Propionibacterium freudenreichii is essential as a ripening culture in Swiss-type cheeses and is also considered for its probiotic use . This species exhibits slow growth, low nutritional requirements, and hardiness in many habitats. It belongs to the taxonomic group of dairy propionibacteria, in contrast to the cutaneous species P. acnes. The genome of the type strain, P. freudenreichii subsp. shermanii CIRM-BIA1 (CIP 103027T), was sequenced with an 11-fold coverage.
The circular chromosome of 2.7 Mb of the CIRM-BIA1 strain has a GC-content of 67% and contains 22 different insertion sequences (3.5% of the genome in base pairs). Using a proteomic approach, 490 of the 2439 predicted proteins were confirmed. The annotation revealed the genetic basis for the hardiness of P. freudenreichii, as the bacterium possesses a complete enzymatic arsenal for de novo biosynthesis of aminoacids and vitamins (except panthotenate and biotin) as well as sequences involved in metabolism of various carbon sources, immunity against phages, duplicated chaperone genes and, interestingly, genes involved in the management of polyphosphate, glycogen and trehalose storage. The complete biosynthesis pathway for a bifidogenic compound is described, as well as a high number of surface proteins involved in interactions with the host and present in other probiotic bacteria. By comparative genomics, no pathogenicity factors found in P. acnes or in other pathogenic microbial species were identified in P. freudenreichii, which is consistent with the Generally Recognized As Safe and Qualified Presumption of Safety status of P. freudenreichii. Various pathways for formation of cheese flavor compounds were identified: the Wood-Werkman cycle for propionic acid formation, amino acid degradation pathways resulting in the formation of volatile branched chain fatty acids, and esterases involved in the formation of free fatty acids and esters.
With the exception of its ability to degrade lactose, P. freudenreichii seems poorly adapted to dairy niches. This genome annotation opens up new prospects for the understanding of the P. freudenreichii probiotic activity.
Citation: Falentin H, Deutsch S-M, Jan G, Loux V, Thierry A, Parayre S, et al. (2010) The Complete Genome of Propionibacterium freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T, a Hardy Actinobacterium with Food and Probiotic Applications. PLoS ONE 5(7): e11748. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0011748
Editor: Niyaz Ahmed, University of Hyderabad, India
Received: March 30, 2010; Accepted: June 29, 2010; Published: July 23, 2010
Copyright: © 2010 Falentin et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: INRA and Genoscope supported the cost of the complete project. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
The genus Propionibacterium belongs to the class of high GC actinobacteria. All species of this genus produce propionic acid as a major metabolic end-product. However, taxonomical studies clearly distinguished two groups of propionibacteria: cutaneous and dairy. Over a century ago, P. freudenreichii was the first dairy species isolated from Emmental cheese . Since then, other dairy propionibacteria species such as P. acidipropionici, and P. thoenii have been found in milk and cheese, and sometimes also in various biotopes like silage, soil, rumen, and waste water . These observations indicate the ability to adapt to various environmental conditions. Dairy propionibacteria grow slowly (generation time ~5 h under optimal conditions) and have low nutritional requirements.
Due to its long documented use in cheese, and in particular in Swiss type cheeses, P. freudenreichii has received the American Generally Recognized as Safe (GRAS) status. It has also been granted the European Qualified Presumption of Safety (QPS) status. During ripening, this species drives the fermentation of lactate into propionate, acetate and CO2, via the Wood-Werkman cycle, resulting in the formation of the characteristic “eyes” and flavor of these cheeses. P. freudenreichii also plays an essential role in the production of other flavor compounds, such as free fatty acids released via lipolysis of milk glycerides, and branched-chain acids resulting from the catabolism of amino acids , . Because of their impact on flavor, dairy propionibacteria are now used in an increasing number of cheeses without eyes . Meanwhile, a second application of P. freudenreichii concerns production of vitamin B12, one of nature's most structurally complex small molecules. Most of the vitamin B12 pathway has been elucidated , , , , and overproducing modified strains developed.
Finally, there is increasing interest in the probiotic activity of P. freudenreichii, as the bifidogenic compound it produces, 1,4-dihydroxy-2-naphthoic acid (DHNA) , , stimulates growth of bifidobacteria, which has been shown to be beneficial for human health , . Some strains of P. freudenreichii adapt very well to gastric and bile salt stresses ,  and are able to survive and maintain active metabolism in vivo in the rat or human gut , , . Supernatants or live freeze-dried strains of propionibacteria are already commercially available as tablets to improve intestinal transit. In vitro, P. freudenreichii produces beneficial metabolites, including short chain fatty acids, and conjugated linoleic acid; some strains like P. freudenreichii JS also exhibit immunomodulatory activity .
The only completely sequenced, fully annotated and publicly available genome within the Propionibacterium genus is that of the commensal cutaneous species P. acnes .
The physiology and technological properties of P. freudenreichii subsp. shermanii CIRM-BIA1T have been studied by several teams around the world. Genome sequencing will provide the molecular basis of traits important for cheese or probiotic applications, and will allow a better assessment of the “distance” between the two main groups of propionibacteria: dairy and cutaneous.
Results and Discussion
General genome features
The genome of P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T consists of a circular chromosome of 2,616,384 base pairs (bp) with 67% GC content. The genome contains 2 rRNA operons and 45 tRNAs (Fig. 1). These small numbers are in agreement with the slow growth of this bacterium. Indeed, bacteria with few ribosomal operons tend to be slow-growing organisms that can utilize resources efficiently, and are capable of growth in low-nutrient environments . The chromosome is predicted to contain 2439 protein-coding genes, 490 of which were identified by proteomics (2D gels and 2D-LC), followed by liquid chromatography and mass spectrometry (Table S1). These proteins correspond to 16% of the total number of predicted proteins, and 29% of the 1391 proteins predicted in the pI 4–7 and 15–150 kDa ranges. The CIRM-BIA1T strain harbors no plasmid, whereas one or two plasmids, generally cryptic, have been reported in 10–30% of P. freudenreichii strains .
The outer circle shows the coding sequence by functional category: cell envelope in green, metabolism in blue, replication, transcription and traduction in yellow, other functions in orange, hypothetical proteins in violet. The second circle shows red blocks for coding sequences on the (+) strand. The third circle shows blue blocks for coding sequences on the (−) strand. The fourth circle shows rRNA in purple and tRNA in light purple. The fifth circle shows the insertion sequences and phage integrase in green. The sixth circle shows the precentage GC (window size 10,000 bp, step size 2000 bp) ranging from 59 to 72% with a step of 1%. The seventh circle shows the GC skew (window size 10,000 bp, step size 2000 bp) ranging from −0.13 to 0.09 with a step of 0.01%. The replication origin is between 10,426 bp and 12,300 bp.
Mobile elements and CRISPR
Insertion sequences and transposable elements may promote genome plasticity and contribute to bacterial adaptability . Seventy-two different transposases were found in the P. freudenreichii genome and each of them is repeated one to eight times. The genome also contains 22 different Insertion Sequences (IS) belonging to four different families (IS3, ISL3, IS30 and IS481) according to the nomenclature at http://www-is.biotoul.fr (Table S2, ). IS represent 3.47% (in base pairs) of the genome, with 2.95% of complete IS and 0.52% of partial IS. Each complete IS is repeated one to ten times. IS are located in the first and last quarters of the genome (near the replication origin).
Six of the 22 IS are repeated twice and are colocalized with two integrases between the 1,242,179 bp and 1,287,760 bp positions, which could be potentially a highly variable region. This region does not contain other genes encoding proteins of other functions.
The transposase gene is mutated in ISPfr8: a guanidine insertion created a frameshift observed in all three copies rendering it non-functional. IS Aar30 was also found in Arthrobacter arilaitensis, a bacterium of smear-ripened cheese surfaces. In only two cases does the IS contain functional genes (different from transposases): (1) ISPfr21 contains a transposase gene and two other genes, one coding for PFREUD_08140, a transcription factor belonging to the TetR regulator family, and the other coding for PFREUD_08150, a protein of unknown function similar (42%) to a protein of Sinorhizobium sp.; (2) a mobile insertion cassette (MIC) with the same termini as ISPfr11 but without the transposase gene is located between 371,214 and 372,936 bp. This MIC contains a gene encoding a protein of unknown function, PFREUD_03020, similar (52%) to a protein of Kineococcus radiotolerans. In most cases, the IS insertion has no obvious impact because very few genes are present.
