Fatty-acid metabolism plays a key role in acquired and inborn metabolic diseases. To obtain insight into the network dynamics of fatty-acid β-oxidation, we constructed a detailed computational model of the pathway and subjected it to a fat overload condition. The model contains reversible and saturable enzyme-kinetic equations and experimentally determined parameters for rat-liver enzymes. It was validated by adding palmitoyl CoA or palmitoyl carnitine to isolated rat-liver mitochondria: without refitting of measured parameters, the model correctly predicted the β-oxidation flux as well as the time profiles of most acyl-carnitine concentrations. Subsequently, we simulated the condition of obesity by increasing the palmitoyl-CoA concentration. At a high concentration of palmitoyl CoA the β-oxidation became overloaded: the flux dropped and metabolites accumulated. This behavior originated from the competition between acyl CoAs of different chain lengths for a set of acyl-CoA dehydrogenases with overlapping substrate specificity. This effectively induced competitive feedforward inhibition and thereby led to accumulation of CoA-ester intermediates and depletion of free CoA (CoASH). The mitochondrial [NAD+]/[NADH] ratio modulated the sensitivity to substrate overload, revealing a tight interplay between regulation of β-oxidation and mitochondrial respiration.
Lipid metabolism plays an important role in the development of metabolic syndrome, a major risk factor for cardiovascular disease and diabetes. Furthermore, inborn errors in lipid oxidation cause rare, but severe diseases in children. To obtain more insight into the response of lipid oxidation to dietary and medical interventions, we constructed a computational model. The model correctly simulated the rate of lipid oxidation and the time courses of most acyl carnitines. The latter are used as diagnostic markers in blood. Subsequently, we subjected the model to an increased supply of lipids, as often happens in obese people. We discovered that the lipid-oxidation machinery easily becomes overloaded, very much like a highway during rush hours: the more cars enter the road, the slower they proceed and the more they clog the road. Analogously, an overload of lipids slowed down the lipid oxidation and led to an accumulation of intermediate metabolites in the pathway. Potential protection mechanisms of cells consist of restricted entry of lipids into the oxidation pathway or efficient downstream processing of reaction products. In future research we will use the model to test dietary or medical interventions in silico and thereby guide the development of new treatment and prevention strategies.
Citation: van Eunen K, Simons SMJ, Gerding A, Bleeker A, den Besten G, Touw CML, et al. (2013) Biochemical Competition Makes Fatty-Acid β-Oxidation Vulnerable to Substrate Overload. PLoS Comput Biol 9(8): e1003186. doi:10.1371/journal.pcbi.1003186
Editor: Jeffrey J. Saucerman, University of Virginia, United States of America
Received: March 25, 2013; Accepted: July 8, 2013; Published: August 15, 2013
Copyright: © 2013 van Eunen et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work was funded by the Netherlands Genomics Initiative via the Netherlands Centre for Systems Biology, a Rosalind Franklin Fellowship from the University of Groningen to BMB and an NWO grant (Centers for Systems Biology Research) to BMB, DJR and AG. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Pathophysiological mechanisms underlying acquired and inborn metabolic diseases, such as type-2 diabetes and deficiencies in the fatty-acid oxidation, are largely elusive. Although we know many important molecular factors, yet the complexity of the metabolic and regulatory network hampers elucidating the relation between the primary disease factors and their systemic effects , . Moreover, the experimental accessibility of large parts of the metabolic networks is limited. Computational kinetic models yield insight into the dynamics of metabolic networks and make predictions about the parts that are experimentally inaccessible.
Fatty-acid (FA) β-oxidation is a prime example of a pathway involved in many diseases, but for which it is difficult to acquire a complete and quantitative view on the relation between metabolite concentrations and fluxes. Insulin resistance, one of the hallmarks of metabolic syndrome, is strongly associated with elevated levels of free FAs . It has been argued that an imbalance between cellular FA uptake and oxidation leads to accumulation of FAs and other lipid molecules in the cytosol, which in turn causes insulin resistance , . Others showed that a functioning acyl-CoA uptake into mitochondria is needed to develop insulin resistance, leading to the hypothesis that intermediates of FA β-oxidation are part of the problem . Since the acyl-CoA intermediates are difficult to measure, conclusions are often based on acyl-carnitine levels in the blood , , which are interpreted as a reflection of acyl-CoA concentrations in the mitochondria. Similar limitations hamper the understanding of systemic effects of enzyme deficiencies in the FA β-oxidation and their impact on global energy and glucose regulation , . Clearly, a more direct view on the dynamics of β-oxidation intermediates is urgently needed.
A careful look at the basic biochemistry of the FA β-oxidation reveals complex interactions, of which the implications have never been investigated (Figure 1). First, it is a cyclic pathway. In each cycle the acyl-CoA substrate is shortened by two carbon atoms and the product is a substrate for the next cycle. Second, the shortened acyl-CoA product competes with the substrate for a set of enzymes with overlapping chain-length specificity. The complete breakdown of palmitoyl CoA, an acyl CoA with 16 carbon atoms, to 8 molecules of acetyl CoA (C2) requires seven reaction cycles. There are, however, only four acyl-CoA dehydrogenases and two parallel sets of enzymes for the further conversion of enoyl CoA (Figure 1). This results in a competition in two ways: substrates of different chain lengths compete for common enzymes, while enzymes with overlapping specificity compete for common substrates. The competition between substrates generates a feedforward inhibition in the network: the more palmitoyl CoA molecules enters the pathway, the more enzyme molecules they occupy, which are then not available for shorter acyl CoAs downstream in the pathway. Third, the two parallel pathways for the breakdown of enoyl-CoA molecules are of a different nature. Enoyl CoAs are either converted by a sequence of three enzymes (crotonase, medium/short-chain hydroxyacyl-CoA dehydrogenase (M/SCHAD) and medium-chain ketoacyl-CoA thiolase (MCKAT)) or via the mitochondrial trifunctional protein (MTP), which catalyzes the entire sequence of reactions (Figure 1). At present it is unclear how these properties affect the pathway behavior.
