To extend the understanding of host genetic determinants of HIV-1 control, we performed a genome-wide association study in a cohort of 2,554 infected Caucasian subjects. The study was powered to detect common genetic variants explaining down to 1.3% of the variability in viral load at set point. We provide overwhelming confirmation of three associations previously reported in a genome-wide study and show further independent effects of both common and rare variants in the Major Histocompatibility Complex region (MHC). We also examined the polymorphisms reported in previous candidate gene studies and fail to support a role for any variant outside of the MHC or the chemokine receptor cluster on chromosome 3. In addition, we evaluated functional variants, copy-number polymorphisms, epistatic interactions, and biological pathways. This study thus represents a comprehensive assessment of common human genetic variation in HIV-1 control in Caucasians.
The ability to spontaneously control HIV-1 upon infection is highly variable between individuals. To evaluate the contribution of variation in human genes to differences in plasma viral load and in disease progression rates, we performed a genome-wide association study in >2,500 HIV–infected individuals. This study achieved two goals: it completed the analysis of common variation influencing viral control, and it re-assessed the majority of previously reported genetic associations. We show that genetic variants located near the HLA-B and HLA-C genes are the strongest determinants of viral control, and that other independent associations exist in the same region of chromosome 6, the Major Histocompatibility Complex, known to contain a large number of genes involved in immune defense. We could not replicate most of the previously published associations with HIV candidate genes in this large, well-characterized cohort. Overall, common human genetic variation, together with demographic variables, explains up to 22% of the variability in viral load in the Caucasian population.
Citation: Fellay J, Ge D, Shianna KV, Colombo S, Ledergerber B, Cirulli ET, et al. (2009) Common Genetic Variation and the Control of HIV-1 in Humans. PLoS Genet5(12): e1000791. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1000791
Editor: Mark I. McCarthy, University of Oxford, United Kingdom
Received: June 15, 2009; Accepted: November 25, 2009; Published: December 24, 2009
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Public Domain declaration which stipulates that, once placed in the public domain, this work may be freely reproduced, distributed, transmitted, modified, built upon, or otherwise used by anyone for any lawful purpose.
Funding: Funding was provided by the NIAID Center for HIV/AIDS Vaccine Immunology (CHAVI) grant AI067854. This project has also been funded in part with federal funds from the National Cancer Institute, National Institutes of Health, under Contract No. HHSN261200800001E, and by the Intramural Research Program of the NIH, National Cancer Institute, Center for Cancer Research. The content of this publication does not necessarily reflect the views or policies of the Department of Health and Human Services, nor does mention of trade names, commercial products, or organizations imply endorsement by the U.S. Government. AT and SEA are supported by the Swiss National Science Foundation and by the Infectigen Foundation. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
The clinical outcome of HIV-1 infection is highly variable and determined by complex interactions between virus, host and environment. Several human genetic factors have been reported to modulate HIV-1 disease ,, but current knowledge only explains a small fraction of the observed variability in the course of infection. Our first genome-wide association study (GWAS) of human genetic variants that associate with HIV-1 control analyzed 486 individuals of European ancestry and identified two genome-wide significant determinants of viremia at set point, and one determinant of disease progression . The 3 single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) collectively explained 14% of the variation in viral load at set point and 10% of the variation in disease progression. All 3 were located in the Major Histocompatibility Complex (MHC) region on chromosome 6, confirming, in a genome-wide context, the essential role played by the MHC region in HIV-1 control ,,. Since then, the findings have been replicated by several independent groups that used either targeted genotyping ,, or whole genome approaches ,.
The power of our initial study was limited to the detection of common variants (with minor allele frequency of 5% or more) which explain a sizable fraction of the phenotypic variability: it had an 80% power of identifying SNPs that explain at least 5% of the variability. Here we have increased the sample size to 2554 which allows us to provide a much more thorough investigation of the role of common variation in the control of HIV-1: considering the final number of participants included in the analysis, the study was powered to detect the effects of common variants down to 1.3% of explained variability.
One surprising feature of the first genome-wide investigation was that it failed to identify any of the many non-MHC candidate gene variants that have been reported to associate with HIV-1 disease outcomes over the past 15 years. Candidate gene studies claimed associations for variants in genes selected for their known or suspected role in HIV-1 pathogenesis and in immune response , [compiled in http://www.hiv-pharmacogenomics.org]. Collectively, this body of work has implicated various components of innate, adaptive, and intrinsic immunity in HIV-1 control, cellular co-factors important in viral life cycle, and quite unexpected candidates such as the vitamin D receptor. We here use our large sample size and the power of genome-wide data, which allows precise correction for population stratification, to evaluate most candidate gene discoveries.
Genome-wide analysis also makes it possible to assess genetic interactions, copy number polymorphisms, enrichment of gene sets and of functional variants: these analyses were pursued in the present work. Collectively, our study circumscribes the impact of common variation in the control of HIV-1 in an adult and predominantly male Caucasian population.
A total of 2554 HIV-1 infected individuals of self-reported Caucasian ancestry were genotyped on Illumina whole-genome chips (Table S1). Participants were recruited between 1984 and 2007 in one of the 9 cohorts forming the Euro-CHAVI Consortium (N = 1397, including 486 subjects that were included in our previous study , 75.7% male, median age: 33 years) or in the MACS cohort (N = 1157, 100% male, median age: 33 years). A subset of 1113 patients had a proven date of seroconversion (“seroconverters”) and the remainder had a confirmed stable viremia profile but no known date of infection (“seroprevalent” patients). Several quality control steps (Text S1) resulted in the exclusion of 115 individuals with insufficient genotype call rates, of 17 individuals that were found to be genetically related with another study subject, and of 5 individuals with a gender discrepancy between phenotype and genotype data. To control for population stratification, we performed a principal component analysis of the whole-genome genotyping data (Eigenstrat , Text S1), which identified 12 significant axes after exclusion of 55 outlier subjects. The most significant principal component is a north-to-south European axis that has already been described  (Figure S1). A total of 2362 individuals were included in the set point association analyses (including 486 subjects studied before ), and 1071 seroconverters were eligible for the analysis of disease progression (including 337 subjects studied before ). A subset of 1204 subjects had complete 4-digit HLA Class I results and could be included in models assessing the respective influences of SNPs and HLA alleles on HIV-1 control.
