, also reported in Table 1 and Figure 2.
(0.61 MB TIF)
GWAS P-value distributions for the Haplotype Likelihood Ratio (HLR) tests for association for drug resistance. Population-sensitive permutations of the null model were used to calculate P-values from LOD scores. Final distributions of P-values show little to no confounding effect from population structure for most tests. Exceptions include the 6-SNP artemether (HLR_risk_6_ARTM) test and the 4-SNP amodiaquine (HLR_risk_4_ADQ) test--these results are not reported in Table 1 or Figure 2. Manhattan plots for other tests that reached genome-wide significance are in Figure 2A.
(3.52 MB TIF)
GWAS P-value distributions for Haplotype Likelihood Ratio (HLR) tests for association for drug sensitivity. Population-sensitive permutations of the null model were used to calculate P-values from LOD scores. Final distributions of P-values show little to no confounding effect from population structure. Genome-wide significant hits include piperaquine (HLR_protect_4_PIP) on a haplotype that spans PF07_0126, PF07_0127 and MAL7P1_167 and amodiaquine (HLR_protect_4_ADQ) on a haplotype in PFL1800w. A chloroquine hit on pfcrt just misses genome-wide significance. These results are not reported in Table 1.
(3.51 MB TIF)
Intensity Z-score for the Affymetrix array across chromosome 5. The results illustrate that probes for many of the SNPs assayed within the pfmdr1 (888-988 k) locus exhibit notably higher hybridization intensity values in Dd2 relative to the other parasites, with 13 assays exhibiting average intensities greater than 2 standard deviations higher than observed in other strains. This is consistent with the copy number variation reported in the pfmdr1 locus, with 3–4 copies present in the Dd2 strain relative to a collection of other strains.
(0.35 MB DOC)
PF10_0355 copy number variation measured by Southern blotting. Select parasite isolates were digested with AflIII, EcoRV and XbaI and fragments were detected using probes to portions of the PF10_0355 and dhps genes. Primers used for making probes were: dhps F: 5′-GTG ATT GTG TGG ATC AGA AGA TGA ATA ATC-3′; R: 5′-GGA TTA GGT ATA ACA AAA GGA CCA GAG G-3′; PF10_0355 F: 5′-GGG GAA AGC ATA TAA TAA TAC TAT AGA TGC-3′; R: 5′-CTT GGA GGA ACA AGA ACC CCC TTA TTA TCA-3′ Radioactivity was measured using a phosphorimager plate and quantified using Quantity One software (version 4.6.5). Halofantrine (HFN) response is listed as sensitive (S) or resistant (R) for each strain.
(0.07 MB DOC)
Drug resistance phenotype classification for sweep and GWAS analyses. IC50 data were collected for thirteen anti-malarial drugs against all genotyped parasite lines. Quantitative IC50s were converted into binary "sensitive" and "resistant" phenotypes at the cutoffs shown (see also Table S4). These binary phenotypes were only used for the Haplotype Likelihood Ratio (HLR) test. Drug abbreviations: amodiaquine (ADQ), artemether (ARTM), artesunate (ARTN), artemisinin (ARTS), atovaquone (ATV), chloroquine (CQ), dihydroartemisinin (DHA), halofuginone (HFG), halofantrine (HFN), lumefantrine (LUM), mefloquine (MFQ), piperaquine (PIP) and quinine (QN).
(1.44 MB EPS)
63 parasites used in the study with the name (parasite), geographic origin (region, country), source, and molecular barcode , as well as which samples were included in SNP discovery (SEQ), population characterization (POP), long-range haplotype (LRH), and GWAS analyses. For GWAS, * indicates that the sample was used, but not included in any population cluster for stratified or permuted analyses. The human control sample and the ancestral P. reichenowi sample were not used in any analyses reported here.
(0.12 MB DOC)
Analysis of the ability of SNPs on the array to act as a proxy for or. This ability is measured using the standard correlation metric r2. In our data set, 28% of SNPs in the Brazilian sample (which has the most LD) had a nearby SNP on the array in strong LD (r2>0.5) with it, while in the Senegal sample the proportion was only 16%. Most of the time, therefore, we will only be able to detect association with markers that have been directly typed. The exception is strong selective sweeps, which affect many markers within a region.
(0.18 MB DOC)
Long Range Haplotype (LRH) hits. All REHH hits with Q-value <0.25.