Enzymes are depicted in italics bold face, metabolites in regular and allosteric inhibitors in red. CPT1: carnitine-palmitoyl transferase 1 (E.C. 18.104.22.168), CACT: carnitine-acyl-carnitine translocase, CPT2: carnitine-palmitoyl transferase 2 (E.C. 22.214.171.124), VLCAD: very-long-chain acyl-CoA dehydrogenase (E.C. 126.96.36.199), LCAD: long-chain acyl-CoA dehydrogenase (E.C. 188.8.131.52), MCAD: medium-chain acyl-CoA dehydrogenase (E.C. 184.108.40.206), SCAD short-chain acyl-CoA dehydrogenase (E.C.220.127.116.11 for butanoyl CoA (C4) (was previously E.C. 18.104.22.168) and E.C. 22.214.171.124 for hexanoyl CoA (C6)), MTP: mitochondrial trifunctional protein (E.C. 126.96.36.199, E.C. 188.8.131.52 and E.C. 184.108.40.206), M/SCHAD: medium/short-chain hydroxyacyl-CoA dehydrogenase (E.C. 220.127.116.11), MCKAT: medium-chain ketoacyl-CoA thiolase (E.C. 18.104.22.168). The chain-length specificity as included in the model is indicated for each enzyme (e.g. C6–C12). The boundary metabolites which are kept at fixed concentrations are underlined. The direction of the flux is from the small to large arrow heads.
In contrast to the myriad of models of carbohydrate metabolism, we know of only two kinetic models of FA β-oxidation and each of these ignores the above biochemical interactions. The first model  contains only a single cycle of β-oxidation and thereby lacks the competition between the pathway substrate and its downstream products. The second model does comprise the complete conversion of acyl CoAs to acetyl CoA, but the authors overlooked that this should lead to competition and modeled it as if distinct pools of each enzyme existed for each substrate .
In this study we present and validate a quantitative kinetic model of the mitochondrial FA β-oxidation, which explicitly includes molecular competition. This model reveals how the complex biochemical wiring of the network gives rise to non-intuitive or ‘emergent’ behavior . We will show i) how the competition renders the pathway vulnerable to substrate overload; ii) how the robustness of the system can be modulated; and iii) what the role is of the experimentally inaccessible CoA esters in this process.
We constructed a model for mitochondrial FA β-oxidation with all enzyme reactions and transporters (Figure 1). The reactions correspond to the mitochondrial β-oxidation module in the updated human metabolic reconstruction , with the difference that we tailored them to rat liver. Thus, we added the long-chain acyl-CoA dehydrogenase (LCAD), which is involved in rodent β-oxidation –. The model is limited to the β-oxidation of saturated FAs containing an even number of carbon atoms. It starts from the transport of palmitoyl CoA across the mitochondrial inner membrane by the carnitine shuttle. The shuttle is reversible and also catalyzes the export of acyl-CoA esters of other chain lengths, which can be released as acyl carnitines in the extramitochondrial space. For simplicity we assumed that CPT1 activity is restricted to palmitoyl CoA (C16). Once inside the mitochondrial matrix, acyl-CoA molecules are oxidized to enoyl CoA by a set of chain-length-specific, FAD-dependent acyl-CoA dehydrogenases (SCAD, MCAD, LCAD and VLCAD in Figure 1) , . The resulting enoyl CoAs undergo a sequential hydratase, dehydrogenase and thiolase reaction, leading to the formation of an NADH, an acetyl CoA and an acyl CoA which is two C-atoms shorter than the substrate of the cycle. This sequence of reactions is either catalyzed by the MTP (the right-hand branch in Figure 1)  or by three different enzymes (the left hand ‘crotonase’ branch in Figure 1) –. We assume that MTP does not release the hydroxyacyl-CoA and ketoacyl-CoA intermediates in the matrix, but channels them from one active site to another. In contrast, the intermediates in the ‘crotonase’ branch can diffuse freely through the matrix. There is overlap between the substrates that can be converted by the two pathways. However, MTP has a preference for longer chain lengths, while C4 and C6 substrates are uniquely converted by the crotonase branch.
The reaction scheme in Figure 1 is translated into a set of 45 ODEs describing how the time derivatives of the concentrations of the variable metabolites depend on the enzyme rates. For instance:(1)denotes that the rate of change of the enoyl-CoA concentration of chain length C14 in the mitochondrial matrix equals the rate v of formation by VLCAD and LCAD minus the rate of consumption by crotonase and MTP. VMAT denotes the volume of the mitochondrial matrix. In equation 1 each reaction rate is specific for a certain combination of enzyme and substrate, since most enzymes catalyze multiple reactions. The competing substrates inhibit each other's conversion competitively. This leads for instance to the following set of rate equation for crotonase:(2)
In the above ODE (equation 1) n = 14 for conversion of C14 and therefore the parameters for C14 are filled in, except in the Σ-term which sums over all substrates and products that are converted by crotonase and thus bind the enzyme reversibly. All of the reactions are modeled as reversible, mostly of Michaelis-Menten type as above, and most parameters were taken from the literature and mainly based on biochemical characterization of purified rat-liver enzymes. Some affinity and equilibrium constants were taken from rat-heart datasets. However, for enzymes of which only one isoenzyme exists, the affinity constants may be considered to be tissue-independent. Equilibrium constants do not depend at all on the enzyme that catalyzes the reaction. Three parameters, Vcpt1, Vvlcad and Vlcad, were estimated, since we could not find a reliable value in literature.