Common variants and variation in viral load at set point
All QC-passed SNPs (Text S1, Table S11) were tested for association with HIV-1 viremia at set point in separate linear regression models that included gender, age, and the 12 significant PC axes as covariates. The global distribution of resulting p-values was very close to the null expectation (λ = 1.006, Figure S2) indicating that stratification was adequately controlled . Male gender and older age both associated with higher set point (p = 1.9E-21 and p = 2.6E-05, respectively) and explained 4% of the inter-individual variability. The population sub-structure, reflected in the 12 significant PC axes, explained an additional 3.4%.
The 2 SNPs previously reported as genome-wide significant  were confirmed to be the strongest determinants of variation in HIV-1 viral load (Figure 1 and Figure 2): rs2395029, an HCP5 T>G variant, which is known to be an almost perfect proxy for HLA-B*5701 in Caucasians , (p = 4.5E–35), and rs9264942, a T>C SNP located in the 5′ region of HLA-C, 35 kb away from transcription initiation (p = 5.9E–32). Of note, the association signals were also convincingly genome-wide significant in an analysis restricted to the subjects that were not included in our initial study (Table 1). Each SNP explained 5 to 6% of the variability in set point viremia, as determined by the increase in the r2 value of the respective linear regression models: the effect size estimates are smaller in the expanded data set than in the previously reported study. This is due, at least in part, to the inclusion of seroprevalent subjects with less stringent phenotype definition. Interestingly, we observed a break in the strong linkage disequilibrium (LD) between HCP5 and HLA-B in 9/1204 subjects with HLA Class I results (0.7%, r2 = 0.93): the set point values were lower for the 4 patients that had B*5701 without the rs2395029 minor allele than for the 5 patients with a G at rs2395029 but without B*5701 (median [IQR] log10 HIV-1 cp/ml = 3.14 [2.77–3.68] vs. 4.22 [4.14–4.28] respectively (Table S2); p = 0.05, Kruskal-Wallis rank test). Consequently, the association with set point was stronger for B*5701 (p = 3.8E–19) than it was for rs2395029 (p = 1.7E–17) in the same subset of patients.
Representation of a 3 Mb stretch in the MHC region, encompassing the HLA Class I gene loci and the genome-wide significant SNPs identified in the study (red dots represents SNPs with p-value<5E–08). Results are shown for set point (upper plot) and for progression (lower plot). The figure was created with WGAViewer .
HIV-1 viremia at set point strongly associates with rs2395029 (upper panel) and rs9264942 (lower panel) genotypes. The rs2395029 minor allele G has a frequency of 4.8% and each copy of this allele associates with a 0.7 log lower set point. The rs9264942 minor allele C has a frequency of 41.2%, and each copy of this allele associates with a 0.3 log lower set point. Mean and Standard Deviation (error bars) are represented for the respective genotypes.
A major challenge in assessing association evidence in the MHC is the long range pattern of LD, complicating the definitive identification of causal variants and making it necessary to consider evidence for association in the region as a whole. For this reason, we evaluated the evidence for independent effects of the two reported associations. Since the HCP5 and the HLA-C variants are in partial LD (r2 = 0.06, D′ = 0.86), the combined strength of their associations with set point is less than the sum of the signals measured separately. It is also interesting to note that in 95% of cases the rs2395029 minor allele, tagging B*5701, is found in combination with the controlling C allele at HLA-C rs9264942. This means that the protective effect in this haplotype is a combination of the effect of both alleles and that analyses that are not adjusted for the HLA-C variant overestimate the B*5701-related effect. Nonetheless, nested regression models clearly demonstrated that each of the variants is independently genome-wide significant (p = 1.8E–23 for rs2395029; p = 2.4E–20 for rs9264942). We therefore can conclude unequivocally that the two SNPs represent independent effects: they together explain 9% of the variability in HIV-1 set point.
Further independent associations in the MHC region
We next addressed the question of whether there are any additional, independent and significant SNP effects in the MHC region. In addition to the top 2 associated variants, 86 other SNPs met the criteria of genome-wide significance (p<5E–08), all located in the MHC (Figure 1, Table S9).
We included a total of 331 MHC SNPs with p<1E–04 in a conservative forward selection algorithm within a linear regression model. SNPs were tested and selected into the model one at a time, independently of the top 2 associated variants and of the other covariates (gender, age and Eigenstrat axes). In order to control for multiple testing, a permutation procedure was performed to assess the empirical significance cut-off value. Four additional SNPs were found to significantly associate with set point in models including the previously associated variants (Table S3):  rs259919, located in an intron of the uncharacterized C6orf12 gene, 3.5 kb away from the ZNRD1 gene in the 5′ region;  rs9468692, located in the 3′ region of the TRIM10 gene, in high LD (r2 = 0.87) with a non-synonymous coding SNP in the first exon of TRIM10 - rs12212092: 279A>G; H65R, which is predicted to be a high-risk change by FastSNP  (non-conservative amino acid change; possibly splicing regulation);  rs9266409, located in the 3′ region of HLA-B, 12 kb away;  rs8192591, a non-synonymous coding SNP located in the 9th exon of the NOTCH4 gene: 1739A>G; S534G (conservative amino acid change; possibly influencing splicing). We emphasize that these analyses demonstrate that there are further independent effects in the MHC region, but they do not prove that the specific SNPs implicated are responsible for those effects. Some or all of these SNPs are most likely markers for one or more variants that have not been genotyped and which provide aspects of viral control independent of the two previously reported associations.
As one possible contribution to these associations we assessed the HLA Class I alleles in the subset of 1204 subjects who had full MHC typing results. The 4-digit alleles were tested separately and in models including the identified MHC SNPs (Table 2, Table S4). 15 alleles were found to associate with set point, but only 4 of them (A*3201, B*1302, B*2705 and B*3502) had an independent effect that was still detectable in models including the top associated SNPs. Several HLA-C alleles associated significantly with viral control before but not after adjustment for the top SNPs (Table 2, Table S6). This is partly because all HLA-C alleles are in LD with the HLA-C -35 rs9264942. They can in fact be perfectly divided into 2 mutually exclusive groups on the basis of their LD with the rs9264942 C or T allele. The C-related alleles, as a group, strongly associated with lower setpoint (p = 2.8E–14) but failed to entirely recapitulate the rs9264942 association signal (p = 8.4E–16 in this group). Homozygosity for the HLA Class I loci also showed a weak independent association (p = 0.03 after adjustment for the SNPs). Altogether, a model including 6 SNPs, 4 alleles and homozygosity status shows that MHC variation explains 12% of the set point variability in this cohort.