(0.19 MB DOC)
IC50 drug resistance phenotype data (nM). ND: No data.
(0.12 MB DOC)
Parasites used in the GWAS. Parasites used, indicating their nucleotide and amino acid sequence for various positions (indicated by number) in the dhfr, pfcrt, and pfmdr1 gene loci.
(0.24 MB DOC)
PF10_0355 copy number summary for 38 parasites tested by qPCR using the Delta Delta Ct method. Copy number (CN) was compared to the reference locus PF07_0076 and 3D7 was used as a reference strain. A cut-off of 1.4 was used to define PF10_0355 copy number greater than 1; parasites with greater than 1 copy of PF10_0355 are shaded. Parasites are ranked by Halofantrine (HFN) IC50: HFN-sensitive parasites are indicated by an S and HFN-resistant parasites are indicated by an R.
(0.08 MB DOC)
Annotation and GeneID Information for identified genes in Figure 1B.
(0.05 MB DOC)
We gratefully acknowledge B. Coleman, J. Dvorin, M. T. Duraisingh, U. Ribacke, and C. Valim for help with overexpression vectors and useful discussions. T. Burke, N. Mahesh, G. Ramirez, and N. Senaratne provided technical help. Parasites lines or samples were provided by: J. Barnwell, A. P. Dash, C. E. Chitnis, K. Day, A. Djimde, C. Plowe, A. M. Katzin, D. Kyle, S. Thaithong, S. d. L. Moraes, J. Smith; and X. Su. Malaria Research and Reagent Resource Repository provided parasites deposited by: W. E. Collins, D. E. Kyle, L. H. Miller, D. Baruch, W. Trager, D. Walliker, U. Certa, R. Reber-Liske, T. E. Wellems, and Y. Wu (Text S1).
Conceived and designed the experiments: DLH BWB RCW ESL DFW SKV PCS. Performed the experiments: DVT JFC KGB DMR AKL RFD CAJ JSB. Analyzed the data: DVT DJP SFS DEN EA SRG EKK. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: DAMJ IS SRG DY EKK DN OS SM CH NAF EE HMK. Wrote the paper: DVT DJP SFS DEN EA DLH DFW SKV PCS.
- 1. Gardner MJ, Hall N, Fung E, White O, Berriman M, et al. (2002) Genome sequence of the human malaria parasite Plasmodium falciparum. Nature 498–511.MJ GardnerN. HallE. FungO. WhiteM. Berriman2002Genome sequence of the human malaria parasite Plasmodium falciparum.Nature498511
- 2. Volkman SK, Sabeti PC, DeCaprio D, Neafsey DE, Schaffner SF, et al. (2007) A genome-wide map of diversity in Plasmodium falciparum. Nat Genet 39: 113–119.SK VolkmanPC SabetiD. DeCaprioDE NeafseySF Schaffner2007A genome-wide map of diversity in Plasmodium falciparum.Nat Genet39113119
- 3. Jeffares DC, Pain A, Berry A, Cox AV, Stalker J, et al. (2007) Genome variation and evolution of the malaria parasite Plasmodium falciparum. Nat Genet 120–125.DC JeffaresA. PainA. BerryAV CoxJ. Stalker2007Genome variation and evolution of the malaria parasite Plasmodium falciparum.Nat Genet120125
- 4. Mu J, Awadalla P, Duan J, McGee KM, Keebler J, et al. (2007) Genome-wide variation and identification of vaccine targets in the Plasmodium falciparum genome. Nat Genet 126–130.J. MuP. AwadallaJ. DuanKM McGeeJ. Keebler2007Genome-wide variation and identification of vaccine targets in the Plasmodium falciparum genome.Nat Genet126130
- 5. Carret CK, Horrocks P, Konfortov B, Winzeler E, Qureshi M, et al. (2005) Microarray-based comparative genomic analyses of the human malaria parasite Plasmodium falciparum using Affymetrix arrays. Mol Biochem Parasitol 177–186.CK CarretP. HorrocksB. KonfortovE. WinzelerM. Qureshi2005Microarray-based comparative genomic analyses of the human malaria parasite Plasmodium falciparum using Affymetrix arrays.Mol Biochem Parasitol177186
- 6. Kidgell C, Volkman SK, Daily J, Borevitz JO, Plouffe D, et al. (2006) A systematic map of genetic variation in Plasmodium falciparum. PLoS Pathog 2: e57.C. KidgellSK VolkmanJ. DailyJO BorevitzD. Plouffe2006A systematic map of genetic variation in Plasmodium falciparum.PLoS Pathog2e57