However, the transposable elements of P. freudenreichii can induce phenotypic changes. The first example is provided by an IS upstream the gtf gene, PFREUD_19370. The gtf gene encodes a polysaccharide synthase involved in the synthesis of capsular exopolysaccharides (EPS). While the presence of capsular EPS in P. freudenreichii is strain-specific, all strains tested were shown to possess one gtf copy. Recently, we demonstrated that the presence of an IS element within the putative promoter region of gtf enhanced gtf transcription, and was associated to the capsular phenotype , . The second example concerns the ability to ferment lactose. P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T is able to degrade lactose but this trait is strain-dependent. In the genome, the lactose locus consists of three genes, PFREUD_02370, PFREUD_02360 and PFREUD_02350, encoding a β-galactosidase, LacZ, a galactoside transporter, GalP, and an UDP-glucose isomerase, GalE1, respectively. These three genes are surrounded by integrases (PFREUD_24460) and transposases (PFREUD_24470) (Fig. 2). GalE is similar (73% to Q6AGJ6 from Leifsonia xylii) to GalE of other actinobacteria, but LacZ and GalP are similar to those of several species of Mannheimia succiniciproducens and of Clostridium (LacZ, 55% similar to Q65UK4 from Mannheimia succiniciproducens; GalP, 52% similar to Q2WUG8 from Clostridium beijerincki). These two species, like propionibacteria, are present in the cow rumen ecosystem. These observations strongly suggest that the Lac genes may have been acquired through a horizontal transfer event mediated by phage infection, which could explain why this ability is strain dependent. As lactose fermentation is one of the two phenotypic criteria used to distinguish the subspecies P. freudenreichii subsp. shermanii (positive for lactose fermentation) from P. freudenreichii subsp. freudenreichii (negative for lactose fermentation), the justification of these subspecies should be further investigated. Since no difference in GC content was observed in these regions relative to the rest of the genome, this locus may have been acquired a long time ago.
The lactose locus consists of three genes, PFREUD_02370, PFREUD_02360 and PFREUD_02350 (numbers are indicated below the arrows), which encode a βgalactosidase, LacZ, a galactoside transporter, and an UDP-glucose isomerase, GalE, respectively. Lac genes may have been acquired through a horizontal transfer event. PFREUD_02380 encodes the N-terminal end of an N-acetylmuramic acid 6-phosphate etherase and PFREUD_02390 encodes a transcriptional regulator.
The phages in the genome could not be precisely located because the attP and attB sites are unknown. One temperate phage closely related to the L5  and FRAT1  temperate mycobacteriophages was identified. This locus contains a gene coding for a capsid protein of the HK97 family (PFREUD_04110, 57% similar to Q1B5C3 from Mycobacterium sp.), several proteins of unknown function, and a phage integrase (PFREUD_04210) with 45% similarity with the integrase of mycobacteriophage L5 (Swissprot entry VINT_BPML5).
Several traces of prophages were also identified in the genome. They are evidenced by the presence of 31 integrase loci, scattered throughout the chromosome, but with most (22/31) clustered less than 100 kb from each other. Six regions of the chromosome have clusters of integrases: (1) between 124,000 and 129,000 bp, two copies of the PFREUD_24770; (2) from 233,000 to 291,000 bp, three integrases PFREUD_24990, PFREUD_24980 and PFREUD_24460 at the lactose locus; (3) from 427,000 to 509,000, three integrases (PFREUD_24610, PFREUD_24630 and PFREUD_04210); (4) from 1,825,318 to 1,836,629 bp, PFREUD_24770 and PFREUD_24830; (5) from 2,288,000 to 2,295,000 bp PFREUD_24990, PFREUD_24980; and, lastly, (6) from 2,432,000 to 2,482,000, PFREUD_21190, PFREUD_22610 to PFREUD_22650, PFREUD_25160, and PFREUD_25070. These regions also have a lower GC content (Fig. 1). This illustrates the highly variable regions in the genome.
Phage attacks are frequently reported during cheese manufacture using lactic acid bacteria, but not for dairy propionibacteria. However, lysogeny was fully demonstrated for P. freudenreichii ITG P18 and the presence of prophage was detected using hybridization experiments with phi101 in many species, including CIRM BIA1 . Clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR) provide acquired resistance to viruses in prokaryotes, as recently demonstrated in Streptococcus thermophilus . CRISPR loci typically consist of several non-contiguous direct repeats separated by variable sequences called spacers and are often adjacent to cas (CRISPR associated) genes. Three CRISPR loci were identified in the P. freudenreichii genome using the CRISPR finder tool (crispr.u-psud.fr/Server/CRISPRfinder.php,). In silico analyses of the spacers showed sequence similarities with foreign elements, including bacteriophages sequences. The CRISPR1 locus, located between 441,264 and 443,689 bp, harbors a 36 bp direct repeat (DR) sequence GCCTCAATGAAGGGCCCCTCCAGAAGGAGGGGCAAT and 34 spacer sequences of 35 to 40 bp. Blast results on the EMBL phage database (http://blast.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/Blast.cgi) showed that the third spacer displays a strong similarity (32/39 nt identity) to the Stenotrophomonas phage S1 (EU849489), and that the 26th and 27th spacers shared a high level of identity with orf6 and orf9 of the Propionibacterium phage phiB5, a filamentous ssDNA inovirus . Two other possible CRISPR loci were identified, however they did not contain two identical DRs. The first locus, located between 652,209 and 652,301 bp, contains the 23 bp DR sequence CAAGCGCCCTGCTGTGTTCGTTT and only one spacer, without homology. The second one, located between 2,215,874 and 2,216,038, contains a 24 bp DR sequence CTTCTTCGCCGCCGGCTTCTTGGC and three spacer sequences without homology in the database. The PFREUD_03690 gene for cas1/cas4 associated CRISPR proteins was found near the replication origin between 399 and 2000 bp but no CRISPR was associated with it. The presence of CRISPR loci indicates that P. freudenreichii has been in contact with phages, and strongly suggests that they may contribute to its resistance to phage attacks.
In conclusion, IS and prophages are a source of plasticity and adaptability of the bacteria to various environments, and the influence of transposable elements on two phenotypic traits in P. freudenreichii was illustrated by the formation of a capsular EPS and the ability to ferment lactose. The presence of the CRISPR loci may protect P. freudenreichii against phage attacks.
Comparative genomics with P. acnes
Belonging to the cutaneous group, P. acnes is the only species within the Propionibacterium genus with a complete genome sequence publicly available. A comparison of this species with P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T was carried out. P. acnes has a 2.5 Mb and 60% GC genome composed of 2333 putative genes . The two species differ by their habitat and ecology. P. acnes is a major inhabitant of human skin and is considered to be an opportunistic pathogen, while P. freudenreichii has GRAS status. The two species, however, share some similarities. Both species can grow under microaerophilic and anaerobic conditions, and produce propionic acid as the main fermentation product. To compare gene colinearity, we aligned the genomes at the protein level because the nucleotide sequences were too divergent (Fig. 3). A relatively high synteny between the genomes was observed, with the exception of two inversions between 90,000–120,000 bp and 100,000–115,000 bp. We also mined the P. freudenreichii genome to look for the genes potentially involved in pathogenicity described in the P. acnes genome. In performing bidirectional best hits (Table S3), no similarity was found between the P. freudenreichii predicted protein set, and P. acnes proteins putatively involved in the degradation of host molecules or in mediating inflammation. In particular, the genes encoding endoglycoceramidase, sialidase, hemolysin, CMP factor, and toxins in P. acnes were not identified in P. freudenreichii. However, two genes annotated in P. acnes as encoding invasion-associated proteins (PPA_1962 and PPA_0721) were found in P. freudenreichii (three-quarters of the C-terminal part of PFREUD_04850 is 50% similar to Q6A6D4; PFREUD_04280 is 73% similar to Q6A9T8 from P. acnes). These proteins were annotated in P. freudenreichii as “cell-wall peptidase, NlpC/P60 family secreted protein”, due to their high similarity (73% and 76%) to S. coelicolor Q9KY71_STRCO and Q9KY68_STRCO, respectively, and the presence of a signal peptide and Pfam 00877 domain.
dnaA is at the zero position. Forward matches are displayed in red and reverse matches are displayed in blue. Relatively high synteny along the genome is observed, with the exception of two inversions between 90,000–120,000 bp and 100,000–115,000 bp.
We also compared the putative esterases/lipases in P. freudenreichii and P. acnes because lipolytic activity is an important feature in both species. P. freudenreichii has a major role in the hydrolysis of milk glycerides during cheese ripening . The free fatty acids resulting from lipolysis are important compounds in cheese flavor. P. acnes lipases are thought to degrade human skin lipids such as sebum. Free fatty acids resulting from this activity could promote bacterial adherence and colonization of the sebaceous follicle . Comparison of esterases/lipases in P. acnes and P. freudenreichii showed that the two species shared a common pool of intracellular esterases, but differed in secreted esterases/lipases. P. acnes produces a secreted lipase, GehA, and another lipase with 41% identity to GehA at the protein level, encoded by the genes PPA2105 and PPA1796, respectively , . Neither of these proteins has an ortholog in P. freudenreichii. P. freudenreichii was recently shown to produce a secreted lipase active on milk fat, encoded by PFREUD_04340 . However, this enzyme has no ortholog in P. acnes. Of the 11 putative esterases identified in the P. freudenreichii genome, six predicted cytoplasmic proteins and one potentially surfaced exposed protein , , have orthologs in P. acnes.