Three conserved moieties follow from the pathway stoichiometry: the total of FAD, NAD+ and CoA species. The model fulfills the criterion of microscopic reversibility, i.e. alternative reaction paths have the same overall equilibrium constant. For instance, the overall equilibrium constant of the MTP reaction equals the product of the equilibrium constants in the crotonase branch. We note that most equilibrium constants are not far from 1; hence the pathway lacks a strong thermodynamic driving force and depends on the delivery of substrate upstream and the further conversion of products downstream. A notable exception is the couple M/SCHAD – MCKAT, which has equilibrium constants of respectively 2.2·10−4 and 1.1·103. This implies that M/SCHAD favors the reverse direction, which is compensated by the high equilibrium constant of MCKAT. MTP dampens this thermodynamic hurdle by keeping the intermediate ketoacyl CoA bound.
Based on the above principles, we constructed a model of 45 variable metabolite concentrations, 56 reactions and 234 parameters (for detailed description see Text S1), which predicts fluxes and metabolites in time and at steady state.
Experimental validation of the model
The predicted model outcome was validated with experiments on isolated rat-liver mitochondria. We measured the oxygen-consumption flux and the acyl-carnitine concentrations (C4–C16) in time upon addition of palmitoyl CoA or palmitoyl carnitine. Mitochondria were incubated with an excess amount of malate. In this way CoASH could be regenerated from acetyl CoA by malate dehydrogenase and citrate synthase, allowing the β-oxidation to proceed. Each cycle of β-oxidation in the presence of excess malate gives rise to 1 FADH2 by acyl-CoA dehydrogenase and 2 NADH by enoyl-CoA dehydrogenase and malate dehydrogenase. The oxygen flux due to the β-oxidation per se was obtained by correcting the measured oxygen consumption for the oxygen consumption due to malate dehydrogenase. That malate to citrate was the main source of NADH beyond the β-oxidation was confirmed by measuring citrate, which indeed accumulated over time. Over the entire time course of 24 min, there was no significant gap between the carbon consumed as palmitoyl carnitine and the recovered products: carbon consumed = −16 • ([acyl carnitineC16]t24 - [acyl carnitineC16]t0) = 328±89 µM (SD) and carbon produced = (SD); paired t-test p>0.05. Note that we did not include the carnitine moiety in the balance as it plays only a catalytic role. The same holds for the four carbons in citrate that are derived from malate. α-Ketoglutarate was not detectable. The uncertainty of the carbon balance leaves, however, room for other intermediates to contribute.
We determined the time course of palmitoyl carnitine and used this as an input function for the substrate concentration in the model. We assumed that the time course was similar for palmitoyl CoA when the latter was given as substrate (see Text S1).
Within the experimental error the experimental and modeled flux corresponded well on both substrates (Figure 2A and Figure S1A). With palmitoyl carnitine, but not with palmitoyl CoA, a sharp initial overshoot was observed in the oxygen consumption flux, which was reproduced qualitatively by the model (Figure S1D–G). For the experiment with palmitoyl CoA as substrate, the dynamics of palmitoyl carnitine and the downstream intermediates myristoyl, octanoyl and hexanoyl carnitine (C14, C8 and C6) were quantitatively reproduced by the model. The remaining acyl carnitines (C10–C12 and C4) showed a qualitative correspondence between the experiment and model (Figure 2 and Figure S2A): the dynamics of the acyl carnitines were in all cases in the same direction, but the concentrations and/or timescale differed. For the experiment with palmitoyl carnitine as substrate, a qualitative correspondence was found, but the timescale and also concentrations differed (Figure S1B–C and S2B). We emphasize that the model parameters were not fitted to the experiments hence the correspondence between model and experiment is remarkably good.
At time point zero the substrate palmitoyl CoA was added to uncoupled mitochondria in the presence of an excess amount of l-carnitine and malic acid. Samples for acyl carnitine analysis were taken at different time points. Error bars on the experimental data represent SEM (n = 4 for the flux data, n = 8 for the acyl-carnitine concentrations). Panel A: Comparison of the experimental and modeled flux through the FA β-oxidation. The reported experimental flux is 2/3 of the oxygen consumption flux averaged from 1.5 to 8 min. The modeled flux equals the production fluxes of NADH plus FADH2 divided by 2 (one O2 oxidizes two NADH or FADH2), averaged over the same time interval. Panel B: experimental acyl-carnitine concentrations in total samples, i.e. including intra- and extramitochondrial metabolites. Panel C: acyl-carnitine concentrations simulated by the computer model, representing the weighted average over the matrix and extramitochondrial concentrations to allow direct comparison to the experiments.
Perturbation of the system: Mimicking obesity
FA levels in plasma from obese people are often elevated , . This means a constantly high availability of FAs for the β-oxidation. We have simulated this by calculating the steady-state flux and metabolite concentrations as a function of the concentration of palmitoyl CoA, the substrate in the model (Figure 3). The flux increased with an increasing concentration of palmitoyl CoA, but above 50 µM the flux decreased steeply, yet smoothly (Figure 3A, standard model). This was preceded by an accumulation of CoA esters (Figure 3B and Figure S3E) and consequently a decrease of CoASH (Figure 3B, standard model).