HIV-1 disease progression
We defined HIV-1 disease progression as the drop of CD4 T cell count to below 350 cells/ul or the initiation of potent antiretroviral treatment (cART) following a CD4 T cell count <500 cells/ul. A total of 1071 individuals with known date of seroconversion and at least two CD4 T cell determinations in absence of cART were included in a survival analysis. Of those, 765 (71.4%) progressed during follow-up: 612 (80%) because of a CD4 T cell value <350/ul and 153 (20%) because they started treatment with <500 CD4 T cells per ul.
The top associated variants were HCP5/B*5701 rs2395029 (p = 1.2E–11) and HLA-C rs9264942 (p = 6.4E–12) (Figure 1 and Figure 3, Table S10). If viral load at set point is added to the models, the association signals are much weaker (p = 0.001 for rs2395029 and p = 0.02 for rs9264942), demonstrating that the HCP5/B*5701 and HLA-C effects on disease progression are mainly driven by their impact on early viral control. Another set of variants reached genome-wide significance: rs9261174, rs3869068, rs2074480, rs7758512, rs9261129, rs2301753 and rs2074479 (p = 1.8E–08), in high-LD and located around the ZNDR1 and RNF39 genes, close to the HLA-A locus in the MHC region. This association is largely independent of viremia (p = 4.7E–05 in a model including set point as covariate), suggesting that a different mechanism of action is here modulating HIV disease progression. The causal variant(s) responsible for this association remains largely undetermined, and it seems possible that the association depends on the contribution of multiple causal sites. We do note, however, that no single HLA Class I allele can account for the association. Specifically, the recent claim that it is due entirely to the A10 serogroup of HLA-A alleles  is not supported by the LD data. When this claim is evaluated by including the A10 alleles in a regression model and testing the significance of the increased variation explained by the ZNRD1 SNPs, we observe an independent additional effect of the SNPs (p = 0.03). Indeed, the identified SNPs still associate with progression in individuals without HLA-A10 (Figure S3). Conversely, HLA-A10 alleles do not significantly associate with progression in models that include the ZNRD1 SNPs. The fact that A10 alleles (notably A*2501 and A*2601) are in LD with the ZNRD1 SNPs (r2 = 0.46) is not sufficient evidence to assign responsibility for the association, although A10 may contribute to the association signal.
Results are shown for the 3 most associated SNPs indentified in the genome-wide progression scan and for CCR5-Δ32. The survival curves show, for each genotype, the proportion of the individuals that do not reach a progression outcome over the first 10 years after seroconversion.
Genetic variants in HIV candidate genes
We tested a total of 34 SNPs in 21 genes, representing 27 previously reported associations with HIV-1 control (individual SNPs or haplotypes) (Table 3) ,,. Nine SNPs were directly genotyped and 12 had a good proxy (r2>0.8) on all the chips that we used. Two were present on the Human1M chips only and 9 were not represented: these 11 SNPs were genotyped by TaqMan assays. The CCL3L1 copy number polymorphism was also assessed and the absence of any association with HIV-1 control has been recently reported .
The CCR5-Δ32 variant, a 32 bp deletion in the main HIV-1 co-receptor that protects against HIV-1 acquisition when present in homozygous form ,,, strongly associated with both set point (p = 1.7E–10) and progression (p = 3.5E–07). CCR5-Δ32 explained 1.7% of the variability in viral control. Only two other variants showed significant associations: The CCR5 promoter variant P1 , found on a haplotype known to increase CCR5 expression , associated with higher set point and faster progression, whereas the CCR2-64I variant, a Valine to Isoleucine change in the HIV-1 minor receptor CCR2 , associated with better viral control (Table 3). They together explained 1% of the variability in viral control. Partial association results for the two CCR5 variants in a subset of our study population were reported elsewhere .
Effect of identified genetic determinants throughout the full phenotype range
By design, this study focused on the control of HIV-1 as a quantitative trait, with a particular focus on the amount of virus during the set point period. One important question to address therefore is whether the genetic determinants identified influence viral control throughout the full phenotypic range, from those with low to high viral loads, and from slow to fast progression times. To address this, we looked at allele frequencies in individuals that maintained variable degrees of viral control: we found a consistent enrichment of the protective alleles in categories of subjects with good viral control or slow disease progression rate in comparison to subjects with poor control or rapid progression (Figure 4).
The bar graphs show the allelic distribution of the 4 variants that have a genome-wide significant association with HIV-1 set point and/or disease progression in subsets of the study population. Groups were defined according to HIV-1 set point (left-hand side graphs) and to progression time (right-hand side graphs).
The large genotypic and phenotypic data set generated in this study is a resource that allows a more in-depth exploration of the role of human genetic variation: we ran additional analyses to test whether there is any evidence from the existing data, which mainly represents common variants, for other determinants of viral control.
We first performed a genome-wide screen (Text S1) for SNPs that modify the effect of rs2395029 (HCP5/B*5701), rs9264942 (HLA-C) rs9261174 (ZNRD1/RNF39) and CCR5-Δ32: no interaction was large enough to reach genome-wide significance. To evaluate common structural variation, we tested 285 SNPs that were identified as tags for copy number polymorphisms (CNP) in HapMap CEU samples . No significant association was observed when theses CNP-tagging SNPs were considered as a set. We also used a gene set enrichment analysis (GSEA) , to ask whether groups of genes or pathways were enriched in SNPs with low association p-values: 5 gene sets were significant, some of them with suggestive evidence of involvement in HIV-1 pathogenesis (Table S7). Finally, we developed a permutation procedure to test whether genetic variants with known functional role were more likely to associate with differences in HIV-1 control than non-functional SNPs: we observed a significant effect that was however limited to the MHC region (p = 0.001) (Figure S4).
The results presented here reaffirm the central role of the MHC in HIV-1 control by first confirming with certainty the independence of two association signals in the genomic region that encompasses HLA-B and HLA-C. These common variants show the strongest association with both viral set point and progression. We initially speculated that the HCP5 gene itself, which contains the top-associated SNP rs2395029, contributes to HIV-1 control , but recent epidemiologic and functional reports ,, suggest that the gene and the variant itself have no such effect. In addition, we here present data from a small number of subjects with a recombination event between HCP5 and HLA-B indicating that HLA-B*5701 is the main contributor to the association signal: the HCP5 variant is therefore likely to be only a marker for the effect of HLA-B*5701 and possibly of other protective variants present on the same haplotype. The HLA-C variant rs9264942, which is in partial LD with all HLA-C alleles (Table S6), associates with mRNA and protein expression levels of HLA-C , (R. Thomas, M.C., personal communication): it is thus likely that this SNP is in fact a marker of the effect of HLA-C expression on HIV-1 control: more work is needed to understand the precise immunological and biological function of HLA-C in the context of HIV-1 infection.