In conclusion, no pathogenicity factor from P. acnes was identified in P. freudenreichii. This finding is consistent with the GRAS and QPS status of P. freudenreichii.
Reconstruction of specific metabolic pathways
Carbon substrates and nutritional requirements.
Experimentally, P. freudenreichii is able to grow, under anaerobic conditions, in a minimal medium containing a carbon source, ammonium as the sole nitrogen source, minerals, and two to four vitamins. Like most other P. freudenreichii strains, CIRM-BIA1T is able to use a variety of carbon substrates, including sugars (lactose, galactose, D-glucose, D-mannose), alcohols (erythritol, glycerol, adonitol), and acids (lactic acid, gluconic acid)  (Table S4). Genome annotation clearly confirmed that this strain was able to import these carbon sources and to catabolise them by different pathways (glycolysis, pentose phosphate, and Entner-Doudoroff pathways). The use of other carbon substrates, such as D-fructose, L-arabinose, ribose, D-raffinose, saccharose, xylitol, and gluconic acid, is strain-dependent in P. freudenreichii (Table S4). For example, the CIRM-BIA1T strain does not catabolise L-arabinose, in contrast to most P.freudenreichii strains. The araB gene (PFREUD_06570 and PFREUD_06580) encoding a ribulokinase is a pseudogene in the CIRM-BIA1T strain. At least one other araB gene is present at another locus of the genome (PFREUD_22370) and may complement the pseudogene. However, no transporter for arabinose was found, which may explain why CIRM-BIA1T does not catabolize L-arabinose. The ability to use propanediol, a less common growth substrate, was reported for P. freudenreichii subsp. freudenreichii ATCC 6207 . CIRM-BIA1T possesses a complete pdu (propanediol utilization) operon (from PFREUD_08980 to PFREUD_09150), with predicted proteins similar to those of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium , . The gene order is not conserved in the two species; however, as in Salmonella, an integrase-coding gene was identified at the end of the locus, suggesting that this operon could have been acquired through horizontal transfer.
Regarding nitrogen requirements, P. freudenreichii is prototrophic for all amino acids and nucleotides. The complete biosynthetic pathways of all amino acids were reconstituted (to examine the complete pathways with the annotated genes, see http://www.genome.jp/kegg/catalog/org_list.html).
Regarding vitamins, all propionibacteria strains require pantothenate (vitamin B5) and biotin (vitamin H). Some strains require thiamine (B1) and p-aminobenzoic acid in addition . Genome data showed that all the vitamin synthesis pathways are complete in strain CIRM-BIA1T, with the exception of pantothenate and biotin. In our study, it was shown (see Material & Methods and Table S5) that pantothenate and biotin were indeed required for CIRM-BIA1T growth, in agreement with genomic data. Unexpectedly, we also observed that P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T required thiamine whereas the biosynthetic pathway seemed complete. The vitamin B12 synthesis pathway (anaerobic early cobalt incorporation) of one strain of P. freudenreichii was previously described in detail –. Fourteen genes were cloned in E. coli and were sequenced. The organization of genes for vitamin B12 synthesis in CIRM-BIA1T is in agreement with the results reported for this strain (Fig. 4). However, five new genes (cbiA, cobU, cobS, cobR at locus (c) and hemD) were discovered and revealed another locus putatively responsible for cobalt transport (PFREUD_20190 and 20200). The complete description of vitamin B12 synthesis pathway in P. freudenreichii opens up new prospects for genetic engineering and for the screening of highly productive strains using molecular tools.
(A) Vitamin B12 pathway: enzyme number (red), gene name (green) and locus tag (black). (B) Four loci (a, b, c, d) are involved in vitamin B12 biosynthesis. Gene names are indicated above the arrows, locus tags (PFREUD) are indicated below the arrows. The locus (a) codes for the cobalt ABC transporter. The colors of the arrows used in (B) for locus b, c and d are also used for the pathway background in (A), with the exeption of the steps in the white background corresponding to isolated genes (hemD and cobT2/bluB).
Wood-Werkman cycle and pyruvate conversion.
Propionic acid is the major end product of fermentation in propionibacteria and confers their typical flavor to Swiss-type cheeses. Two pathways of propionate formation have been described in bacteria. The first pathway, known as Wood-Werkman cycle, involves succinyl-CoA and methylmalonyl-CoA as intermediates. It was first described in P. freudenreichii and Pelobacter propionicus , and is present in other bacterial species such as Bacteroïdes fragilis , Veillonella parvula , and Veillonella gazogenes . The second pathway involves an acrylyl-CoA intermediate and has been described in Clostridium propionicum . The Wood-Werkman cycle was extensively investigated in P. freudenreichii at biochemical – and genetic levels. It includes a methylmalonyl-CoA carboxytransferase, a methylmalonyl-CoA epimerase, and a methylmalonyl-CoA mutase. The key feature of the Wood-Werkman cycle in P. freudenreichii is a transcarboxylation reaction without the involvement of free CO2. The enzyme catalyzing this reaction is a methylmalonyl-CoA carboxytransferase, transferring a carboxyl group from methylmalonyl-CoA to pyruvate to form oxaloacetate and propionyl-CoA (Fig. 5). The enzyme involved has been fully characterized and its structure resolved. It is a biotin-dependent carboxytransferase (EC 188.8.131.52) composed of three subunits. The methylmalonyl-CoA carboxytransferase is encoded by a polycistronic gene containing four coding sequences . In CIRM-BIA1T, the 1.3S and the 5S subunits, encoded by PFREUD_18840 and PFREUD_18870, have the same length and share 76% and 99% similarity with Swissprot entries P02904 and Q70AC7 from P. freudenreichii subsp. shermanii W52, respectively. The 12S subunit, encoded by PFREUD_18860, shares 96% similarity with the N-terminal part (524 amino acids) of the Swiss-Prot entry Q8GBW6, and would be a functional but truncated protein, as in the P. acnes genome . Another coding sequence (PFREUD_18850) encodes the C-terminal part (98% similarity with the Swiss-Prot entry Q8GBW6) of the 12S subunit. The 12S subunit coding sequence is in agreement with those of P. acnes but do not agree with the crystallographic data of the 12S subunit in P. freudenreichii . The 12S subunit coding sequence is probably strain-dependant without effect on the enzyme functionality because the catalytic domains are all located in the N-terminal part of the protein.
Enzyme numbers are in red, gene names are in green, and locus tags are in black. Reactions are directed toward propionate production, but are reversible.
The complete Wood-Werkman cycle could be reconstituted (Fig. 5), as well as the pathway for oxidative decarboxylation of pyruvate, which results in the formation of acetate and CO2. A partial TCA cycle was also reconstituted, but lacked a succinyl-CoA hydrolase (E.C.184.108.40.206) (Fig. 5). This activity was previously described in P. freudenreichii subsp. freudenreichii CIP103026 . In the CIRM-BIA1T strain, succinyl-CoA formation results from CoA transferase activity.
The co-metabolism of aspartate/asparagine and lactate was previously reported . During lactate fermentation, aspartate is deaminated to fumarate by an aspartate ammonia lyase ( = aspartase) encoded by aspA (PFREUD_16320 and PFREUD_16330), fumarate is then converted to succinate, with regeneration of oxidized co-enzymes and ATP. The intensity of this conversion depends on the conditions and on the P. freudenreichii strain , . Interestingly, cells using this pathway modulate the conversion of pyruvate towards oxidative decarboxylation to maintain their oxido-reduction balance, leading to more acetate and CO2 at the expense of pyruvate, which is reduced to propionate via the Wood-Werkman cycle. In addition to this aspartate catabolism pathway, other genes encoding aspartate-converting enzymes were found in the CIRM-BIA1T genome: aminotransferases (aspB encoded by PFREUD_04930, tyrB encoded by PFREUD_09460, aspC encoded by PFREUD_23330), L-aspartate oxidase, (EC 220.127.116.11, encoded by nadB (PFREUD_09210 and PFREUD_21690)) and adenylosuccinate synthetase (EC 18.104.22.168, encoded by PFREUD_19280). Each enzymatic activity can impact intracellular aspartate concentration and can modulate CO2 production, consequently affecting the size of the eyes that form in cheese.