Panels A and C: Steady-state flux through the FA β-oxidation. Panel B: CoASH concentration (solid lines) and total CoA esters (dashed lines) corresponding to the simulations in A. Panel D: Graphical representation of the differences between the computational models with and without competition. Blue lines in A and B: standard model; red lines in A and B: model without competition; green lines in A and B: model with fixed CoASH concentration (see text). Solid line in C: standard model (malonyl-CoA concentration 0 µM, mitochondrial NAD/NADH ratio 15); short-dashed line in C: standard model but with increased concentration of malonyl CoA of 10 µM; long-dashed line in C: standard model but with increased mitochondrial NAD+/NADH ratio of 40. Different colors in panel D represent the four acyl-CoA dehydrogenases; cyan: SCAD, yellow: MCAD, purple: LCAD and green: VLCAD.
Most often a metabolic flux reaches a maximum at saturating substrate concentration, hence we considered the steep decline at high palmitoyl CoA an emergent, non-intuitive property of the β-oxidation. To prove that this property resulted from the competition between metabolites for a common set of enzymes, we adapted the model such that a percentage of each enzyme was dedicated to a particular chain length (‘No competition’ in Figure 3). This percentage was attributed such that at 25 µM of palmitoyl CoA the flux distribution among parallel enzymes was similar in both models (Figure S4). Indeed, in the model without competition the flux increased until saturation (Figure 3A), while the accumulation of CoA esters and the depletion of CoASH were prevented (Figure S3F and 3B).
A priori either the accumulation of the CoA esters or the depletion of CoASH could cause the decline of flux in the standard model. To distinguish between these possibilities we fixed the CoASH concentration in the standard model and left the CoA esters free to accumulate (Figure 3B), i.e. as if an external supply of CoASH had broken the moiety conservation. In this scenario the CoA esters accumulated extremely (Figure 3B and Figure S3G), but the flux nevertheless increased until saturation (Figure 3A, fixed CoASH). Accordingly, the drop in flux observed in the standard model is a result of CoASH depletion rather than of the high CoA-ester concentration.
Sensitivity analysis revealed that the influx of FAs into the FA β-oxidation by CPT1 and the consumption of the products of the enzyme M/SCHAD (NADH and ketoacyl CoAs in the mitochondrial matrix) had the largest effect on the CoASH concentration (Table S1). To explore the role of CPT1, we decreased its activity by adding the endogenous CPT1 inhibitor malonyl CoA or by lowering its Vmax. At low concentrations of palmitoyl CoA the flux was lower than in the standard model, but it rose to the same maximum and the drop in flux occurred at a higher palmitoyl-CoA concentration (Figure 3A and S3A). Accordingly, the accumulation of CoA esters and the depletion of CoASH still occurred, but at higher concentrations of palmitoyl CoA (Figure 3B and S3B, S3H–I). The influence of M/SCHAD is due to its very small equilibrium constant (2 · 10−4 , ) implying that the reaction can only work in the direction of the β-oxidation when its product concentrations are extremely low as compared to its substrate concentrations. To shift the M/SCHAD reaction in the forward direction, we increased the NAD/NADH ratio in the mitochondrial matrix from 15 to 40 without altering the sum of NAD and NADH. This prevented the flux decline at higher palmitoyl-CoA concentrations (Figure 3C and S3C). Accordingly, the concentrations of the CoA esters stayed low (Figure S3J) and a high CoASH concentration was maintained (Figure S3D).
In this paper we present the first dynamic model of the FA β-oxidation that appreciates the complex biochemical interactions in the network. Notably, we included the extensive competition in the system, as well as the qualitatively different pathways for conversion of enoyl CoAs. The parameters were based on biochemical analysis of individual enzymes and not fitted to obtain the desired metabolite and flux profiles. In this light, the correspondence between model predictions and experimental observations (Figure 2) was remarkably good. This allowed us to further explore the properties of the pathway.
We found that the unique pathway structure makes the FA β-oxidation vulnerable to substrate overload: at high palmitoyl-CoA concentrations the shorter CoA esters accumulate to outcompete the palmitoyl CoA. Above a critical palmitoyl-CoA concentration this results in depletion of CoASH and a steep decline in flux. This is an example of an ‘emergent’ property: it would not have occurred in a linear pathway without competition. Hence, it could not be predicted from the properties of the individual enzymes, but resulted from the wiring of the entire network. It is tempting to speculate that this overload phenotype is at the basis of various diseases and may be one of the mechanisms of lipotoxicity. We emphasize, however, that we modeled the FA β-oxidation in isolation. In reality, surrounding pathways may protect the pathway from overload. In addition, the model revealed two possible protection mechanisms at the pathway boundaries. In the following we will discuss these protective mechanisms as well the possible role of fatty-acid overload in insulin resistance.
First, according to the model the flux decline could be prevented by decreasing the activity of CPT1. Accordingly, increased concentrations of the CPT1 inhibitor malonyl CoA as well as a decreased catalytic capacity of CPT1 have been observed experimentally –. The most convincing data are for malonyl CoA, which is increased in skeletal muscle of obese humans and rodents , , ,  as well as in liver tissue from obese mice . Instead of being a cause of obesity via decreased FA oxidation and increased synthesis, malonyl CoA may rather confer protection against overload of the β-oxidation.