- 7. Jiang H, Yi M, Mu J, Zhang L, Ivens A, et al. (2008) Detection of genome-wide polymorphisms in the AT-rich Plasmodium falciparum genome using a high-density microarray. BMC Genomics 398.H. JiangM. YiJ. MuL. ZhangA. Ivens2008Detection of genome-wide polymorphisms in the AT-rich Plasmodium falciparum genome using a high-density microarray.BMC Genomics398
- 8. Dharia NV, Sidhu AB, Cassera MB, Westenberger SJ, Bopp SE, et al. (2009) Use of high-density tiling microarrays to identify mutations globally and elucidate mechanisms of drug resistance in Plasmodium falciparum. Genome Bio R21.NV DhariaAB SidhuMB CasseraSJ WestenbergerSE Bopp2009Use of high-density tiling microarrays to identify mutations globally and elucidate mechanisms of drug resistance in Plasmodium falciparum.Genome BioR21
- 9. Tan JC, Patel JJ, Tan A, Blain JC, Albert TJ, et al. (2009) Optimizing comparative genomic hybridization probes for genotyping and SNP detection in Plasmodium falciparum. Genomics 93: 543–550.JC TanJJ PatelA. TanJC BlainTJ Albert2009Optimizing comparative genomic hybridization probes for genotyping and SNP detection in Plasmodium falciparum.Genomics93543550
- 10. Neafsey DE, Schaffner SF, Volkman SK, Park DJ, Montgomery P, et al. (2008) Genome-wide SNP genotyping highlights the role of natural selection in Plasmodium falciparum population divergence. Genome Bio. R171 p.DE NeafseySF SchaffnerSK VolkmanDJ ParkP. Montgomery2008Genome-wide SNP genotyping highlights the role of natural selection in Plasmodium falciparum population divergence.Genome BioR171
- 11. Mu J, Myers RA, Jiang H, Liu S, Ricklefs S, et al. (2010) Plasmodium falciparum genome-wide scans for positive selection, recombination hot spots and resistance to antimalarial drugs. Nat Genet 42: 268–271.J. MuRA MyersH. JiangS. LiuS. Ricklefs2010Plasmodium falciparum genome-wide scans for positive selection, recombination hot spots and resistance to antimalarial drugs.Nat Genet42268271
- 12. Anderson TJ, Haubold B, Williams JT, Estrada-Franco JG, Richardson L, et al. (2000) Microsatellite markers reveal a spectrum of population structures in the malaria parasite Plasmodium falciparum. Mol Biol Evol 1467–1482.TJ AndersonB. HauboldJT WilliamsJG Estrada-FrancoL. Richardson2000Microsatellite markers reveal a spectrum of population structures in the malaria parasite Plasmodium falciparum.Mol Biol Evol14671482
- 13. Mu J, Awadalla P, Duan J, McGee KM, Joy DA, et al. (2005) Recombination hotspots and population structure in Plasmodium falciparum. PLoS Biol 3: e335.J. MuP. AwadallaJ. DuanKM McGeeDA Joy2005Recombination hotspots and population structure in Plasmodium falciparum.PLoS Biol3e335
- 14. Sabeti PC, Reich DE, Higgins JM, Levine HZ, Richter DJ, et al. (2002) Detecting recent positive selection in the human genome from haplotype structure. Nature 419: 832–837.PC SabetiDE ReichJM HigginsHZ LevineDJ Richter2002Detecting recent positive selection in the human genome from haplotype structure.Nature419832837
- 15. Kang HM, Zaitlen NA, Wade CM, Kirby A, Heckerman D, et al. (2008) Efficient control of population structure in model organism association mapping. Genetics 178: 1709–1723.HM KangNA ZaitlenCM WadeA. KirbyD. Heckerman2008Efficient control of population structure in model organism association mapping.Genetics17817091723
- 16. Lindblad-Toh K, Wade CM, Mikkelsen TS, Karlsson EK, Jaffe DB, et al. (2005) Genome sequence, comparative analysis and haplotype structure of the domestic dog. Nature 438: 803–819.K. Lindblad-TohCM WadeTS MikkelsenEK KarlssonDB Jaffe2005Genome sequence, comparative analysis and haplotype structure of the domestic dog.Nature438803819