Although P. freudenreichii is usually grown under anaerobic or microaerophilic conditions, it possesses all the genes required for aerobic respiration: genes encoding NADH dehydrogenase (EC 22.214.171.124/126.96.36.199, nuoA, nuoB, nuoC, nuoD, nuoE, nuoF, nuoG, nuoH, nuoI, nuoJ, nuoK, nuoL, nuoM, nuoN), succinate dehydrogenase (EC 188.8.131.52, sdhA, sdhA3, sdhB, sdhB3 and two sdhC), cytochrome bd complex (cydA and cydB), ATPase (atpA, atpB, atpC, atpD, atpE, atpF, atpG, atpH) and the complete pathway for heme synthesis (hem genes). Under anaerobic conditions, the electron acceptor in P. freudenreichii can be sulfate, fumarate, menaquinone (vitamin K2), or the pool of ferrous iron and humic acid in the soil . Nitrate cannot be used as an electron acceptor, because CIRM-BIA1T has no denitrification capacity. In fact, the gene corresponding to the beta subunit of nitrate reductase is a pseudogene due to a frameshift. The ability to reduce nitrate is the second criterion used to distinguish the subspecies shermanii (negative) from freudenreichii (positive).
High storage ability and long survival
P. freudenreichii displays numerous features which allow its long-term survival, including the accumulation of energy and carbon storage compounds, the accumulation of compatible solutes, and the induction of a multi-tolerance response under carbon starvation.
Interestingly, P. freudenreichii is able to accumulate inorganic polyphosphate (polyP) as an energy reserve whereas most bacteria utilize ATP. Only bacteria particularly adapted to extreme environments are able to use polyP . P. freudenreichii strain ST33 grown on lactate accumulates large amounts of long-chain polyP, up to 3% of the cell dry weight , whereas ST33 accumulates short chain polyP and exhibits a 100-fold decrease in the amount of long chain polyP when grown on glucose. The key enzyme involved in the synthesis of polyP in bacteria is polyphosphate kinase (PPK). PPK synthesizes polyP by transferring the terminal phosphate of ATP to polyP. In many species, ppk mutants are unable to survive during stationary phase . In P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T, the ppk gene is followed by genes coding for NUDIX (a kind of pyrophosphohydrolase) and for an ABC phosphate transporter. Several polyP or pyrophosphate using enzymes were found in the genome (Table S6). We detected nine different NUDIX hydrolases (PFREUD_02720, PFREUD_07140, PFREUD_09230, PFREUD_09830, PFREUD_10620, PFREUD_17200, PFREUD_18300, PFREUD_19450, PFREUD_19940). In eukaryotes and prokaryotes, the number of NUDIX genes varies from 0 to 30. A high number of NUDIX genes reflects the metabolic complexity and adaptability of the organism . Utilization of pyrophosphate instead of ATP also adds metabolic flexibility, because reactions become reversible. For example, pyrophosphate phosphofructokinase (PFREUD_12040) is involved both in glycolysis and in gluconeogenesis .
P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T is able to synthesize glycogen, as reported for the first time using in vivo 13C NMR analysis of cells grown in the presence of 13C glucose . The genes potentially involved in glycogen metabolism had not been previously described in P. freudenreichii. Six genes related to glycogen metabolism were identified in the genome: PFREUD_16180, PFREUD_16190, PFREUD_10630, PFREUD_10670, PFREUD_10700, and PFREUD_22680, encoding ADP-glucose pyrophosphorylase, a glycogen synthase, a glycogen branching enzyme, an α-glucan phosphorylase, and two glycogen debranching enzymes, respectively. Four of these six genes were also found in P. acnes. Since phenotypic data indicate that neither P. freudenreichii nor P. acnes is able to ferment extracellular glycogen, these enzymes must be involved in intracellular glycogen accumulation and/or hydrolysis.
P. freudenreichii strains, including CIRM-BIA1T, are able to synthesize and accumulate trehalose from glucose and pyruvate . The synthesis of trehalose is enhanced at the beginning of the stationary phase and under oxidative, osmotic, and acid stress conditions , . This ability is strain-dependent . Trehalose is most commonly synthesised in bacteria via the trehalose-6-phosphate synthase/phosphatase (OtsA–OtsB) pathway and catabolised by trehalose synthase (TreS). The genes otsA, otsB, and treS were previously identified in strain NIZO B365 . These three genes (PFREUD_12170, PFREUD_12160, PFREUD_10650) were similarly organized in CIRM-BIA1T and the corresponding proteins showed 99%, 99% and 100% similarity, respectively, to the previously reported sequences.
P. freudenreichii is also known to accumulate glycine betaine. In addition to osmotic stress adaptation , glycine betaine participates in long-term survival, as does trehalose, by acting as a chemical chaperone. Genes supporting glycine betaine transport and biosynthesis reflect this ability. Glycine betaine is synthesized by oxidation of choline (dehydrogenase, PFREUD_19130), leading to betaine aldehyde, which is then oxidized to glycine betaine (Betaine-aldehyde dehydrogenase, dha1, PFREUD_01860).
P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T survives for a very long time at room temperature even under conditions of carbon starvation, and is considered a non-lytic strain. Starvation and stationary phases induce a multi-tolerance response in P. freudenreichii , associated with over-expression of molecular protein chaperones . A few strains of this species (about 7%) are unable to survive after one week under such conditions and lyse . The polyP and glycogen accumulated in the exponential phase and trehalose accumulated at the beginning of the stationary phase are likely to be useful for cell survival in the stationary phase, or in the dormant phase induced by carbon or oxygen starvation. Dormancy has previously been reported in other actinobacteria like Koccuria sp, Mycobacterium sp. and Rhodoccocus sp . Dormancy is defined as ‘a reversible state of low metabolic activity, in which cells can persist for extended periods without division’ . In the P. freudenreichii genome, PFREUD_06100 encodes a protein similar (50%) to the Rpf (resuscitation promoting factor) protein from Mycobacterium smegmatis ATCC 700084. Rpf is an essential protein for the growth of dormant cells from different actinobacteria and is propably involved in long-term survival of P. freudenreichii.
In conclusion, several genes involved in phosphate, glycogen, and trehalose metabolism and a gene encoding an Rpf protein are good candidates to explain the survival of a majority of P. freudenreichii strains in long-term stationary phase conditions. The long-term survival ability is favorable for both probiotic and cheese starter applications of dairy propionibacteria.
Probiotic potential of Propionibacterium freudenreichii
General stress adaptation genes, key factors of probiotic capacity, are multicopy and stress-induced in P. freudenreichii. Two copies of the groSL operon (groL: PFREUD_06470, PFREUD_18470; groS: PFREUD_06460), the clpB ATP-dependent protease (PFREUD_17920, PFREUD_19250), the endopeptidase clpP (PFREUD_08240, PFREUD_08250), the dnaKJ operon (dnaK: PFREUD_04630, PFREUD_17840; dnaJ: PFREUD_04650, PFREUD_17820), and grpE (PFREUD_04640, PFREUD_17830) and 3 copies of the surface serine protease htrA (PFREUD_17860, PFREUD_02310, PFREUD_02320) and the hsp20 chaperone (PFREUD_09500, PFREUD_22780, PFREUD_22790) were found in the genome. The redundancy and inducibility of this chaperone and protease machinery in P. freudenreichii ,  suggests the ability to efficiently and rapidly adapt to stressful environments, such as the human host .
Stress-induced genes reflect the ability to cope with digestive (acid and bile) stresses. Regulation of intracellular pH is crucial for survival. Analysis of the P. freudenreichii genome reveals a complete atpBEFHAGDC operon, whose gamma chain (atpG, PFREUD_10480) is induced in P. freudenreichii by acid and bile salts . These stimuli also induce pyruvate-flavodoxin oxidoreductase (nifJ, PFREUD_01840) and succinate dehydrogenase (sdhB, PFREUD_14300), which are involved in electron transport and ATP synthesis, as well as glutamate decarboxylase (gadB, PFREUD_23230) and aspartate ammonia-lyase (aspA, PFREUD_16320), which are involved in intracellular pH homeostasis. Proteins involved in protection and repair of DNA are crucial for survival. Genome analysis demonstrated the presence of members of the SOS response including lexA, recA and uvrABC in P. freudenreichii. Moreover, the helix-destabilizing Ssb protein (PFREUD_23460), which is involved in DNA recombination and repair, as well as Dps (PFREUD_02870), which protects DNA against oxidative stress, are stress-induced in P. freudenreichii . Stress-induced genes also reflect the ability to modulate the envelope properties. This includes the D-alanylalanine synthetase (ddlA, PFREUD_13250) and the UDP- MurNAc-pentapeptide synthetase (murF, PFREUD_15540) , . The murF gene localizes to the same locus as the entire set of genes corresponding to peptidoglycan biosynthesis in P. freudenreichii, suggesting co-regulation. Stress-induced genes include the branched-chain aminoacid transferase IlvE (PFREUD_13350), which is involved in the synthesis of branched-chain fatty acids that are important for stress tolerance in S. aureus . Survival and activity within the gut depend on oxidative stress remediation, as bile was shown to induce oxidative stress . P. freudenreichii possesses an arsenal of genes for disulfide-reduction and elimination of reactive oxygen species. The P. freudenreichii genome encodes a redundant thioredoxin system (10 thioredoxins: PFREUD_05410, PFREUD_19550, PFREUD_24100, PFREUD_24110, PFREUD_10600, PFREUD_07790, PFREUD_17940, PFREUD_18140, PFREUD_08110, PFREUD_00640) and two peptide-methionine-S-oxide reductases (PFREUD_17100, PFREUD_12520). Moreover, in response to bile salts, P. freudenreichii over-expressed the iron/manganese superoxide dismutase (SodA, PFREUD_06110), catalase (KatA, PFREUD_23800), Glutathione S-transferase (Gst, PFREUD_12610), two cysteine synthases (Cys2, PFREUD_16420; Cys1, PFREUD_06560) and S-adenosylmethionine synthetase (MetK, PFREUD_11410). The occurrence of a sodium/bile acid symporter, PFREUD_14830, reflects adaptation to the gut environment. Moreover, we identified four genes encoding multidrug resistance transporters (PFREUD_08180, PFREUD_17620, PFREUD_22240, PFREUD_00020) indicating an ability to cope with toxic compounds. Two genes encoding heavy metal translocating P-type ATPases (PFREUD_04920, PFREUD_22190) further suggest adaptation to toxic environments. The genome suggests a significant ability to sense changes in the environment. Eleven two-component regulatory system histidine kinases were detected (PFREUD_00320, 00810, 01640, 03260, 06720, 10230, 15210, 17760, 17900, 18790, 21970). Finally, stress-induced genes ,  include polyribonucleotide nucleotidyltransferase (pnpA, PFREUD_14570) and the inosine-5-monophosphate dehydrogenase (guaB, PFREUD_06480), suggesting the ability to synthesize the alarmone ppGpp in response to stress.