A second mechanism to prevent overload was to keep the products of the thermodynamically unfavorable M/SCHAD reaction low. In the parallel MTP pathway the long-chain hydroxyacyl-CoA (LCHAD) dehydrogenase is linked to the preceding long-chain enoyl-CoA hydratase and the following long-chain ketoacyl-CoA thiolase at the inner mitochondrial membrane , , . Since the intermediate CoA esters are not detectable, it has been proposed that they are directly channeled from one active site to another , , –. The overall equilibrium constant of the lumped MTP reaction is 0.7, dampening the thermodynamic hurdle at LCHAD. Channeling has not been described for the short-chain intermediates (C4 and C6) and therefore we modeled their conversion by a sequence of enzymes (the ‘crotonase branch’) including the M/SCHAD reaction. The impact of the thermodynamic hurdle at M/SCHAD is demonstrated by the fact that the long-chain intermediates have a strong preference for the MTP branch, even though they could in principle be converted by the crotonase branch (Figure S4). Only C4 and C6 substrates, which are not recognized by MTP, take the crotonase route. Due to the low equilibrium constant of M/SCHAD (Keq = 2×10−4), the C6 and C4 intermediates accumulate in the model as well as in the experiment (Figure 2). A high mitochondrial NAD+/NADH ratio shifts the M/SCHAD equilibrium in the forward direction, prevents accumulation of the short-chain intermediates and eventually protects against the overload phenotype (Figure 3). This provides a functional explanation for the co-existence of M/SCHAD and Complex I in a respiratory supercomplex , : locally, the NADH produced by M/SCHAD may be kept low by channeling it directly to complex I. In agreement with this hypothesis, the respiration-linked β-oxidation rate in gently-disrupted mitochondria (assuming an intact complex between M/SCHAD and Complex I) was much higher than in completely-disrupted mitochondria .
Besides the protection mechanisms found in the model, alternative mechanisms might be provided by surrounding pathways. Limited formation of palmitoyl CoA, either by inhibition of the synthetase reaction or due to a low cytosolic CoA concentration, would be very effective. Little is known however, about regulation of palmitoyl CoA synthesis. Another option is upregulation of the pathways that consume the product acetyl CoA, such as the Krebs cycle or the formation of ketone bodies. Indeed, the liver can produce high amounts of ketone bodies when confronted with a high fat load . According to the model, a decreased acetyl-CoA concentration (K1acesink in the parameter list) should increase the concentration of CoASH (Table S1), although not as strongly as a decrease of the mitochondrial NADH concentration.
So far, direct experimental evidence for the overload phenotype is lacking. It is not unlikely, however, that it is at the basis of the well-known association of high FA levels to insulin resistance. Chronic exposure of muscle to elevated lipid levels results in an increased expression of FA β-oxidation genes, but this is not accompanied by an upregulation of downstream metabolic pathways, such as the TCA cycle and electron transport chain. In line with our model, it has been reported that this results in incomplete oxidation of fatty acids and accumulation of acyl carnitines and ketone bodies (reviewed in ). The fact that CPT1 is required to confer insulin resistance, suggests that the accumulated intermediate metabolites of the FA β-oxidation and/or ketone bodies may be involved in insulin resistance . It is unclear, however, if the CoA esters or the carnitine esters are responsible for this effect, or both. Administration of l-carnitine, which is the ‘scavenger’ of CoA esters, sometimes restores glucose tolerance, in rats as well as humans , . It is tempting to speculate that carnitine protects by trans-esterification of CoA esters to carnitine esters, which liberates CoASH and prevents accumulation of intermediates. In vivo it is not clear, however, if carnitine prevents overload, since it plays a dual role: in the mitochondrial matrix it scavenges intermediate CoA esters, but in the cytosol it drives the uptake of acyl CoAs into the mitochondria.
Since glucose and FA oxidation share the mitochondrial cofactors NAD+/NADH and CoASH, it may be expected that the presence of glucose will make the β-oxidation even more susceptible to overload. Vice versa a severe drop in CoASH will also compromise glucose oxidation via the TCA cycle. To further understand the interplay between glucose and FA metabolism and the quantitative role of various protective pathways, it will be of key interest to link the new model with (partially) existing models of glucose metabolism, TCA cycle, respiration, ketone-body synthesis and FA synthesis –. This should be the next step in elucidating the mechanisms behind acquired and inborn diseases of glucose and FA metabolism.
Materials and Methods
Experimental procedures were approved by the Ethics Committees for Animal Experiments of the University of Groningen.
The computational model was built and analyzed in Mathematica Wolfram. It consists of a set of Ordinary Differential Equations (ODEs). Time simulations were done with the algorithm NDSolve. Steady states were calculated by setting all time derivatives to zero and solving the resulting set of non-linear equations with the algorithm FindRoot. FindRoot is a root-finding algorithm combining damped Newton's method, the secant method and Brent's method. The solutions fulfilled the criterion that all time derivatives of metabolite concentrations approached zero (<10−11). We have no indications for alternative steady-state solutions, since different initial conditions led to identical steady states. As an input for the steady-state root-finding algorithm we used the endpoint of a time simulation. A Mathematica script and the corresponding pdf is added to this paper (Protocol S1 (steady state) and Protocol S2 (time simulation), as well as a detailed model description in Text S1). The models will become publically available at JWS Online Cellular Systems Modeling (jjj.bio.vu.nl).
Flux and metabolite concentrations
Mitochondria were isolated from liver tissue of adult female Wistar rats (250–300 gram) according to Mildaziene . The oxygen consumption rate of uncoupled mitochondria was measured with either palmitoyl CoA or palmitoyl carnitine as substrate, in the presence of ADP at 37°C in a stirred, two-channel high-resolution Oroboros oxygraph-2 k (Oroboros, Innsbruck, Austria). All measurements were done in 2 ml of MiR05 medium  to which 0.5 mg/ml mitochondrial protein, 0.2 µM FCCP (uncoupler), 2 mM malic acid, 500 µM l-carnitine, 1 mM ADP and 25 µM of either palmitoyl CoA or palmitoyl carnitine were added.
In parallel, 15–20 ml of the same reaction mixture was analyzed in a stirred, open vessel from which samples were taken in time for acyl-carnitine concentrations and TCA-cycle intermediates. Samples of 1.5 ml each were quenched by adding HCl to a final concentration of 0.4 M.