Beyond the top 2 associated variants, we demonstrate that there are other, independent, genetic contributors to HIV-1 control in the MHC. The intricacy of the LD pattern in the region makes it difficult to find causal variants with certainty. Nevertheless, using both SNP and HLA Class I data, we identify additional variants that associate independently with viral set point and together explain at least 3.5% of the variability, on top of the 9% explained by the first 2 SNPs. We do not know at this stage whether any of the 4 SNPs identified in our permutation analysis have a direct functional role, though a non-synonymous coding change in a TRIM gene represents an attractive candidate . Several of the HLA alleles that independently associate with control have good functional support for their involvement in HIV-1 pathogenesis: B*2705 presents epitopes that lead to efficient viral restriction , while B*3502 is a member of the B35Px group  that, according to recent data obtained on B*3503, has a preferential binding to the inhibitory myelomonocytic MHC class I receptor ILT4 on myeloid dendritic cells, which results in dysfunctional antigen-presenting properties of these cells (XG Yu, personal communication). Functional studies of the gene variants identified in the MHC and deeper understanding of the structure of the associations between SNPs and surrounding HLA alleles  are warranted.
We show data that question most previously reported associations in HIV-1 candidate genes (Table 3 and ). The chemokine/chemokine receptor locus on chromosome 3 is the only non-MHC region with convincing association evidence for an impact of genetic variation on HIV-1 phenotypes. Homozygosity for CCR5Δ32 is known to confer almost complete protection against infection ,, and we here show that heterozygosity for the 32 bp deletion is the strongest protective factor for VL control and progression outside of MHC. While it is possible that our analyses missed some real candidate gene associations, our failure to replicate most previous reports confirms the critical importance of adopting stringent standards for significance level and stratification control ,,.
Our study was powered to detect a single marker association that explains just above 1% of the inter-individual variability in HIV-1 control. In the absence of further significant association at the individual SNP level, we sought to comprehensively assess the impact of common variation by using the genotyping results in several additional ways: these analyses provide no evidence for strong interactions between the MHC or CCR5 polymorphisms and any other common variant, or for CNP-related effects. We also used a more global approach that shows enrichment for associated variants in some interesting gene sets, but was not designed to identify novel genetic determinants. Limitations to these additional analyses include  the deliberately limited scope of our interaction screen, in which only pairs of SNPs including one that is significant have been tested (Text S1): we did not run any exhaustive SNP by SNP or haplotype analyses;  the use of SNP tags for copy number assessment, which limits the analysis to previously described deletions and duplications that are in LD with common SNPs.
All variants securely identified in this study together explain 13% of the observed variability in HIV-1 viremia in a population of mostly male Caucasian adults. The addition of gender, age and residual population structure to the genetic model pushes this figure up to 22%. These fractions compare favorably to what is known for other complex traits, where dozens of SNPs often explain only a few percent of the variance. Comparable studies are certainly needed in additional populations, notably in other ethnic groups, in women and in children to fully assess the impact of common human genetic variation in HIV-1 control.
Many factors certainly contribute to the large unexplained portion of the inter-individual variability (viral genetics/fitness, environment, stochastic biological variation, noise in phenotype determination), but it is also expected that much more is attributable to human genetic variation. The data presented here suggest that common polymorphisms are unlikely to add much, unless more complex gene by gene and gene-environment interactions play a major role in the genetic architecture of HIV-1 control. After an era of candidate genes studies and a first wave of large-scale genomics projects that could only interrogate common genetic variation, resequencing strategies to identify rare causal variants, as well as integration of multiple genome-level data (genomic DNA, epigenetic marks, transcriptome, siRNA screens) will prove essential to better appreciate the global contribution of the human genome to HIV-1 control.
All participating centers provided local institutional review board approval for genetic analysis, and each participant provided informed consent for genetic testing.
Patients have been included from two sources (Text S1):  Euro-CHAVI, a Consortium of 8 European and 1 Australian Cohorts/Studies; and  MACS, the Multicenter AIDS Cohort Study that enrolled homosexual and bisexual men in 4 US cities. In general, patients had viral load (VL) and CD4 count monitoring at least 6 monthly. Eligible patients had 3 or more stable plasma HIV RNA results in the absence of antiretroviral treatment, and met one of the following criteria: a valid seroconversion date estimation proven by documents or biological markers; or, for seroprevalent patients, VL data over a period of at least 3 years, diverging by no more than 0.5 log. Only individuals with known date of seroconversion and at least 2 CD4 T cell determinations in absence of potent antiretroviral treatment (cART) were included in the progression analysis.
Determination of phenotypes
HIV-1 set point was defined as the average of the remaining VL results after careful assessment of each individual data and elimination of VL outliers: see Text S1 for criteria used to identify and exclude outlier VL data. Of note, our phenotype definition leads to the exclusion rapid progressors that never reach a stable VL plateau. The disease progression phenotype was defined as  the drop of CD4 T cells below 350/ul, or  the initiation of cART, but only if the last CD4 T cell count before cART start was <500/ul. This later criterion was made necessary by the different rationales behind treatment initiation between patients and over time: a large part of patients starting cART with CD4 T cell counts approaching the 350/ul threshold did so because their CD4 slope actually showed a significant decrease, whereas most of patients who started treatment with normal or subnormal CD4 T cell counts had stable CD4 T cell profiles. Since progression has been represented in a number of different ways in genetic studies, we used the known genetic determinants to confirm that our measure is the most accurate, by comparing it to survival analyses that used cART start either as a censoring event (i.e. all patients starting cART are considered non-progressors) or as a progression event (i.e. all patients starting cART are considered progressors) (Table S8).
All participants were genotyped using Illumina BeadChips: We used HumanHap550 Beadchips for 1633 samples and Human1M Beadchips for 921 samples. Most common SNPs found in the HapMap CEU population are readily covered by both chips; however, it is not clear yet whether common variants that have not been genotyped in the HapMap project will be measured equally well. To increase the coverage of the MHC region in the samples genotyped with the 550K chip, we designed a customized MHC-chip that contained an additional 8000 SNPs, largely overlapping with the variants that are present on the Human1M chip. We carried out a series of data cleaning and quality control procedures: SNPs were filtered based on missingness (drop if call rate <99%), MAF (drop if <0.006) and Hardy-Weinberg Equilibrium deviation. Participants were filtered based on call rate, gender check (heterozygosity testing), cryptic relatedness and population structure (see EIGENSTRAT below). The genetic variants located in HIV-1 candidate genes that were not represented directly or indirectly on the genome-wide chips were independently genotyped with TaqMan assays.