The genome reveals adaptation to the nutritional environment of the gut. P. freudenreichii maintains an active metabolism in animal and human guts , , indicating that it can use substrates present in the colon. Accordingly, the complete pathway corresponding to gluconic acid degradation, including gluconate kinase (PFREUD_01040) and 6-phosphogluconate dehydrogenase (PFREUD_04620) was identified, in agreement with gluconate utilization. The complete iol operon, mostly detected in inhabitants of soil but also in L. casei BL23 , was discovered in P. freudenreichii, consistent with utilization of myo-inositol by this bacterium. Finally, the preferred carbon source for propionibacteria, lactic acid, is one of the end products of colic fermentation by indigenous bacteria including lactic acid bacteria and bifidobacteria.
Interaction with the host gut is strongly suggested by the presence of genes encoding key surface proteins. Analysis of the genome using SurfG+  suggests the existence of 161 surface exposed proteins, including seven distinct S-layer proteins (PFREUD_03310, PFREUD_16070, PFREUD_18270, PFREUD_18290, PFREUD_23030, PFREUD_23570, PFREUD_00110), one of which, SlpA (PFREUD_18290) was identified here by surface proteomics. Slp proteins are involved in lactobacilli adhesion  and immunomodulation . Two parts (PFREUD_23540 and PFREUD_23560) of a disrupted gene which are similar to an internalin A-like gene, involved in adhesion by other probiotic organisms, exist in the P. freudenreichii genome. The protein was identified by proteomics. Moreover, PFREUD_05930 exhibited 53% sequence similarity to the Bifidobacterium bifidum surface lipoprotein BopA, which is involved in adhesion to colonocytes and immunomodulation . Finally, the gtf gene (PFREUD_19370), responsible for the biosynthesis of a P. freudenreichii surface polysaccharide was discovered. A (1,3)- β-D-glucan capsule has been reported to affect immunomodulation in Pediococcus parvulus . The involvement of P.freudenreichii surface proteins in adhesion  and immunomodulatory properties  should therefore be investigated.
Some genes support production of beneficial metabolites. The methylmalonyl-CoA carboxytransferase operon is induced by acid and bile salt stress and is also induced in vivo during transit through the digestive tract , . This result strongly suggests that P. freudenreichii is able to release in vivo short chain fatty acids known for their beneficial effects on colon epithelial cells –. The bifidogenic effect of dairy propionibacteria means that they are also of major interest for their use as probiotics in the field of microbiota modulation. The compound 1,4-dihydroxy-2-naphtoic acid (DHNA) is a precursor of menaquinone (vitamin K2), and has been identified as a bifidogenic compound . The enzymes involved in menaquinone biosynthesis have been identified in the CIRM-BIA1T genome. DHNA is synthesized by the naphtoate synthase (or dihydroxynaphtoic acid synthethase) in P. freudenreichii encoded by menB (PFREUD_07540).
Growth in Swiss-type cheese
Swiss cheese is the biotope where propionibacteria reach the highest population density, i.e., over 109 colony-forming units (cfu)/g. However, P. freudenreichii shows poor growth in milk, even for the subspecies shermanii which is able to ferment lactose. P. freudenreichii is able to grow in Swiss cheese, mainly due to its ability to ferment lactic acid under anaerobic conditions, the abundance of peptides due to the activity of the lactic acid starter bacteria (P. freudenreichii does not possess any protease capable of hydrolyzing milk caseins ), the favorable temperature of ripening (around 22–24°C for several weeks), and the relatively low NaCl concentration in the curd. P. freudenreichii is also able to cope with the stressful conditions of the “cooking” step, when the curd is heated to ~50–54°C for 30 min, although this ability is strain dependent. Thermotolerant strains differ from thermosensitive strains by constitutive over-expression of stress-related molecular chaperones and ATP-dependent proteases . Furthermore, the existence of the dihydroxyacetone kinase locus (dhaKL, PFREUD_07980 and PFREUD_07990) induced by stress and starvation in P. freudenreichii (Table S1) is also consistent with the acquisition of thermotolerance.
P. freudenreichii ferments lactate produced by lactic starter bacteria to propionate, acetate and CO2 (see “Reconstruction of specific metabolic pathways”). L-lactate enters the cells due to the expression of a L-lactate permease (PFREUD_18660). No gene encoding a D-lactate permease was found in the genome. The two isomers of lactate are converted into pyruvate by specific lactate dehydrogenases, two NAD-dependent L-lactate dehydrogenases encoded by two paralogs (PFREUD_11570 and PFREUD_12840), and one FAD-dependent D-lactate dehydrogenase (PFREUD_16710).
P. freudenreichii also plays a key role in the formation of other cheese flavor compounds. It releases free fatty acids through milk fat lipolysis and short branched-chain fatty acids through amino acid catabolism . Lipolysis is thought to result mainly from the activity of a secreted lipolytic esterase active on milk fat (PFREUD_04340) . Another putative esterase (PFREUD_04240) which is predicted to be surface-exposed may also be involved in lipolysis. Ten intracellular esterases, five with activity confirmed by expression in E. coli, and five putative esterases were also found in the P. freudenreichii genome . Some of these esterases could be involved in the synthesis of the volatile esters associated with the fruity flavor of cheese. The only esterase gene previously identified in P. freudenreichii strain JS, estA , was absent from the genome of the CIRM-BIA1T strain. The sequences flanking estA were close to the lactose locus (Fig. 2), with a transposase (PFREUD_24470) and an integrase (PFREUD_24460) inserted in place of the estA gene.
P. freudenreichii produces two short branched-chain fatty acids, 2-methylbutanoic acid and 3-methylbutanoic acid, imparting the “cheesy/sweaty” notes in many cheeses. These fatty acids are produced by the catabolism of isoleucine and leucine, respectively. Their synthesis is closely related to that of membrane fatty acids, which consist primarily of methyl-branched chain fatty acids in P. freudenreichii . Two permease proteins (high-affinity branched-chain amino acid transport system permease proteins BraE and BraD, encoded by PFREUD_10860 and PFREUD_10870, respectively) enable leucine and isoleucine to be transported into the cell. The first steps in the synthesis of BCFA and membrane fatty acids are common. The pathway involves the activity of a branched-chain aminotransferase, encoded by PFREUD_13350, and a branched-chain ketoacid dehydrogenase complex, composed of three subunits, E1α1, E1β and E2 (encoded by PFREUD_02190, PFREUD_02200, and PFREUD_02210, respectively).
In lactic acid bacteria, adaptation to the rich dairy niche is associated with gene decay, leading to metabolic simplification and auxotrophy. In contrast, P. freudenreichii possesses the complete enzymatic arsenal for the de novo biosynthesis of aminoacids and vitamins (with the exception of two). This result shows that P. freudenreichii cannot be considered a milk-adapted species.