Mass spectrometry analysis of acyl carnitines and TCA cycle intermediates
Comparison between the model results and experimental data. Panel A–C: model compared to the data of the experiment with palmitoyl carnitine as substrate. Error bars on the experimental data represent SEM (n = 4 for the flux data, n = 8 for the acyl carnitine concentrations). The reported experimental flux is 2/3 of the oxygen consumption flux averaged from 1.5 to 8 min. The modeled flux equals the production fluxes of NADH plus FADH2 divided by 2 (one O2 oxidizes 2 NADH or FADH2), averaged over the same time interval. Panel D–G: Comparison of the flux dynamics over time between model and experiment with either palmitoyl-CoA or palmitoyl carnitine as substrate for isolated rat-liver mitochondria. Dashed lines in the graphs from the experiment represent SEM (n = 4).
Comparison of the acylcarnitine concentrations between model and experiment. Panel A: palmitoyl CoA as substrate. Experimental values are depicted at the x-axis and the model values at the y-axis. Experimental concentration is the total concentration of intra and extramitochondrial acyl carnitine. Error bars indicate the SEM of the experimental data (n = 8). The black line represents a perfect match between the model and experimental values. Panel B: palmitoylcarnitine as substrate. Exeperimental values are depicted at the x-axis and the model values at the y-axis. Experimental concentration is the total concentration of intra and extramitochondrial acyl carnitine. Error bars indicate the SEM of the experimental data (n = 8). The black line represents a perfect match between the model and experimental values.
Steady-state flux through the FA β-oxidation (A and C), CoASH concentration (B and D) and concentrations of the CoA esters (E–J) from the various model calculations. Panel A–D: Steady-state flux through the FA β-oxidation (A and C) and CoASH concentration (B and D) at various concentrations of the substrate palmitoyl CoA. In the standard model the malonyl CoA concentration was 0 µM and the mitochondrial NAD/NADH ratio was 15. Panel E–J: For each CoA ester the concentrations of the specific CoA esters with different chain length were summed up. Panel E corresponds to Figure 3A and B (blue lines) in the main text; Panel F corresponds to Figure 3A and B (red lines) in the main text; Panel G corresponds to Figure 3A and B (green lines) in the main text; Panel H corresponds to Figure 3C (short-dashed lines) in the main text and Figure S3A and B (long-dashed lines); Panel I corresponds to Figure S3A and B (short-dashed lines); Panel J corresponds to Figure 3C (long-dashed lines) in the main text and Figure S3C and D (short-dashed lines).
Flux distribution through the individual enzymes for the standard model (black bars) and the model without competition (white bars) at a palmitoyl-CoA concentration of 25 µM. This figure corresponds to Figure 3A and B (blue lines) in the main text.
Steady-state model of the FA β-oxidation.
Time-simulation model of the FA β-oxidation.
Sensitivity analysis of the standard model. Response coefficients of the concentration of CoASH towards the model parameters p. The response coefficient was approximated by increasing the parameter of interest by 1%. Response coefficients are ranked from the highest to the lowest absolute value (positive coefficients in the left-hand column; negative coefficients in the right-hand column). Response coefficients were calculated for the steady-state standard model with 25 µM palmitoyl CoA as substrate.
We would like to thank prof. R.J. Wanders, dr. T.G.J. Derks and M.J. Wagner for valuable discussions and dr. J.R. Haanstra for carefully checking the computational models.
Conceived and designed the experiments: KvE SMH BKG KK DJR BMB. Performed the experiments: KvE SMJS AG AB GdB. Analyzed the data: KvE SMJS AG. Wrote the paper: KvE BMB. Interpretation of the results: KvE SMJS AG AB GdB CMLT SMH BKG KK DJR BMB.
- 1. Oresic M (2010) Systems biology strategy to study lipotoxicity and the metabolic syndrome. Biochim Biophys Acta 1801: 235–239. doi: 10.1016/j.bbalip.2009.11.003
- 2. Vockley J (2008) Metabolism as a complex genetic trait, a systems biology approach: Implications for inborn errors of metabolism and clinical diseases. J Inherit Metab Dis 31: 619–29. doi: 10.1007/s10545-008-1005-8
- 3. Boden G (2008) Obesity and free fatty acids. Endocrinol Metab Clin North Am 37: 635–46, viii–ix.