The quality control of the genotyping data included a check on the gender specification obtained from the phenotype database, using the observed genotypes of SNPs on chromosome X and Y. Subjects that were identified as “male” in the phenotype file but had a significant amount of heterozygous X genotypes (> = 1%), as well as subjects that was identified as “female” in the phenotype file but had a high frequency of homozygous X genotypes (> = 80%) and Y genotype readings were excluded.
Control for population stratification
To control for the possibility of spurious associations resulting from population stratification we used a modified EIGENSTRAT approach. This method derives the principal components of the correlations among gene variants and corrects for those correlations in the association tests. In principle therefore the principal components in the analyses should reflect population ancestry. Having noticed however that some of the leading axes depend on other sources of correlation, such as sets of variants near one another that show extended association (LD), we inspected the SNP loadings and followed a series of pruning procedures to ensure that EIGENSTRAT axes reflected only effects that applied equally across the whole genome (Text S1).
Genome-wide association analysis
The core association analyses on HIV-1 setpoint focused on single-marker genotype-trend tests of the quality control–passed SNPs using linear regression and including age, gender, and the significant EIGENSTRAT axes values as covariates. Associations with progression were tested using a Cox proportional hazards model. We assessed significance with a Bonferroni correction taking into account 1 million tests (p-value cutoff = 5E–08).
Search for independent associations in the MHC
To search for additional SNPs effects in the MHC region we used a forward selection algorithm to investigate all MHC SNPs with p<1E–04 (N = 331). The top 2 associated variants and the standard covariates were fixed in a linear regression model, while new SNPs were added and selected into the model one at a time. In the forward selection process, a newly selected SNP is expected to explain a certain proportion of the set point variation independently of all variables already in the model. To control for multiple testing, a permutation procedure was used to assess the empirical significance cut-off value. In the permutation, the LD patterns among SNPs were retained while the associations between SNPs and set point were permuted. 1000 permutation runs were performed and the 5th percentile of the empirical distributions of the partial R-squares and the p-values of the 1st, 2nd, 3rd, etc. selected SNPs were recorded and compared to the observed sample statistics. The permutation p-value was defined as the probability that the statistics observed in the permutation was more extreme than the statistics observed in the real sample. The forward selection algorithm is expected to be conservative. To verify this, a large-scale statistical simulation was performed, considering different effect sizes, various LD patterns among SNPs and different sample sizes (Text S1). The simulation results confirmed that the forward selection algorithm with permutation procedure is conservative.
We performed a two-way interaction test between each QC-passed SNP and the top associated variants. For each genome-wide significant polymorphism, the screening procedure involved the calculation of the p-value associated with each of the ∼1 million multivariate linear models incorporating the 2 polymorphisms. The p-value associated with the interaction term for this model was retained and then the top p-values for all ∼1 million tests considered. This approach followed recommendations that the search space for interactions can be appropriately reduced and therefore the power can be improved by focusing the search on pairs of polymorphisms including at least one that is known to be significant .
Gene set enrichment analysis (GSEA)
The SNPs that were represented in all genotyping chips were mapped to their closest gene (if <500 kb away) and used in the GSEA analysis if minor allele frequency was >0.05, Hardy-Weinberg Equilibrium test p-value was >0.001, and at least 90% individuals were successfully genotyped. Among the 639 canonical pathway gene sets that are represented in the Molecular Signatures Database (MsigDB, http://www.broad.mit.edu/gsea/msigdb/collections.jsp), we tested the 298 gene sets that had at least 20 and at most 200 genes represented in the study (Text S1).
A permutation procedure was developed to test whether genetic variants with known functional role were more likely to have a lower p-values distribution than supposedly neutral variants (Text S1). We compared the overall p-value distribution of 12,535 putatively functional polymorphisms, including stop-gained, stop-lost, frame-shift coding, non-synonymous coding, and essential splicing site genetic variants, with the global distribution of p-values of all genotyped SNPs (with 10,000 permutations). We also ran the same analysis for the MHC region only (318 functional variants) and for the rest of the genome (12217 functional variants).
Distribution of individual eigen values along the first axis identified by principal component analysis of the genotyping data (Eigenstrat). Participants are grouped by country of recruitment. The most important contributor to population stratification in our Caucasian population is a North-to-South European ancestry axis. Participants from the USA and Australia are most similar to northern Europeans.
(0.05 MB DOC)
QQ-plot of observed versus expected -log(p-values) for all SNPs in the set point association analysis. The plot shows no deviation from the expected line, except for the top 3000 SNPs (0.3%).
(0.03 MB DOC)
Associations between the SNPs identified in the ZNRD1/RNF39 region and disease progression in individuals with and without HLA-A alleles belonging to the serogroup A10. The rs9261174 minor allele C shows the strongest association with progression in individuals that also have an HLA-A10 (green), but it also associates when HLA-A10 is absent (red). The LD (r2) between the ZNRD1 SNP rs9261174 and HLA-A10 as a group is 0.46. It is 0.17 for HLA-A*2501, 0.25 for A*2601, 0.00 for A*3402 and 0.02 for A*6601.
(0.06 MB DOC)
P-value distribution of functional variants. P-value distributions of 12,535 functional genetic variants (red, A) in comparison with 12,535 randomly selected intergenic variants (red, B), both in the background of p-value distributions generated from 10,000 permutations (blue, A and B). The upper figures show the distributions of ranked -log10(P) for each of the observed and permutated p-value series. The lower figures show the distributions of the sum -log10(P) generated from the permutated series (blue), their 95% cutoff of empirical probability (cyan), and the relative position and probability of the observed sum -log10(P) (red) in these distributions. The sum -log10(P) from the observed functional genetic variants (red, A) is higher than what would be expected if there were no enrichment of low p-values in this series, and this phenomenon is very unlikely to be due to chance (p = 0.004), while the data from randomly selected 12,535 intergenic variants shows no difference (p = 0.76). The randomly selected 12,535 intergenic variant series in (B) can be approximately viewed as one of the permutated data series in (A) except that they are restricted to be annotated as intergenic, and is presented here for better illustration of the results. Functional genetic variants are those annotated as falling into one or more of these categories: stop-gained, stop-lost, fame-shift coding, non-synonymous coding, and essential splicing site genetic variants. Ensembl database version 50_36i was used for these annotations.
(0.13 MB DOC)
Participants included in the study.
(0.04 MB DOC)
VL setpoint values for groups of individuals with or without a recombination event between HCP5 and HLA-B.