Annotation of the P. freudenreichii genome reveals the hardiness of the bacterium, its ability to cope with different stresses (oxidative, bile salt, temperature), to withstand phage attack, to accumulate glycogen and polyphosphate under favorable conditions, to mobilize these compounds during starvation conditions and, lastly, to synthesize most vitamins and amino acids. Unlike lactic acid bacteria such as L. bulgaricus, Propionibacteria do not seem to be over-adapted to cheese conditions. The presence of beta galactosidase probably resulting from a horizontal transfer event seems to be the unique adaptive trait revealed by our study. The genetic basis of the P. freudenreichii capacity to produce aromatic compounds was in agreement with those described at the biochemical level: the Wood-Werkman cycle producing propionic acid, pathways for production of acetic acid and CO2, production of branched-chain fatty acids from leucine and isoleucine, and discovery of an extracellular lipolytic esterase. Regarding probiotic activity, the complete pathway for synthesis of a bifidogenic compound was reconstructed and a large number of surface proteins involved in adhesion and immunomodulatory activity, as in the Lactobacillus and Bifidobacterium genera, were identified. Functional validations should now be investigated using transcriptomic and inactivation-complementation approaches. These investigations should take into account the large panel of P. freudenreichii phenotypes for aromatic and probiotic properties among the thousands of strains stored and described in microbiological resource centers for this species. The versatility and the high adaptability of the species could also include non-alimentary perspectives.
Materials and Methods
The strain used for sequencing was P. freudenreichii subsp. shermanii CIRM-BIA1T (equivalent names: ATCC9614, American Type Culture Collection, Rockville, MD; CIRM1, CIRM-BIA, INRA, Rennes; TL34, INRA).
The complete sequence of P. freudenreichii subsp. shermanii CIRM-BIA1T (Genbank accession number FN806773) was determined after genomic DNA fragmentation by mechanical shearing or BamHI partial digest for the construction of plasmid and large insert libraries, respectively. The 3 kb (A), 10 kb (B) and 25 kb (C) fragments were cloned onto pCNS (pSU18 derived, (A) and (B)) and pBBc (pBeloBac11 derived (C)). Vector DNAs were purified and end-sequenced (9216 (A), 29184 (B) and 5376 (C)) using dye-terminator chemistry on ABI3730 sequencers. A pre-assembly was made without repeat sequences as described by Vallenet et al.  using the Phred/Phrap/Consed software package (www.phrap.org). The finished genome sequence was achieved by primer walking using a GC sequence finishing kit (GEhealthcare) and transposition bombs. A complement of 4004 sequences (3648 transpositions and 356 primer walking) was needed for gap closure and quality assessment (11.8-fold coverage with less than 1.4/10,000 bp error in sequencing).
Automatic and manual annotations were conducted with the AGMIAL platform .
For the vitamin B12 synthesis pathway, the gene nomenclature from  was used, with the exception that CobA adoT (encoding a Cob(I)alamin adenosyltransferase) was replaced by CobA2. Genes involved in anti-oxidative properties were identified using OxygeneDB . Subcellular localization was predicted using SurfG+ . The replication origin was identified using Ori-finder . Atlas of gene (Fig. 1) was realized using Circos software .
P. acnes comparison
The Promer program from the Mummer package  was used to highlight synteny with P. acnes. The homology of P. freudenreichii predicted proteins with proteins putatively involved in the degradation of host molecules or in the mediation of inflammation was determined by bidirectional best hits with an e-value less than 10−3 and covering over 80% of the shortest sequence.
Vitamin requirements were evaluated by growing P. freudenreichii in a chemically defined medium, as previously described , pH 6.8, containing lactic acid, eight amino acids, minerals (K, P, Mg, Mn, Fe, Na, Co and Zn), and either i) control medium: nine vitamins (pyridoxal phosphate (B6), nicotinic acid (PP), pantothenate (B5), thiamine (B1), riboflavin (B2), p-aminobenzoic acid, folic acid (B9), biotine (H), and vitamin B12), or ii) test media (all but one of these nine vitamins), or iii) all but p-aminobenzoic acid (an intermediate in the synthesis of vit B9) and vit B9. The media were sterilized by filtration, inoculated with 1.0% of a culture grown in the same medium, and incubated at 30°C under semi-anaerobic (static cultures in air atmosphere) and anaerobic conditions for at least 12 days. Four successive transfers were performed under the same conditions. The growth was followed both by optical density at 650 nm and plate counting on Yeast Extract Lactate agar medium .
Carbohydrate fermentation tests
Fermentation of various carbohydrates was tested using the Biolog plate test (Biolog Inc, Hayward, CA, USA) and api50CH (Biomérieux, Craponne, France), according to manufacturer's instructions.
List of identified proteins from the Propionibacterium freudenreichii genome by 2D-LC MSMS. Three different experimental setups were used and are given in the last column. Setup “a” is nanoLC-ESI/MS/MS, “b” is MALDI/MS/MS and “c” is 2DLC-ESI/MS/MS (first dimension being cation exchange chromatography and second dimension being reverse phase liquid chromatography).
(0.09 MB PDF)
Insertion sequences occurence.
(0.00 MB PDF)
Bidirectional best hits results between P. freudenreichii proteins and P. acnes proteins. No P. acnes protein putatively involved in the degradation of host molecules or in the mediation of inflammation was found in P. freudenreichii.
(0.15 MB PDF)
Propionibacterium freudenreichii carbon substrate degradation.
(0.03 MB PDF)
Results of test of vitamin requirements by P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1.
(0.04 MB PDF)
List of pyrophosphate and polyphosphate enzymes.
(0.03 MB PDF)
Conceived and designed the experiments: HF PW. Performed the experiments: HF SMD VL SP MBM JD JJ PS AC VB BV PW. Analyzed the data: HF SMD GJ VL AT JJ PS VB. Wrote the paper: HF SMD GJ AT JD FJC PS VB JFG CG SL.
- 1. Cousin FJ, Mater DD, Foligné B, Jan G (2010) Dairy propionibacteria as human probiotics: A review of recent evidence (in press). Dairy Sci Technol. doi:10.1051/dst/2010032.
- 2. von Freudenreich E, Orla-Jensen O (1906) Uber die in Emmentalerkäse stattfindene Propionsäure-gärung. Zentralbl Bakteriol 17: 529–546.
- 3. Cummins CS, Johnson JL (1992) The genus Propionibacterium. In: Balows E, Truper HG, Dworkin M, Harder W, Schleifer KH, editors. The prokaryotes. Springer Verlag.
- 4. Thierry A, Maillard MB (2002) Production of cheese flavour compounds derived from amino acid catabolism by Propionibacterium freudenreichii. Lait 82: 17–32.
- 5. Thierry A, Maillard MB, Richoux R, Kerjean JR, Lortal S (2005) Propionibacterium freudenreichii strains quantitatively affect production of volatile compounds in Swiss cheese. Lait 85: 57–74.
- 6. Thierry A, Maillard MB, Bonnarme P, Roussel E (2005) The addition of Propionibacterium freudenreichii to Raclette cheese induces biochemical changes and enhances flavour development. J Agric Food Chem 53: 4157–4165.
- 7. Kiatpapan P, Kanamnuay N, Jongserijit B, Piao YZ, Yamashita M, et al. (2003) Production of 5-aminolevulinic acid and vitamin B-12 using metabolic engineering of Propionibacterium freudenreichii. Fermentation Biotech 862: 221–232.
- 8. Piao Y, Yamashita M, Kawaraichi N, Asegawa R, Ono H, et al. (2004) Production of vitamin B-12 in genetically engineered Propionibacterium freudenreichii. J Biosci Bioeng 98: 167–173.
- 9. Murooka Y, Piao Y, Kiatpapan P, Yamashita M (2005) Production of tetrapyrrole compounds and vitamin B-12 using genetically engineering of Propionibacterium freudenreichii. An overview. Lait 85: 9–22.
- 10. Roessner CA, Huang K-X, Warren MJ, Raux E, Scott AI (2002) Isolation and characterization of 14 additional genes specifying the anaerobic biosynthesis of cobalamin (vitamin B12) in Propionibacterium freudenreichii (P. shermanii). Microbiol 148: 1845–1853.
- 11. Isawa K, Hojo K, Yoda N, Kamiyama T, Makino S, et al. (2002) Isolation and identification of a new bifidogenic growth stimulator produced by Propionibacterium freudenreichii ET-3. Biosci Biotech Biochem 66: 679–681.
- 12. Kaneko T, Mori H, Iwata M, Meguro S (1994) Growth stimulator for bifidobacteria produced by Propionibacterium freudenreichii and several intestinal bacteria. J Dairy Sci 77: 393–404.
- 13. Bouglé D, Roland N, Lebeurrier F, Arhan P (1999) Effect of propionibacteria supplementation on fecal bifidobacteria and segmental colonic transit time in healthy human subjects. Scand J Gastroenterol 34: 144–148.
- 14. Hojo K, Yoda N, Tsuchita H, Ohtsu T, Seki K, et al. (2002) Effect of ingested culture of Propionibacterium freudenreichii ET-3 on fecal microflora and stool frequency in healthy females. Biosci Microfl 21: 115–120.