- 17. Crabb BS, Triglia T, Waterkeyn JG, Cowman AF (1997) Stable transgene expression in Plasmodium falciparum. Mol Biochem Parasitol 90: 131–144.BS CrabbT. TrigliaJG WaterkeynAF Cowman1997Stable transgene expression in Plasmodium falciparum.Mol Biochem Parasitol90131144
- 18. Pradines B, Hovette P, Fusai T, Atanda HL, Baret E, et al. (2006) Prevalence of in vitro resistance to eleven standard or new antimalarial drugs among Plasmodium falciparum isolates from Pointe-Noire, Republic of the Congo. J Clin Microbiol 44: 2404–2408.B. PradinesP. HovetteT. FusaiHL AtandaE. Baret2006Prevalence of in vitro resistance to eleven standard or new antimalarial drugs among Plasmodium falciparum isolates from Pointe-Noire, Republic of the Congo.J Clin Microbiol4424042408
- 19. Sidhu AB, Uhlemann AC, Valderramos SG, Valderramos JC, Krishna S, et al. (2006) Decreasing pfmdr1 copy number in plasmodium falciparum malaria heightens susceptibility to mefloquine, lumefantrine, halofantrine, quinine, and artemisinin. J Infect Dis 194: 528–535.AB SidhuAC UhlemannSG ValderramosJC ValderramosS. Krishna2006Decreasing pfmdr1 copy number in plasmodium falciparum malaria heightens susceptibility to mefloquine, lumefantrine, halofantrine, quinine, and artemisinin.J Infect Dis194528535
- 20. Chavchich M, Gerena L, Peters J, Chen N, Cheng Q, et al. (2010) Role of pfmdr1 amplification and expression in induction of resistance to artemisinin derivatives in Plasmodium falciparum. Antimicrob Agents Chemother 54: 2455–2464.M. ChavchichL. GerenaJ. PetersN. ChenQ. Cheng2010Role of pfmdr1 amplification and expression in induction of resistance to artemisinin derivatives in Plasmodium falciparum.Antimicrob Agents Chemother5424552464
- 21. Foote SJ, Thompson JK, Cowman AF, Kemp DJ (1989) Amplification of the multidrug resistance gene in some chloroquine-resistant isolates of P. falciparum. Cell 57: 921–930.SJ FooteJK ThompsonAF CowmanDJ Kemp1989Amplification of the multidrug resistance gene in some chloroquine-resistant isolates of P. falciparum.Cell57921930
- 22. Wilson CM, Serrano AE, Wasley A, Bogenschutz MP, Shankar AH, et al. (1989) Amplification of a gene related to mammalian mdr genes in drug-resistant Plasmodium falciparum. Science 244: 1184–1186.CM WilsonAE SerranoA. WasleyMP BogenschutzAH Shankar1989Amplification of a gene related to mammalian mdr genes in drug-resistant Plasmodium falciparum.Science24411841186
- 23. Price RN, Uhlemann AC, Brockman A, McGready R, Ashley E, et al. (2004) Mefloquine resistance in Plasmodium falciparum and increased pfmdr1 gene copy number. Lancet 364: 438–447.RN PriceAC UhlemannA. BrockmanR. McGreadyE. Ashley2004Mefloquine resistance in Plasmodium falciparum and increased pfmdr1 gene copy number.Lancet364438447
- 24. Nair S, Miller B, Barends M, Jaidee A, Patel J, et al. (2008) Adaptive copy number evolution in malaria parasites. PLoS Genet 4: e1000243.S. NairB. MillerM. BarendsA. JaideeJ. Patel2008Adaptive copy number evolution in malaria parasites.PLoS Genet4e1000243
- 25. Anderson TJ, Patel J, Ferdig MT (2009) Gene copy number and malaria biology. Trends Parasitol 25: 336–343.TJ AndersonJ. PatelMT Ferdig2009Gene copy number and malaria biology.Trends Parasitol25336343
- 26. Ribacke U, Mok BW, Wirta V, Normark J, Lundeberg J, et al. (2007) Genome wide gene amplifications and deletions in Plasmodium falciparum. Mol Biochem Parasitol 33–44.U. RibackeBW MokV. WirtaJ. NormarkJ. Lundeberg2007Genome wide gene amplifications and deletions in Plasmodium falciparum.Mol Biochem Parasitol3344