(0.03 MB DOC)
Results of the stepwise forward selection of MHC SNPs.
(0.04 MB DOC)
Associations between 4-digit HLA Class I alleles and HIV-1 set point in the subset of 1204 subjects with complete SNP and HLA typing results.
(0.10 MB DOC)
Pairs of HLA-B and HLA-C alleles that are in linkage disequilibrium (with an r2 of at least 0.1) in the subset of 1204 individuals with complete HLA typing results.
(0.07 MB DOC)
Associations between HLA-C alleles and HIV-1 set point in the subset of 1204 subjects with complete SNP and HLA typing results.
(0.06 MB DOC)
Results of the GSEA analysis.
(0.04 MB DOC)
Comparison of the strength of the association results for polymorphisms with clear association with HIV outcomes using different definitions of progression in survival analyses.
(0.03 MB DOC)
Top 500 SNPs in the setpoint analysis.
(0.74 MB DOC)
Top 500 SNPs in the progression analysis.
(0.72 MB DOC)
Number of SNPs discarded during quality control procedures.
(0.03 MB DOC)
We thank Steven A. McCarroll for giving us the tag-SNPs for CNPs. We gratefully acknowledge all patients, clinicians, and researchers from the Euro-CHAVI Consortium and the Multicenter AIDS Cohort Study. A complete list of collaborators and funding agencies is available in Text S1.
The Euro-CHAVI Consortium is coordinated by A. Telenti (University of Lausanne, Switzerland), with S. Colombo (University of Lausanne, Switzerland) and B. Ledergerber (University of Zurich, Switzerland). Participating Cohorts/Studies (Principal Investigators) are: Swiss HIV Cohort Study, Switzerland (P Francioli); Icona Foundation Study, Rome, Italy (A. De Luca); IrsiCaixa Foundation, Barcelona, Spain (J. Martinez-Picado, with the help of J. Dalmau); San Raffaele del Monte Tabor Foundation, Milan, Italy (A. Castagna); Danish Cohort, Denmark (N. Obel); Royal Perth Hospital, Perth, Australia (S. Mallal); Guy's, King's, and St. Thomas' Hospitals, United Kingdom (P. Easterbrook); Modena Cohort, Modena, Italy (A. Cossarizza); Hospital Clinic-IDIBAPS cohort, Barcelona, Spain (J. M. Gatell).
The Multicenter AIDS Cohort Study has centers (Principal Investigators) at The Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health (Joseph B. Margolick, Lisa P. Jacobson), Howard Brown Health Center, Feinberg School of Medicine, Northwestern University, and Cook County Bureau of Health Services (John P. Phair, Steven M. Wolinsky), University of California, Los Angeles (Roger Detels), and University of Pittsburgh (Charles R. Rinaldo).
Conceived and designed the experiments: JF JSB NLL AJM BFH MC AT DBG. Performed the experiments: JF KVS TJU CEG JPS PD. Analyzed the data: JF DG BL ETC KZ SF. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: KVS SC BL AC ACL ADL PE HFG SM CM JD JMP JMM NO SMW JJM RD JBM LPJ SEA SJO BFH MC AT. Wrote the paper: JF AT DBG.
- 1. Telenti A, Bleiber G (2006) Host genetics of HIV-1 susceptibility. Future Virology 1: 55–70.A. TelentiG. Bleiber2006Host genetics of HIV-1 susceptibility.Future Virology15570
- 2. O'Brien SJ, Nelson GW (2004) Human genes that limit AIDS. Nat Genet 36: 565–574.SJ O'BrienGW Nelson2004Human genes that limit AIDS.Nat Genet36565574
- 3. Fellay J, Shianna KV, Ge D, Colombo S, Ledergerber B, et al. (2007) A whole-genome association study of major determinants for host control of HIV-1. Science 317: 944–947.J. FellayKV ShiannaD. GeS. ColomboB. Ledergerber2007A whole-genome association study of major determinants for host control of HIV-1.Science317944947
- 4. Martin MP, Carrington M (2005) Immunogenetics of viral infections. Curr Opin Immunol 17: 510–516.MP MartinM. Carrington2005Immunogenetics of viral infections.Curr Opin Immunol17510516
- 5. Carrington M, O'Brien SJ (2003) The influence of HLA genotype on AIDS. Annu Rev Med 54: 535–551.M. CarringtonSJ O'Brien2003The influence of HLA genotype on AIDS.Annu Rev Med54535551
- 6. Detels R, Liu Z, Hennessey K, Kan J, Visscher BR, et al. (1994) Resistance to HIV-1 infection. Multicenter AIDS Cohort Study. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr 7: 1263–1269.R. DetelsZ. LiuK. HennesseyJ. KanBR Visscher1994Resistance to HIV-1 infection. Multicenter AIDS Cohort Study.J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr712631269
- 7. Catano G, Kulkarni H, He W, Marconi VC, Agan BK, et al. (2008) HIV-1 disease-influencing effects associated with ZNRD1, HCP5 and HLA-C alleles are attributable mainly to either HLA-A10 or HLA-B*57 alleles. PLoS ONE 3: e3636.G. CatanoH. KulkarniW. HeVC MarconiBK Agan2008HIV-1 disease-influencing effects associated with ZNRD1, HCP5 and HLA-C alleles are attributable mainly to either HLA-A10 or HLA-B*57 alleles.PLoS ONE3e3636
- 8. van Manen D, Kootstra NA, Boeser-Nunnink B, Handulle MA, van't Wout AB, et al. (2009) Association of HLA-C and HCP5 gene regions with the clinical course of HIV-1 infection. AIDS 23: 19–28.D. van ManenNA KootstraB. Boeser-NunninkMA HandulleAB van't Wout2009Association of HLA-C and HCP5 gene regions with the clinical course of HIV-1 infection.AIDS231928
- 9. Trachtenberg E, Bhattacharya T, Ladner M, Phair J, Erlich H, et al. (2009) The HLA-B/-C haplotype block contains major determinants for host control of HIV. Genes Immun. E. TrachtenbergT. BhattacharyaM. LadnerJ. PhairH. Erlich2009The HLA-B/-C haplotype block contains major determinants for host control of HIV.Genes ImmunAug 20 [Epub ahead of print]. Aug 20 [Epub ahead of print].