- 15. Jan G, Leverrier P, Pichereau V, Boyaval P (2001) Changes in protein synthesis and morphology during acid adaptation of Propionibacterium freudenreichii. Appl Environ Microbiol 67: 2029–2036.
- 16. Leverrier P, Dimova D, Pichereau V, Auffray Y, Boyaval P, et al. (2003) Susceptibility and adaptive response to bile salts in Propionibacterium freudenreichii: physiological and proteomic analysis. Appl Environ Microbiol 69: 3809–3818.
- 17. Hervé C, Fondrevez M, Chéron A, Barloy-Hubler F, Jan G (2007) Transcarboxylase mRNA: a marker which evidences P. freudenreichii survival and metabolic activity during its transit in the human gut. Int J Food Microbiol 113: 303–314.
- 18. Jan G, Leverrier P, Proudy I, Roland N (2002) Survival and beneficial effects of propionibacteria in the human gut: in vivo and in vitro investigations. Lait 82: 131–144.
- 19. Lan A, Bruneau A, Philippe C, Rochet V, Rouault A, et al. (2007) Survival and metabolic activity of selected strains of Propionibacterium freudenreichii in the gastrointestinal tract of human microbioti-associated rats. Br J Nutr 97: 714–724.
- 20. Kekkonen RA, Lummela N, Karjalainen H, Latvala S, Tynkkynen S, et al. (2008) Probiotic intervention has strain-specific anti-inflammatory effects in healthy adults. World J Gastroenterol 14: 2029–2036.
- 21. Bruggemann H, Henne A, Hoster F, Liesegang H, Wiezer A, et al. (2004) The complete genome sequence of Propionibacterium acnes, a commensal of human skin. Science 305: 671–673.
- 22. Lee ZMP, Bussema C, Schmidt TM (2009) rrnDB: documenting the number of rRNA and tRNA genes in bacteria and archaea. Nucleic Acids Res 37: D489–D493.
- 23. Van Luijk N, Stierli MP, Miescher SS, Hervé C, Dasen G, et al. (2002) Genetics and molecular biology of propionibacteria. Lait 82: 45–57.
- 24. Arber W (2000) Genetic variation: molecular mechanisms and impact on microbial evolution. FEMS Microbiol Rev 24: 1–7.
- 25. Kichenaradja P, Siguier P, Perochon J, Chandler M (2010) ISbrowser: an extension of ISfinder for visualizing insertion sequences in prokaryotic genomes. Nucleic Acids Res 38: D62–D68.
- 26. Deutsch S-M, Falentin H, Dols-Lafargue M, LaPointe G, Roy D (2008) Capsular exopolysaccharide biosynthesis gene of Propionibacterium freudenreichii subsp. shermanii. Int J Food Microbiol 125: 252–258.
- 27. Deutsch S-M, Le Bivic P, Hervé C, Madec M-N, LaPointe G, et al. (2010) Capsular phenotype in Propionibacterium freudenreichii correlates with the expression level of gtf, a unique polysaccharide synthase encoding gene. Appl Environ Microbiol 76: 2740–2746.
- 28. Lee MH, Pascopella L, Jacobs WR, Hatfull GF (1991) Site-specific integration of mycobacteriophage L5: integration-proficient vectors for Mycobacterium smegmatis, Mycobacterium tuberculosis, and bacille Calmette-Guerin. P Acad Nat Sci USA 88: 3111–3115.
- 29. Haeseleer F, Pollet JF, Bollen A, Jacobs P (1992) Molecular cloning and sequencing of the attachment site and integrase gene of the temperate mycobacteriophage Frat1. Nucleic Acids Res 20: 1420.
- 30. Hervé C, Coste A, Rouault A, Fraslin JM, Gautier M (2001) First evidence of lysogeny in Propionibacterium freudenreichii subsp. shermanii. Appl Environ Microbiol 67: 231–238.
- 31. Barrangou R, Fremaux C, Deveau H, Richards M, Boyaval P, et al. (2007) CRISPR provides acquired resistance against viruses in prokaryotes. Science 315: 1709–1712.
- 32. Grissa I, Vergnaud G, Pourcel C (2007) CRISPRFinder: a web tool to identify clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats. Nucleic Acids Res 35: W52–W57.
- 33. Chopin MC, Rouault A, Ehrlich SD, Gautier M (2002) Filamentous phage active on the gram-positive bacterium Propionibacterium freudenreichii. J Bacteriol 184: 2030–2033.
- 34. Miskin JE, Farrell AM, Cunliffe WJ, Holland KT (1997) Propionibacterium acnes, a resident of lipid-rich human skin, produces a 33 kDa extracellular lipase encoded by gehA. Microbiol -UK 143: 1745–1755.
- 35. Dherbécourt J, Falentin H, Jardin J, Maillard MB, Baglinière F, et al. (2010) Identification of a secreted lipolytic esterase in Propionibacterium freudenreichii, a ripening process bacterium involved in Emmental cheese lipolysis. Appl Environ Microbiol 76: 1181–1188.
- 36. Dherbécourt J, Falentin H, Canaan S, Thierry A (2008) A genomic search approach to identify esterases in Propionibacterium freudenreichii involved in the formation of flavour in Emmental cheese. Microb Cell Fact 7:
- 37. Cummins CS, Johnson JL (1986) Genus I. Propionibacterium Orla-Jensen 1909. In: Sneath PHA, Mair NS, Sharpe ME, Holt JG, editors. Bergey's Manual of Systematic Bacteriology. Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins. pp. 1346–1353.
- 38. Toraya T, Kuno S, Fukui S (1980) Distribution of Coenzyme B12-Dependent Diol Dehydratase and Glycerol Dehydratase in Selected Genera of Enterobacteriaceae and Propionibacteriaceae. J Bacteriol 141: 1439–1442.
- 39. Bobik TA, Havemann GD, Busch RJ, Williams DS, Aldrich HC (1999) The propanediol utilization (pdu) operon of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium LT2 includes genes necessary for formation of polyhedral organelles involved in coenzyme B(12)-dependent 1, 2-propanediol degradation. J Bacteriol 181: 5967–5975.
- 40. Sampson EM, Bobik TA (2008) Microcompartments for B12-dependent 1,2-propanediol degradation provide protection from DNA and cellular damage by a reactive metabolic intermediate. J Bacteriol 190: 2966–2971.
- 41. Schink B, Kremer DR, Hansen TA (1987) Pathway of propionate formation from ethanol in Pelobacter Propionicus. Arch Microbiol 147: 321–327.
- 42. Macy JM, Ljungdahl LG, Gottschalk G (1978) Pathway of succinate and propionate formation in Bacteroides fragilis. J Bacteriol 134: 84–91.
- 43. Ng SKC, Hamilton IR (1973) Carbon dioxide fixation by Veillonella parvula M4 and its relation to propionic acid formation. Can J Microbiol 19: 715–723.
- 44. Johns AT (1951) The mechanism of propionic acid formation by Veillonella gazogenes. J Gen Microbiol 5: 326–336.
- 45. Johns AT (1952) The mechanism of propionic acid formation by Clostridium-Propionicum. J Gen Microbiol 6: 123–127.
- 46. Wood HG (1981) Metabolic cycles in the fermentation by propionic acid bacteria. In: Estabrook RW, Srera P, editors. Current topics in cellular regulation-1981. New York: Academic Press. pp. 255–287.
- 47. Beck S, Schink B (1995) Acetate oxidation through a modified citric acid cycle in Propionibacterium freudenreichii. Arch Microbiol 163: 182–187.
- 48. Deborde C (1998) Etude du métabolisme carboné primaire de bactéries propioniques laitières par Résonance Magnétique Nucléaire in vivo du 13C : des voies métaboliques aux tests de performance des souches industrielles [dissertation]. ENSAR/Agrocampus Ouest, Rennes.
- 49. Hall PR, Zheng R, Antony L, Pusztai-Carey M, Carey PR, et al. (2004) Transcarboxylase 5S structures: assembly and catalytic mechanism of a multienzyme complex subunit. EMBO J 23: 3621–3631.
- 50. Crow VL (1986) Metabolism of aspartate by Propionibacterium freudenreichii subsp. shermanii: effect on lactate fermentation. Appl Environ Microbiol 52: 359–365.
- 51. Fröhlich-Wyder MT, Bachmann HP (2004) Cheeses with propionic acid fermentation. In: Fox PF, McSweeney PLH, Cogan TM, Guinee TP, editors. Cheese. Chemistry, Physics and Microbiology. London: Elsevier. pp. 141–156.
- 52. Benz M, Schink B, Brune A (1998) Humic acid reduction by Propionibacterium freudenreichii and other fermenting bacteria. Appl Environ Microbiol 64: 4507–4512.
- 53. Seufferheld MJ, Alvarez HM, Farias ME (2008) Role of polyphosphates in microbial adaptation to extreme environments. Appl Environ Microbiol 74: 5867–5874.