- 4. Glund S, Schoelch C, Thomas L, Niessen HG, Stiller D, et al. (2012) Inhibition of acetyl-CoA carboxylase 2 enhances skeletal muscle fatty acid oxidation and improves whole-body glucose homeostasis in db/db mice. Diabetologia 55: 2044–53. doi: 10.1007/s00125-012-2554-9
- 5. Zhang L, Keung W, Samokhvalov V, Wang W, Lopaschuk GD (2010) Role of fatty acid uptake and fatty acid beta-oxidation in mediating insulin resistance in heart and skeletal muscle. Biochim Biophys Acta 1801: 1–22. doi: 10.1016/j.bbalip.2009.09.014
- 6. Koves TR, Ussher JR, Noland RC, Slentz D, Mosedale M, et al. (2008) Mitochondrial overload and incomplete fatty acid oxidation contribute to skeletal muscle insulin resistance. Cell Metab 7: 45–56. doi: 10.1016/j.cmet.2007.10.013
- 7. Noland RC, Koves TR, Seiler SE, Lum H, Lust RM, et al. (2009) Carnitine insufficiency caused by aging and overnutrition compromises mitochondrial performance and metabolic control. J Biol Chem 284: 22840–22852. doi: 10.1074/jbc.m109.032888
- 8. Mihalik SJ, Goodpaster BH, Kelley DE, Chace DH, Vockley J, et al. (2010) Increased levels of plasma acylcarnitines in obesity and type 2 diabetes and identification of a marker of glucolipotoxicity. Obesity (Silver Spring) 18: 1695–1700. doi: 10.1038/oby.2009.510
- 9. Spiekerkoetter U, Bastin J, Gillingham M, Morris A, Wijburg F, et al. (2010) Current issues regarding treatment of mitochondrial fatty acid oxidation disorders. J Inherit Metab Dis 33: 555–561. doi: 10.1007/s10545-010-9188-1
- 10. Spiekerkoetter U, Mayatepek E (2010) Update on mitochondrial fatty acid oxidation disorders. J Inherit Metab Dis 33: 467–468. doi: 10.1007/s10545-010-9208-1
- 11. Kohn MC, Garfinkel D (1983) Computer simulation of metabolism in palmitate-perfused rat heart. I. palmitate oxidation. Ann Biomed Eng 11: 361–384. doi: 10.1007/bf02584214
- 12. Modre-Osprian R, Osprian I, Tilg B, Schreier G, Weinberger KM, et al. (2009) Dynamic simulations on the mitochondrial fatty acid beta-oxidation network. BMC Syst Biol 3: 2. doi: 10.1186/1752-0509-3-2
- 13. Boogerd FC, Bruggeman FJ, Richardson RC, Stephan A, Westerhoff HV (2005) Emergence and its place in nature: A case study of biochemical networks. Synthese 145: 131–164. doi: 10.1007/s11229-004-4421-9
- 14. Sahoo S, Franzson L, Jonsson JJ, Thiele I (2012) A compendium of inborn errors of metabolism mapped onto the human metabolic network. Mol Biosyst 8: 2545–2558. doi: 10.1039/c2mb25075f
- 15. Izai K, Uchida Y, Orii T, Yamamoto S, Hashimoto T (1992) Novel fatty acid beta-oxidation enzymes in rat liver mitochondria. I. purification and properties of very-long-chain acyl-coenzyme A dehydrogenase. The Journal of Biological Chemistry 267: 1027–1033.
- 16. Ikeda Y, Dabrowski C, Tanaka K (1983) Separation and properties of five distinct acyl-CoA dehydrogenases from rat liver mitochondria. identification of a new 2-methyl branched chain acyl-CoA dehydrogenase. J Biol Chem 258: 1066–1076.
- 17. Ikeda Y, Okamura-Ikeda K, Tanaka K (1985) Purification and characterization of short-chain, medium-chain, and long-chain acyl-CoA dehydrogenases from rat liver mitochondria. isolation of the holo- and apoenzymes and conversion of the apoenzyme to the holoenzyme. J Biol Chem 260: 1311–1325.
- 18. Chegary M, Brinke Ht, Ruiter JPN, Wijburg FA, Stoll MSK, et al. (2009) Mitochondrial long chain fatty acid beta-oxidation in man and mouse. Biochimica Et Biophysica Acta 1791: 806–815. doi: 10.1016/j.bbalip.2009.05.006
- 19. Eaton S, Bursby T, Middleton B, Pourfarzam M, Mills K, et al. (2000) The mitochondrial trifunctional protein: Centre of a beta-oxidation metabolon? Biochemical Society Transactions 28: 177–182.
- 20. Middleton B (1973) The oxoacyl-coenzyme A thiolases of animal tissues. Biochemical Journal 132: 717.
- 21. Furuta S, Miyazawa S, Osumi T, Hashimoto T, Ui N (1980) Properties of mitochondria and peroxisomal enoyl-CoA hydratases from rat liver. Journal of Biochemistry 88: 1059–1070.
- 22. Miyazawa S, Furuta S, Osumi T, Hashimoto T, Ui N (1981) Properties of peroxisomal 3-ketoacyl-coA thiolase from rat liver. Journal of Biochemistry 90: 511–519.
- 23. Uchida Y, Izai K, Orii T, Hashimoto T (1992) Novel fatty acid beta-oxidation enzymes in rat liver mitochondria. II. purification and properties of enoyl-coenzyme A (CoA) hydratase/3-hydroxyacyl-CoA dehydrogenase/3-ketoacyl-CoA thiolase trifunctional protein. The Journal of Biological Chemistry 267: 1034–1041.
- 24. Osumi T, Hashimoto T (1980) Purification and properties of mitochondrial and peroxisomal 3-hydroxyacyl-CoA dehydrogenase from rat liver. Archives of Biochemistry and Biophysics 203: 372–383. doi: 10.1016/0003-9861(80)90189-7
- 25. Kobayashi A, Jiang LL, Hashimoto T (1996) Two mitochondrial 3-hydroxyacyl-CoA dehydrogenases in bovine liver. Journal of Biochemistry 119: 775–782. doi: 10.1093/oxfordjournals.jbchem.a021307
- 26. Goldberg RN, Tewari YB, Bell D, Fazio K, Anderson E (1993) Thermodynamics of enzyme-catalyzed reactions: Part 1. oxidoreductases. J Phys Chem Ref Data 22: 515–582. doi: 10.1063/1.555939
- 27. Saha AK, Kurowski TG, Colca JR, Ruderman NB (1994) Lipid abnormalities in tissues of the KKAy mouse: Effects of pioglitazone on malonyl-CoA and diacylglycerol. Am J Physiol 267: E95–101.
- 28. Bandyopadhyay GK, Yu JG, Ofrecio J, Olefsky JM (2006) Increased malonyl-CoA levels in muscle from obese and type 2 diabetic subjects lead to decreased fatty acid oxidation and increased lipogenesis; thiazolidinedione treatment reverses these defects. Diabetes 55: 2277–2285. doi: 10.2337/db06-0062
- 29. Simoneau JA, Veerkamp JH, Turcotte LP, Kelley DE (1999) Markers of capacity to utilize fatty acids in human skeletal muscle: Relation to insulin resistance and obesity and effects of weight loss. FASEB J 13: 2051–2060.