- 10. Limou S, Le Clerc S, Coulonges C, Carpentier W, Dina C, et al. (2009) Genomewide Association Study of an AIDS-Nonprogression Cohort Emphasizes the Role Played by HLA Genes (ANRS Genomewide Association Study 02). J Infect Dis 199: 419–426.S. LimouS. Le ClercC. CoulongesW. CarpentierC. Dina2009Genomewide Association Study of an AIDS-Nonprogression Cohort Emphasizes the Role Played by HLA Genes (ANRS Genomewide Association Study 02).J Infect Dis199419426
- 11. Dalmasso C, Carpentier W, Meyer L, Rouzioux C, Goujard C, et al. (2008) Distinct genetic loci control plasma HIV-RNA and cellular HIV-DNA levels in HIV-1 infection: the ANRS Genome Wide Association 01 study. PLoS ONE 3: e3907.C. DalmassoW. CarpentierL. MeyerC. RouziouxC. Goujard2008Distinct genetic loci control plasma HIV-RNA and cellular HIV-DNA levels in HIV-1 infection: the ANRS Genome Wide Association 01 study.PLoS ONE3e3907
- 12. Price AL, Patterson NJ, Plenge RM, Weinblatt ME, Shadick NA, et al. (2006) Principal components analysis corrects for stratification in genome-wide association studies. Nat Genet 38: 904–909.AL PriceNJ PattersonRM PlengeME WeinblattNA Shadick2006Principal components analysis corrects for stratification in genome-wide association studies.Nat Genet38904909
- 13. Novembre J, Johnson T, Bryc K, Kutalik Z, Boyko AR, et al. (2008) Genes mirror geography within Europe. Nature. J. NovembreT. JohnsonK. BrycZ. KutalikAR Boyko2008Genes mirror geography within Europe.Nature
- 14. McCarthy MI, Abecasis GR, Cardon LR, Goldstein DB, Little J, et al. (2008) Genome-wide association studies for complex traits: consensus, uncertainty and challenges. Nat Rev Genet 9: 356–369.MI McCarthyGR AbecasisLR CardonDB GoldsteinJ. Little2008Genome-wide association studies for complex traits: consensus, uncertainty and challenges.Nat Rev Genet9356369
- 15. Colombo S, Rauch A, Rotger M, Fellay J, Martinez R, et al. (2008) The HCP5 single-nucleotide polymorphism: a simple screening tool for prediction of hypersensitivity reaction to abacavir. J Infect Dis 198: 864–867.S. ColomboA. RauchM. RotgerJ. FellayR. Martinez2008The HCP5 single-nucleotide polymorphism: a simple screening tool for prediction of hypersensitivity reaction to abacavir.J Infect Dis198864867
- 16. de Bakker PI, McVean G, Sabeti PC, Miretti MM, Green T, et al. (2006) A high-resolution HLA and SNP haplotype map for disease association studies in the extended human MHC. Nat Genet 38: 1166–1172.PI de BakkerG. McVeanPC SabetiMM MirettiT. Green2006A high-resolution HLA and SNP haplotype map for disease association studies in the extended human MHC.Nat Genet3811661172
- 17. Yuan H-Y, Chiou J-J, Tseng W-H, Liu C-H, Liu C-K, et al. (2006) FASTSNP: an always up-to-date and extendable service for SNP function analysis and prioritization. Nucl Acids Res 34: W635–641.H-Y YuanJ-J ChiouW-H TsengC-H LiuC-K Liu2006FASTSNP: an always up-to-date and extendable service for SNP function analysis and prioritization.Nucl Acids Res34W635641
- 18. Telenti A, Goldstein DB (2006) Genomics meets HIV-1. Nat Rev Microbiol 4: 865–873.A. TelentiDB Goldstein2006Genomics meets HIV-1.Nat Rev Microbiol4865873
- 19. Urban TJ, Weintrob AC, Fellay J, Colombo S, Shianna KV, et al. (2009) CCL3L1 and HIV/AIDS susceptibility. Nat Med 15: 1110–1112.TJ UrbanAC WeintrobJ. FellayS. ColomboKV Shianna2009CCL3L1 and HIV/AIDS susceptibility.Nat Med1511101112
- 20. Samson M, Libert F, Doranz BJ, Rucker J, Liesnard C, et al. (1996) Resistance to HIV-1 infection in caucasian individuals bearing mutant alleles of the CCR-5 chemokine receptor gene. Nature 382: 722–725.M. SamsonF. LibertBJ DoranzJ. RuckerC. Liesnard1996Resistance to HIV-1 infection in caucasian individuals bearing mutant alleles of the CCR-5 chemokine receptor gene.Nature382722725
- 21. Dean M, Carrington M, Winkler C, Huttley GA, Smith MW, et al. (1996) Genetic restriction of HIV-1 infection and progression to AIDS by a deletion allele of the CKR5 structural gene. Hemophilia Growth and Development Study, Multicenter AIDS Cohort Study, Multicenter Hemophilia Cohort Study, San Francisco City Cohort, ALIVE Study. Science 273: 1856–1862.M. DeanM. CarringtonC. WinklerGA HuttleyMW Smith1996Genetic restriction of HIV-1 infection and progression to AIDS by a deletion allele of the CKR5 structural gene. Hemophilia Growth and Development Study, Multicenter AIDS Cohort Study, Multicenter Hemophilia Cohort Study, San Francisco City Cohort, ALIVE Study.Science27318561862
- 22. Liu R, Paxton WA, Choe S, Ceradini D, Martin SR, et al. (1996) Homozygous defect in HIV-1 coreceptor accounts for resistance of some multiply-exposed individuals to HIV-1 infection. Cell 86: 367–377.R. LiuWA PaxtonS. ChoeD. CeradiniSR Martin1996Homozygous defect in HIV-1 coreceptor accounts for resistance of some multiply-exposed individuals to HIV-1 infection.Cell86367377
- 23. Martin MP, Dean M, Smith MW, Winkler C, Gerrard B, et al. (1998) Genetic acceleration of AIDS progression by a promoter variant of CCR5. Science 282: 1907–1911.MP MartinM. DeanMW SmithC. WinklerB. Gerrard1998Genetic acceleration of AIDS progression by a promoter variant of CCR5.Science28219071911
- 24. Salkowitz JR, Bruse SE, Meyerson H, Valdez H, Mosier DE, et al. (2003) CCR5 promoter polymorphism determines macrophage CCR5 density and magnitude of HIV-1 propagation in vitro. Clin Immunol 108: 234–240.JR SalkowitzSE BruseH. MeyersonH. ValdezDE Mosier2003CCR5 promoter polymorphism determines macrophage CCR5 density and magnitude of HIV-1 propagation in vitro.Clin Immunol108234240