- 27. Hayton K, Su XZ (2008) Drug resistance and genetic mapping in Plasmodium falciparum. Curr Genet 54: 223–239.K. HaytonXZ Su2008Drug resistance and genetic mapping in Plasmodium falciparum.Curr Genet54223239
- 28. Lohmueller KE, Pearce CL, Pike M, Lander ES, Hirschhorn JN (2003) Meta-analysis of genetic association studies supports a contribution of common variants to susceptibility to common disease. Nat Genet 33: 177–182.KE LohmuellerCL PearceM. PikeES LanderJN Hirschhorn2003Meta-analysis of genetic association studies supports a contribution of common variants to susceptibility to common disease.Nat Genet33177182
- 29. Singh S, Soe S, Weisman S, Barnwell JW, Perignon JL, et al. (2009) A conserved multi-gene family induces cross-reactive antibodies effective in defense against Plasmodium falciparum. PLoS ONE 4: e5410.S. SinghS. SoeS. WeismanJW BarnwellJL Perignon2009A conserved multi-gene family induces cross-reactive antibodies effective in defense against Plasmodium falciparum.PLoS ONE4e5410
- 30. Ochola LI, Tetteh KK, Stewart LB, Riitho V, Marsh K, et al. (2010) Allele frequency-based and polymorphism-versus-divergence indices of balancing selection in a new filtered set of polymorphic genes in Plasmodium falciparum. Mol Biol Evol. LI OcholaKK TettehLB StewartV. RiithoK. Marsh2010Allele frequency-based and polymorphism-versus-divergence indices of balancing selection in a new filtered set of polymorphic genes in Plasmodium falciparum.Mol Biol Evol
- 31. Miletti-Gonzalez KE, Chen S, Muthukumaran N, Saglimbeni GN, Wu X, et al. (2005) The CD44 receptor interacts with P-glycoprotein to promote cell migration and invasion in cancer. Cancer Res 65: 6660–6667.KE Miletti-GonzalezS. ChenN. MuthukumaranGN SaglimbeniX. Wu2005The CD44 receptor interacts with P-glycoprotein to promote cell migration and invasion in cancer.Cancer Res6566606667
- 32. Geisler M, Girin M, Brandt S, Vincenzetti V, Plaza S, et al. (2004) Arabidopsis immunophilin-like TWD1 functionally interacts with vacuolar ABC transporters. Mol Biol Cell 15: 3393–3405.M. GeislerM. GirinS. BrandtV. VincenzettiS. Plaza2004Arabidopsis immunophilin-like TWD1 functionally interacts with vacuolar ABC transporters.Mol Biol Cell1533933405
- 33. Beese SE, Negishi T, Levin DE (2009) Identification of positive regulators of the yeast fps1 glycerol channel. PLoS Genet 5: e1000738.SE BeeseT. NegishiDE Levin2009Identification of positive regulators of the yeast fps1 glycerol channel.PLoS Genet5e1000738
- 34. (2005) Halofantrine and fatal cardiac arrhythmia. GSK: Global Clinical Safety and Pharmacovigilance. 2005Halofantrine and fatal cardiac arrhythmia.GSKGlobal Clinical Safety and Pharmacovigilance
- 35. Bouchaud O, Imbert P, Touze JE, Dodoo AN, Danis M, et al. (2009) Fatal cardiotoxicity related to halofantrine: a review based on a worldwide safety data base. Malar J 8: 289.O. BouchaudP. ImbertJE TouzeAN DodooM. Danis2009Fatal cardiotoxicity related to halofantrine: a review based on a worldwide safety data base.Malar J8289
- 36. Trager W, Jensen JB (1976) Human malaria parasites in continuous culture. Science 193: 673–675.W. TragerJB Jensen1976Human malaria parasites in continuous culture.Science193673675
- 37. Baniecki ML, Wirth DF, Clardy J (2007) High-throughput Plasmodium falciparum growth assay for malaria drug discovery. Antimicrob Agents Chemother 51: 716–723.ML BanieckiDF WirthJ. Clardy2007High-throughput Plasmodium falciparum growth assay for malaria drug discovery.Antimicrob Agents Chemother51716723
- 38. Webster HK, Boudreau EF, Pavanand K, Yongvanitchit K, Pang LW (1985) Antimalarial drug susceptibility testing of Plasmodium falciparum in Thailand using a microdilution radioisotope method. Am J Trop Med Hyg 34: 228–235.HK WebsterEF BoudreauK. PavanandK. YongvanitchitLW Pang1985Antimalarial drug susceptibility testing of Plasmodium falciparum in Thailand using a microdilution radioisotope method.Am J Trop Med Hyg34228235
- 39. Daniels R, Volkman SK, Milner DA, Mahesh N, Neafsey DE, et al. (2008) A general SNP-based molecular barcode for Plasmodium falciparum identification and tracking. Malar J 7: 223.R. DanielsSK VolkmanDA MilnerN. MaheshDE Neafsey2008A general SNP-based molecular barcode for Plasmodium falciparum identification and tracking.Malar J7223
- 40. (2007) 2007BRLMM-P: a Genotype Calling Method for the SNP 5.0 Array http://www.affymetrix.com/support/technical/whitepapers/brlmmp_whitepaper.pdf. BRLMM-P: a Genotype Calling Method for the SNP 5.0 Array http://www.affymetrix.com/support/technical/whitepapers/brlmmp_whitepaper.pdf.
- 41. Patterson N, Price AL, Reich D (2006) Population structure and eigenanalysis. PLoS Genet 2: e190.N. PattersonAL PriceD. Reich2006Population structure and eigenanalysis.PLoS Genet2e190
- 42. Hudson RR, Slatkin M, Maddison WP (1992) Estimation of levels of gene flow from DNA sequence data. Genetics 132: 583–589.RR HudsonM. SlatkinWP Maddison1992Estimation of levels of gene flow from DNA sequence data.Genetics132583589
- 43. Hill WG, Robertson A (1968) Linkage Disequilibrium in Finite Populations. Theoretical and Applied Genetics 38: 226–231.WG HillA. Robertson1968Linkage Disequilibrium in Finite Populations.Theoretical and Applied Genetics38226231
- 44. Sabeti PC, Reich DE, Higgins JM, Levine HZ, Richter DJ, et al. (2002) Detecting recent positive selection in the human genome from haplotype structure. Nature 832–837.PC SabetiDE ReichJM HigginsHZ LevineDJ Richter2002Detecting recent positive selection in the human genome from haplotype structure.Nature832837
- 45. Purcell S, Neale B, Todd-Brown K, Thomas L, Ferreira MA, et al. (2007) PLINK: a tool set for whole-genome association and population-based linkage analyses. Am J Hum Genet 81: 559–575.S. PurcellB. NealeK. Todd-BrownL. ThomasMA Ferreira2007PLINK: a tool set for whole-genome association and population-based linkage analyses.Am J Hum Genet81559575
- 46. Ferreira ID, Rosario VE, Cravo PV (2006) Real-time quantitative PCR with SYBR Green I detection for estimating copy numbers of nine drug resistance candidate genes in Plasmodium falciparum. Malar J 5: 1.ID FerreiraVE RosarioPV Cravo2006Real-time quantitative PCR with SYBR Green I detection for estimating copy numbers of nine drug resistance candidate genes in Plasmodium falciparum.Malar J51
- 47. Triglia T, Duraisingh MT, Good RT, Cowman AF (2005) Reticulocyte-binding protein homologue 1 is required for sialic acid-dependent invasion into human erythrocytes by Plasmodium falciparum. Mol Microbiol 55: 162–174.T. TrigliaMT DuraisinghRT GoodAF Cowman2005Reticulocyte-binding protein homologue 1 is required for sialic acid-dependent invasion into human erythrocytes by Plasmodium falciparum.Mol Microbiol55162174
- 48. Fidock DA, Wellems TE (1997) Transformation with human dihydrofolate reductase renders malaria parasites insensitive to WR99210 but does not affect the intrinsic activity of proguanil. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 94: 10931–10936.DA FidockTE Wellems1997Transformation with human dihydrofolate reductase renders malaria parasites insensitive to WR99210 but does not affect the intrinsic activity of proguanil.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A941093110936