- 30. Pimenta AS, Gaidhu MP, Habib S, So M, Fediuc S, et al. (2008) Prolonged exposure to palmitate impairs fatty acid oxidation despite activation of AMP-activated protein kinase in skeletal muscle cells. J Cell Physiol 217: 478–485. doi: 10.1002/jcp.21520
- 31. Bengtsson C, Blaho S, Saitton DB, Brickmann K, Broddefalk J, et al. (2011) Design of small molecule inhibitors of acetyl-CoA carboxylase 1 and 2 showing reduction of hepatic malonyl-CoA levels in vivo in obese zucker rats. Bioorg Med Chem 19: 3039–3053. doi: 10.1016/j.bmc.2011.04.014
- 32. Pender C, Trentadue AR, Pories WJ, Dohm GL, Houmard JA, et al. (2006) Expression of genes regulating malonyl-CoA in human skeletal muscle. J Cell Biochem 99: 860–867. doi: 10.1002/jcb.20944
- 33. Ishikawa M, Tsuchiya D, Oyama T, Tsunaka Y, Morikawa K (2004) Structural basis for channelling mechanism of a fatty acid beta-oxidation multienzyme complex. EMBO J 23: 2745–2754. doi: 10.1038/sj.emboj.7600298
- 34. Sumegi B, Srere PA (1984) Binding of the enzymes of fatty acid beta-oxidation and some related enzymes to pig heart inner mitochondrial membrane. J Biol Chem 259: 8748–8752.
- 35. Nada MA, Rhead WJ, Sprecher H, Schulz H, Roe CR (1995) Evidence for intermediate channeling in mitochondrial beta-oxidation. The Journal of Biological Chemistry 270: 530–535. doi: 10.1074/jbc.270.2.530
- 36. Liang X, Le W, Zhang D, Schulz H (2001) Impact of the intramitochondrial enzyme organization on fatty acid oxidation. Biochemical Society Transactions 29: 279–282. doi: 10.1042/bst0290279
- 37. Eaton S, Bartlett K, Pourfarzam M (1999) Intermediates of myocardial mitochondrial beta-oxidation: Possible channelling of NADH and of CoA esters. Biochimica Et Biophysica Acta 1437: 402–408. doi: 10.1016/s1388-1981(99)00027-x
- 38. Fukushima T, Decker RV, Anderson WM, Spivey HO (1989) Substrate channeling of NADH and binding of dehydrogenases to complex I. J Biol Chem 264: 16483–16488.
- 39. Sumegi B, Srere PA (1984) Complex I binds several mitochondrial NAD-coupled dehydrogenases. J Biol Chem 259: 15040–15045.
- 40. Sumegi B, Porpaczy Z, Alkonyi I (1991) Kinetic advantage of the interaction between the fatty acid beta-oxidation enzymes and the complexes of the respiratory chain. Biochim Biophys Acta 1081: 121–128. doi: 10.1016/0005-2760(91)90016-b
- 41. Bain JR, Stevens RD, Wenner BR, Ilkayeva O, Muoio DM, et al. (2009) Metabolomics applied to diabetes research: Moving from information to knowledge. Diabetes 58: 2429–2443. doi: 10.2337/db09-0580
- 42. Ringseis R, Keller J, Eder K (2012) Role of carnitine in the regulation of glucose homeostasis and insulin sensitivity: Evidence from in vivo and in vitro studies with carnitine supplementation and carnitine deficiency. Eur J Nutr 51: 1–18. doi: 10.1007/s00394-011-0284-2
- 43. Holzhutter HG (2004) The principle of flux minimization and its application to estimate stationary fluxes in metabolic networks. Eur J Biochem 271: 2905–2922. doi: 10.1111/j.1432-1033.2004.04213.x
- 44. Schmitz JP, van Riel NA, Nicolay K, Hilbers PA, Jeneson JA (2010) Silencing of glycolysis in muscle: Experimental observation and numerical analysis. Exp Physiol 95: 380–397. doi: 10.1113/expphysiol.2009.049841
- 45. Lambeth MJ, Kushmerick MJ (2002) A computational model for glycogenolysis in skeletal muscle. Ann Biomed Eng 30: 808–827. doi: 10.1114/1.1492813
- 46. Wu F, Yang F, Vinnakota KC, Beard DA (2007) Computer modeling of mitochondrial tricarboxylic acid cycle, oxidative phosphorylation, metabolite transport, and electrophysiology. J Biol Chem 282: 24525–24537. doi: 10.1074/jbc.m701024200
- 47. Mildaziene V, Nauciene Z, Baniene R, Grigiene J (2002) Multiple effects of 2,2′,5,5′-tetrachlorobiphenyl on oxidative phosphorylation in rat liver mitochondria. Toxicol Sci 65: 220–227. doi: 10.1093/toxsci/65.2.220
- 48. Gnaiger E, Kuznetsov A, Schneeberger S, Seiler R, Brandacher G, et al.. (2000) Mitochondria in the cold. In: Heldmeier G, Klingenspor M, editors. Life in the Cold. Berlin Heidelberg New York: Springer. pp. 431.
- 49. Derks TG, Boer TS, van Assen A, Bos T, Ruiter J, et al. (2008) Neonatal screening for medium-chain acyl-CoA dehydrogenase (MCAD) deficiency in the netherlands: The importance of enzyme analysis to ascertain true MCAD deficiency. J Inherit Metab Dis 31: 88–96. doi: 10.1007/s10545-007-0492-3
- 50. Gates SC, Sweeley CC (1978) Quantitative metabolic profiling based on gas chromatography. Clin Chem 24: 1663–1673.