- 25. Smith MW, Dean M, Carrington M, Winkler C, Huttley GA, et al. (1997) Contrasting genetic influence of CCR2 and CCR5 variants on HIV-1 infection and disease progression. Hemophilia Growth and Development Study (HGDS), Multicenter AIDS Cohort Study (MACS), Multicenter Hemophilia Cohort Study (MHCS), San Francisco City Cohort (SFCC), ALIVE Study. Science 277: 959–965.MW SmithM. DeanM. CarringtonC. WinklerGA Huttley1997Contrasting genetic influence of CCR2 and CCR5 variants on HIV-1 infection and disease progression. Hemophilia Growth and Development Study (HGDS), Multicenter AIDS Cohort Study (MACS), Multicenter Hemophilia Cohort Study (MHCS), San Francisco City Cohort (SFCC), ALIVE Study.Science277959965
- 26. Rizzardi GP, Morawetz RA, Vicenzi E, Ghezzi S, Poli G, et al. (1998) CCR2 polymorphism and HIV disease. Swiss HIV Cohort. Nat Med 4: 252–253.GP RizzardiRA MorawetzE. VicenziS. GhezziG. Poli1998CCR2 polymorphism and HIV disease. Swiss HIV Cohort.Nat Med4252253
- 27. McCarroll SA, Kuruvilla FG, Korn JM, Cawley S, Nemesh J, et al. (2008) Integrated detection and population-genetic analysis of SNPs and copy number variation. Nat Genet 40: 1166–1174.SA McCarrollFG KuruvillaJM KornS. CawleyJ. Nemesh2008Integrated detection and population-genetic analysis of SNPs and copy number variation.Nat Genet4011661174
- 28. Subramanian A, Tamayo P, Mootha VK, Mukherjee S, Ebert BL, et al. (2005) Gene set enrichment analysis: A knowledge-based approach for interpreting genome-wide expression profiles. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 102: 15545–15550.A. SubramanianP. TamayoVK MoothaS. MukherjeeBL Ebert2005Gene set enrichment analysis: A knowledge-based approach for interpreting genome-wide expression profiles.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A1021554515550
- 29. Wang K, Li M, Bucan M (2007) Pathway-Based Approaches for Analysis of Genomewide Association Studies. Am J Hum Genet 81: K. WangM. LiM. Bucan2007Pathway-Based Approaches for Analysis of Genomewide Association Studies.Am J Hum Genet81
- 30. Han Y, Lai J, Barditch-Crovo P, Gallant JE, Williams TM, et al. (2008) The role of protective HCP5 and HLA-C associated polymorphisms in the control of HIV-1 replication in a subset of elite suppressors. AIDS 22: 541–544.Y. HanJ. LaiP. Barditch-CrovoJE GallantTM Williams2008The role of protective HCP5 and HLA-C associated polymorphisms in the control of HIV-1 replication in a subset of elite suppressors.AIDS22541544
- 31. Shrestha S, Aissani B, Song W, Wilson CM, Kaslow RA, et al. (2009) Host genetics and HIV-1 viral load set-point in African-Americans. AIDS 23: 673–677.S. ShresthaB. AissaniW. SongCM WilsonRA Kaslow2009Host genetics and HIV-1 viral load set-point in African-Americans.AIDS23673677
- 32. Yoon W, Ma B, Fellay J, H W, X S, et al. (2009) A polymorphism in the HCP5 gene associated with HLA-B*5701 does not restrict HIV-1 in vitro. AIDS In press. W. YoonB. MaJ. FellayW. HS. X2009A polymorphism in the HCP5 gene associated with HLA-B*5701 does not restrict HIV-1 in vitro.AIDS In press
- 33. Stranger BE, Forrest MS, Clark AG, Minichiello MJ, Deutsch S, et al. (2005) Genome-wide associations of gene expression variation in humans. PLoS Genet 1: e78.BE StrangerMS ForrestAG ClarkMJ MinichielloS. Deutsch2005Genome-wide associations of gene expression variation in humans.PLoS Genet1e78
- 34. Towers G (2007) The control of viral infection by tripartite motif proteins and cyclophilin A. Retrovirology 4: 40.G. Towers2007The control of viral infection by tripartite motif proteins and cyclophilin A.Retrovirology440
- 35. Schneidewind A, Brockman MA, Yang R, Adam RI, Li B, et al. (2007) Escape from the dominant HLA-B27-restricted cytotoxic T-lymphocyte response in Gag is associated with a dramatic reduction in human immunodeficiency virus type 1 replication. J Virol 81: 12382–12393.A. SchneidewindMA BrockmanR. YangRI AdamB. Li2007Escape from the dominant HLA-B27-restricted cytotoxic T-lymphocyte response in Gag is associated with a dramatic reduction in human immunodeficiency virus type 1 replication.J Virol811238212393
- 36. Gao X, Nelson GW, Karacki P, Martin MP, Phair J, et al. (2001) Effect of a single amino acid change in MHC class I molecules on the rate of progression to AIDS. N Engl J Med 344: 1668–1675.X. GaoGW NelsonP. KarackiMP MartinJ. Phair2001Effect of a single amino acid change in MHC class I molecules on the rate of progression to AIDS.N Engl J Med34416681675
- 37. Little J, Higgins JPT, Ioannidis JPA, Moher D, Gagnon F, et al. (2009) STrengthening the REporting of Genetic Association Studies (STREGA); An Extension of the STROBE Statement. PLoS Med 6: e22.J. LittleJPT HigginsJPA IoannidisD. MoherF. Gagnon2009STrengthening the REporting of Genetic Association Studies (STREGA); An Extension of the STROBE Statement.PLoS Med6e22
- 38. Attia J, Ioannidis JP, Thakkinstian A, McEvoy M, Scott RJ, et al. (2009) How to use an article about genetic association: B: Are the results of the study valid? JAMA 301: 191–197.J. AttiaJP IoannidisA. ThakkinstianM. McEvoyRJ Scott2009How to use an article about genetic association: B: Are the results of the study valid?JAMA301191197
- 39. Brem RB, Storey JD, Whittle J, Kruglyak L (2005) Genetic interactions between polymorphisms that affect gene expression in yeast. Nature 436: 701–703.RB BremJD StoreyJ. WhittleL. Kruglyak2005Genetic interactions between polymorphisms that affect gene expression in yeast.Nature436701703
- 40. Ge D, Zhang K, Need AC, Martin O, Fellay J, et al. (2008) WGAViewer: software for genomic annotation of whole genome association studies. Genome Res 18: 640–643.D. GeK. ZhangAC NeedO. MartinJ. Fellay2008WGAViewer: software for genomic annotation of whole genome association studies.Genome Res18640643