- 54. Clark JE, Beegen H, Wood HG (1987) Isolation of intact chains of polyphosphate from Propionibacterium shermanii grown on glucose or lactate. J Bacteriol 168: 1212–1219.
- 55. Clark JE, Beegen H, Wood HG (1987) Isolation of intact chains of polyphosphate from Propionibacterium shermanii grown on glucose or lactate. J Bacteriol 168: 1212–1219.
- 56. McLennan AG (2006) The Nudix hydrolase superfamily. Cell Mol Life Sci 63: 123–143.
- 57. Meurice G, Deborde C, Jacob D, Falentin H, Boyaval P, et al. (2004) In silico exploration of the fructose-6-phosphate phosphorylation step in glycolysis: genomic evidence of the coexistence of an atypical ATP-dependent along with a PPi-dependent phosphofructokinase in Propionibacterium freudenreichii subsp. shermanii. In Silico Biol 4: 0043.
- 58. Meurice G (2004) Reconstruction in silico de voies métaboliques : application aux voies glycolytiques de Propionibacterium freudenreichi subsp. shermanii [dissertation]. Rennes, France: Ecole Nationale Supérieure Agronomique de Rennes.
- 59. Deborde C, Corre C, Rolin DB, Nadal L, De Certaines JD, et al. (1996) Trehalose biosynthesis in dairy Propionibacterium. J Magn Reson Analysis 2: 297–304.
- 60. Cardoso FS, Gaspar P, Hugenholtz J, Ramos A, Santos H (2004) Enhancement of trehalose production in dairy propionibacteria through manipulation of environmental conditions. Int J Food Microbiol 91: 195–204.
- 61. Cardoso FS, Castro RF, Borges N, Santos H (2007) Biochemical and genetic characterization of the pathways for trehalose metabolism in Propionibacterium freudenreichii, and their role in stress response. Microbiol 153: 270–280.
- 62. Boyaval P, Deborde C, Corre C, Blanco C, Begué E (1999) Stress and osmoprotection in propionibacteria. Lait 79: 59–69.
- 63. Leverrier P, Fremont Y, Rouault A, Boyaval P, Jan G (2005) In vitro tolerance to digestive stresses of propionibacteria: influence of food matrices. Food Microbiology 22: 11–18.
- 64. Leverrier P (2003) Susceptibilité et adaptation de Propionibacterium freudenreichii aux stress digestifs [dissertation].
- 65. Lemée R, Rouault A, Guezenec S, Lortal S (1994) Autolysis of 57 strains of dairy Propionibacteria. Lait 74: 241–251.
- 66. Schroeckh V, Martin K (2006) Resuscitation-promoting factors: distribution among actinobacteria, synthesis during life-cycle and biological activity. Antonie van Leeuwenhoek International Journal of General and Molecular Microbiology 89: 359–365.
- 67. Kaprelyants AS, Gottschal JC, Kell DB (1993) Dormancy in non-sporulating bacteria. FEMS Microbiol Rev 10: 271–285.
- 68. Leverrier P, Vissers JPC, Rouault A, Boyaval P, Jan G (2004) Mass spectrometry proteomic analysis of stress adaptation reveals both common and distinct response pathways in Propionibacterium freudenreichii. Arch Microbiol 181: 215–230.
- 69. Rigoulay C, Poquet I, Madsen SM, Gruss A (2004) Expression of the Staphylococcus aureus surface proteins HtrA(1) and HtrA(2) in Lactococcus lactis. FEMS Microbiol Lett 237: 279–288.
- 70. Sanchez B, Reyes-Gavilan CGD, Margolles A (2006) The F1F0-ATPase of Bifidobacterium animalis is involved in bile tolerance. Environmental Microbiology 8: 1825–1833.
- 71. Anastasiou R, Leverrier P, Krestas I, Rouault A, Kalantzopoulos G, et al. (2006) Changes in protein synthesis during thermal adaptation of Propionibacterium freudenreichii subsp. shermanii. Int J Food Microbiol 108: 301–314.
- 72. Singh VK, Hattangady DS, Giotis ES, Singh AK, Chamberlain NR, et al. (2008) Insertional inactivation of branched-chain alpha-keto acid dehydrogenase in Staphylococcus aureus leads to decreased branched-chain membrane fatty acid content and increased susceptibility to certain stresses. Appl Environ Microbiol 74: 5882–5890.
- 73. Begley M, Gahan CGM, Hill C (2005) The interaction between bacteria and bile. FEMS Microbiol Rev 29: 625–651.
- 74. Yebra MJ, Zuniga M, Beaufils S, Perez-Martinez G, Deutscher J, et al. (2007) Identification of a gene cluster enabling Lactobacillus casei BL23 to utilize myo-inositol. Appl Environ Microbiol 73: 3850–3858.
- 75. Barinov A, Loux V, Hammani A, Nicolas P, Langella P, et al. (2009) Prediction of surface exposed proteins in Streptococcus pyogenes, with a potential application to other Gram-positive bacteria. Proteomics 9: 61–73.
- 76. Lebeer S, Vanderleyden J, De Keersmaecker SCJ (2008) Genes and molecules of Lactobacilli supporting probiotic action. Microbiol Mol Biol R 72: 728–764.
- 77. Konstantinov SR, Smidt H, de Vos WM, Bruijns SCM, Singh SK, et al. (2008) S layer protein A of Lactobacillus acidophilus NCFM regulates immature dendritic cell and T cell functions. P Acad Nat Sci USA 105: 19474–19479.
- 78. Guglielmetti S, Tamagnini I, Mora D, Minuzzo M, Scarafoni A, et al. (2008) Implication of an outer surface lipoprotein in adhesion of Bifidobacterium bifidum to Caco-2 cells. Appl Environ Microbiol 74: 4695–4702.
- 79. de Palencia PF, Werning ML, Sierra-Filardi E, Duenas MT, Irastorza A, et al. (2009) Probiotic properties of the 2-substituted (1,3)-beta-D-glucan-producing bacterium Pediococcus parvulus 2.6. Appl Environ Microbiol 75: 4887–4891.
- 80. Ouwehand AC, Suomalainen T, Tolkko S, Salminen S (2002) In vitro adhesion of propionic acid bacteria to human intestinal mucus. Lait 82: 123–130.
- 81. Jan G, Belzacq AS, Haouzi D, Rouault A, Metivier D, et al. (2002) Propionibacteria induce apoptosis of colorectal carcinoma cells via short-chain fatty acids acting on mitochondria. Cell Death Differ 9: 179–188.
- 82. Lan A, Lagadic-Gossmann D, Lemaire C, Brenner C, Jan G (2007) Acidic extracellular pH shifts colorectal cancer cell death from apoptosis to necrosis upon exposure to propionate and acetate major end-products of the human probiotic propionibacteria. Apoptosis 12: 573–591.
- 83. Lan A, Bruneau A, Bensaada M, Philippe C, Bellaud P, et al. (2008) Increased induction of apoptosis by Propionibacterium freudenreichii TL133 in colonic mucosal crypts of human microbiota-associated rats treated with 1,2-dimethylhydrazine. Br J Nutr 100: 1251–1259.
- 84. Dupuis C, Corre C, Boyaval P (1995) Proteinase activity of dairy Propionibacterium. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol 42: 750–755.
- 85. Suoniemi A, Tynkkynen S (2002) Cloning and characterization of an esterase from Propionibacterium freudenreichi ssp. shermanii. Lait 82: 81–89.
- 86. Dherbécourt J, Maillard MB, Catheline D, Thierry A (2008) Production of branched-chain aroma compounds by Propionibacterium freudenreichii: links with the biosynthesis of membrane fatty acids. J Appl Microbiol 105: 977–985.
- 87. Vallenet D, Nordmann P, Barbe V, Poirel L, Mangenot S, et al. (2008) Comparative Analysis of Acinetobacters: Three Genomes for Three Lifestyles. Plos One 3:
- 88. Bryson K, Loux V, Bossy R, Nicolas P, Chaillou S, et al. (2006) AGMIAL: implementing an annotation strategy for prokaryote genomes as a distributed system. Nucleic Acids Res 34: 3533–3545.
- 89. Thybert D, Avner S, Lucchetti-Miganeh C, Cheron A, Barloy-Hubler F (2008) OxyGene: an innovative platform for investigating oxidative-response genes in whole prokaryotic genomes. Bmc Genomics 9:
- 90. Gao F, Zhang CT (2008) Ori-Finder: A web-based system for finding oriCs in unannotated bacterial genomes. Bmc Bioinformatics 9:
- 91. Krzywinski M, Schein J, Birol I, Connors J, Gascoyne R, et al. (2009) Circos: An information aesthetic for comparative genomics. Genome Research 19: 1639–1645.
- 92. Kurtz S, Phillippy A, Delcher AL, Smoot M, Shumway M, et al. (2004) Versatile and open software for comparing large genomes. Genome Biology 5: