20 May 2008: Kim SC, McGowen MR, Lubinsky P, Barber JC, Mort ME, et al. (2008) Correction: Timing and Tempo of Early and Successive Adaptive Radiations in Macaronesia. PLoS ONE 3(5): 10.1371/annotation/a8922076-0da4-41ff-94ef-5e44f60d1895. doi: 10.1371/annotation/a8922076-0da4-41ff-94ef-5e44f60d1895 View correction
The flora of Macaronesia, which encompasses five Atlantic archipelagos (Azores, Canaries, Madeira, Cape Verde, and Salvage), is exceptionally rich and diverse.
Spectacular radiation of numerous endemic plant groups has made the Macaronesian islands an outstanding area for studies of evolution and speciation. Despite intensive investigation in the last 15 years, absolute age and rate of diversification are poorly known for the flora of Macaronesia. Here we report molecular divergence estimates and rates of diversification for five representative, putative rapid radiations of monophyletic endemic plant lineages across the core eudicot clade of flowering plants. Three discrete windows of colonization during the Miocene and early Pliocene are suggested for these lineages, all of which are inferred to have had a single colonization event followed by rapid radiation. Subsequent inter-archipelago dispersal events into Madeira and the Cape Verdes took place very recently during the late Pliocene and Pleistocene after initial diversification on the Canary Islands. The tempo of adaptive radiations differs among the groups, but is relatively rapid compared to continental and other island radiations. Our results demonstrate that opportunity for island colonization and successful radiation may have been constrained to discrete time periods of profound climatic and geological changes in northern African and the Mediterranean.
Citation: Kim S-C, McGowen MR, Lubinsky P, Barber JC, Mort ME, et al. (2008) Timing and Tempo of Early and Successive Adaptive Radiations in Macaronesia. PLoS ONE 3(5): e2139. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0002139
Editor: Jason E. Stajich, University of California, Berkeley, United States of America
Received: January 14, 2008; Accepted: March 27, 2008; Published: May 14, 2008
Copyright: © 2008 Kim et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: The National Science Foundation generously supported earlier molecular phylogenetic studies.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
The phytogeographical region Macaronesia  consists of five Atlantic volcanic archipelagos, including the Azores, Madeira, the Salvage Islands, the Canary Islands, and the Cape Verde Islands, as well as a “Macaronesian Enclave” on the African mainland, comprising southern Morocco and the former Spanish West Africa (Fig. 1). The five archipelagos are situated between 15° to 40° N latitude, with distances from the European or African continents varying from 95 to 1600 km. Geological ages of individual islands vary from 0.8 million years (My) for El Hierro to 21 My for Fuerteventura , both of which belong to the Canarian archipelago. The influence of moisture-laden northeasterly trade winds combined with altitudes reaching more than 3,700 meters has produced a remarkable diversity of ecological habitats.
The age of current above-sea landmass for each island is from .
The Macaronesian flora displays a number of characteristics typical of oceanic islands, including a high degree of endemism (20% of overall flowering plants ; 40% in the Canary Islands ) and a predominance of woody growth habit among endemics (e.g., 72% of Canary Island endemics are woody , many of which were derived from continental herbaceous ancestors). However, the region in general, and especially the Canary Islands, differs markedly from Pacific archipelagos such as Hawaii, Galapagos, and Juan Fernandez Islands, in that they are very close to potential continental source areas (e.g., the eastern-most Canary Island, Fuerteventura, is presently less than 100 km from the west coast of Morocco) and exhibit a comparatively old and broad range of geological ages from <1 to 21 My , . These two features may contribute to several unusual patterns of colonization and diversification and to relatively high levels of genetic variation compared to other oceanic archipelagos .
The preponderance of endemic plant species has made the Macaronesian islands an outstanding area for studies of evolution and speciation, and plants from these islands have been the focus of intensive investigation in the last 15 years –. Numerous molecular phylogenetic analyses of Macaronesian plant groups have provided valuable insights into the relationships among the region's endemics –. These studies have revealed several emerging general patterns of colonization and dispersal, including: (1) single colonization of a common ancestor followed by rapid radiation –, ; (2) multiple independent colonizations , , , ; (3) back-colonization to the continent from Macaronesia , , ; and (4) a predominantly Macaronesian-Western Mediterranean source area for the endemic lineages (see examples in ). Despite numerous molecular phylogenetic studies, there has been no comprehensive investigation of the timing and/or tempo of Macaronesian flowering plant radiations . Previous studies often used average substitution rates of isozyme data , , cpDNA RFLP data , or nuclear and chloroplast DNA data ,  of other organisms to estimate the origin and timing of radiation of the endemic flora, or more often made no attempt to do so –.
Here we provide a first report the timing of origin and radiation, long distance dispersal events, and rate of diversification of five of the largest and most diverse Macaronesian plant endemic. These groups span several lineages of the core eudicots (Fig. S1, Supporting Information): the woody Sonchus alliance (6 genera, ca. 31 species; Asterids, Euasterid II, Asterales, , Fig. S2), Echium (27 species; Asterids, Euasterid I, unplaced, , Fig. S3), Sideritis (subgenus Marrubiastrum, 23 species; Asterids, Euasterid I, Lamiales, , Fig. S4), Crambe (section Dendrocrambe, 14 species; Rosids, Eurosid II, Brassicales, , Fig. S5), the Aeonium alliance (4 genera, ca. 61 species; Core Eudicots, Saxifragales, , Fig. S6). These five plant groups are premier examples of adaptive radiation in Macaronesia, each of which underwent rapid radiation after a single colonization event from continental source area, and distributed in more than one archipelago. Lack of absolute age and diversification rate estimates in such groups precludes comparisons with other insular radiations, particularly Pacific island [23, references therein], and continental radiations , [25, references therein], which may exhibit different patterns of diversification. In this paper we estimate the age and diversification rate of five of the largest plant lineages endemic to the Macaronesian islands. Comparison of these data for the island endemics versus their congeners on the continent is beyond the scope of this paper due to a lack of available robust phylogenetic frameworks (with exceptions in Sonchus and Crambe) and a reliable data for clock calibration.
Results and Discussion
Three narrow windows of colonization were found for the five plant groups: Middle Miocene (early Serravllian), Late Miocene (late Tortonian), and Early Pliocene (early Zanclean). The Aeonium alliance, a well supported clade of three genera, showed the earliest colonization into the Canary Islands (15.2 Ma), followed by the woody Sonchus alliance (8.47 Ma), Crambe (8.15 Ma), Echium (3.73 Ma), and Sideritis (3.3 Ma) (Fig. 2 and Table 1). The most recent common ancestor (MRCA) of the Aeonium alliance colonized the Canaries when the two eastern-most, geologically older islands were formed during early to mid Tertiary. Within the Aeonium alliance, the MRCA ages of Aichryson, Monanthes, and Aeonium (including Greenovia) are estimated to be 8.67 Ma, 6.93 Ma, and 10.23 Ma, respectively. These divergence time estimates suggest that after the initial colonization, three major lineages slowly diverged and radiation of each lineage began during late Miocene. A second episode of synchronized colonization during the Late Miocene was inferred for Eurosid II and Euastrid II lineages: Crambe (Brassicaceae) and the Sonchus alliance (Asteraceae). Lastly, two of the most speciose and recently radiated lineages among the five investigated here are both members of the families in Euasterid I clade: Sideritis (Lamiaceae) and Echium (Boraginaceae); we infer that these taxa colonized the Canaries during the early Pliocene.
(A) the woody Sonchus alliance (Asterids, Euasterid II, Asterales) (species in the pictures, from top to bottom; Sonchus gandogeri*, S. acaulis*, and S. canariensis*) . (B) Echium (Asterids, Euasterid I, unplaced) (species in the pictures; Echium auberianum†, E. callithyrsum*, and E. wildpretii†). (C) the Aeonium alliance (Saxifragales) (species in the pictures; Aichryson punctatum ∏, Monanthes muralis∏, Greenovia aurea*, and Aeonium cuneatum∏). (D) Sideritis (Asterids, Euasterid I, Lamiales) (species in the pictures, top left, Sideritis gomerae¶; top right, S. macrostachys¶; bottom row, S. eriocephala¶). (E) Crambe (Rosids, Eurosid II, Brassicales) (species in the pictures; Crambe scaberrima§ and C. pritzelii§). Branch colors: gray, closest continental relatives; black, the Canary Islands; blue, Madeira; red, Cape Verde. Branch lengths are proportional to changes on the trees and outgroup taxa are not shown. (photo credits: *Seung-Chul Kim, †Jose Mesa, ¶Janet C. Barber, §Manuel Luis Gil González, and ∏Mark Mort).
The closest continental ancestor(s) of each of the five lineages investigated is inferred to be from the western Mediterranean, including the Iberian Peninsula and Morocco and the timing of colonization coincides with major geological and climatic changes in those areas. The first colonization event by the Aeonium alliance occurred during the Betic crisis (16–14 Ma), which was characterized by significant fluctuations in temperature and resulting glacioeustatic changes in global sea level . We hypothesized that the MRCA of the Aeonium alliance colonized the geologically older eastern islands first and subsequently dispersed to the later forming western islands (Gran Canaria, Tenerife, and La Gomera). Second episode of colonization is synchronous with the onset of recurrent desert conditions in the Sahara  and occurred prior to the desiccation of the Mediterranean Sea (i.e., Messinian salinity crisis, ) when seasonal contrasts in the temperature regime developed. The colonization events of these two unrelated genera were perhaps triggered by these two dramatic geological events in the Mediterranean region. At this time, all but two of the western Canary Islands were formed and it is highly likely that these two genera colonized Tenerife and Gran Canaria separately. A third episode of colonization is inferred for Echium and Sideritis, coinciding with the opening of the Gibraltar Strait and the onset of the first glaciation cycles . These three discrete waves of colonization support the “Colonization Window Hypothesis” which implies that opportunity for island colonization may have been constrained to one or more distinct periods of time . It is possible that three discrete time periods of profound climatic and geologic changes in northern Africa and the Mediterranean and of active volcanism in the Canary Islands facilitated the establishment and subsequent diversification of endemic lineages. The colonization of Limonium (Plumbaginaceae) subsection Nobiles (7.5 Ma, ) into the Canaries coincides with the second wave of colonization of Sonchus and Crambe (i.e., prior to the desiccation of the Mediterranean Sea in the Messinian). The absolute ages of the five genera pre-date those of later multiple colonizers which did not undergo adaptive radiation, such as Convolvulus , and this can be explained by the niche pre-emption hypothesis: earlier colonists that radiated created a clade or clades that occupied more niche space than later colonists that did not radiate. Thus, by filling niche space, adaptive radiation created a barrier that prevented closely related later arrivals from establishing .
Inter-archipelago dispersal events in Macaronesia, with an exception of the Aeonium alliance dispersal into Madeira, appear to be quite recent and did not result in any major radiation for any of these five genera. Our data suggest that dispersal to Madeira occurred in the Late Pliocene and Pleistocene, between 3 and 0.3 Ma, and this time-window is coincident with the onset of the first glaciation cycle. Dispersal into the Cape Verde Islands of three plant groups is even more recent, i.e., during Pleistocene. Back dispersal of Aeonium to the mainland African continent also occurred between 3.0 and 1.28 Ma without subsequent major speciation or radiation. The five lineages investigated here illustrate a variety of dispersal syndromes (Aeonium alliance and Crambe, unassisted; Sonchus alliance, hydrochory; Echium and Sideritis, epizoochory: ). It is plausible that different dispersal mechanisms facilitated inter-archipelago colonization during glaciation cycles.
The estimated mean per lineage diversification rate per million years ranges from 0.22 to 0.79 (Table 1 and Fig. 2). The earliest inferred colonizer, the Aeonium alliance, appears to have the slowest rate of diversification (0.22 for the entire alliance; Aichryson only, 0.13; Monanthes only, 0.20; Aeonium including Greenovia only, 0.30), whereas the most recent colonizing lineages (i.e., Echium and Sideritis) have the fastest diversification rates (0.62 and 0.79, respectively). The diversification rates of Aeonium alliance and Crambe (0.24) are on the low end of the range inferred for other continental and insular radiations (e.g., angiosperm families , rodent families , and recent African large-mammal genera , ). We estimated the rate of diversification for the Sonchus alliance to 0.32 (maximum of 0.66), which is lower than the rate of the silversword alliance in Hawaii (0.56), but similar to the rate of Agave sensu lato (0.32) . The rates of diversification in the later colonizers, Echium and Sideritis lineages, were about two to three times greater than those of earlier colonizers. These rates exceed that of the Hawaiian silversword alliance  and are comparable to Neogene horses (0.5–1.4) , Lake Tanganyika cichlids (0.75–1.49) , Southern African semi-desert ice plants (0.77–1.75) , and Angiosperm orders (maximum of 0.76) . These results suggest that, unlike some other radiations, the Macaronesian island endemics show moderate to relatively rapid speciation rates depending on plant groups. Common possible mechanisms driving diversification are difficult to postulate. During the late Miocene and Pleistocene, however, it is likely that multiple catastrophic volcanic episodes, increasing altitudinal gradients, and the onset of moisture-laden northeastern trade winds created a remarkable array of ecological habitats. In addition, several other major geological and climatic changes in western Mediterranean areas including the Iberian Peninsula, northern Africa, and western Europe could possibly have promoted rapid speciation, inter-island and inter-archipelago colonization of those plant groups.
In conclusion, we recover three discrete windows of colonization for the Canary Islands that explain the origin and adaptive radiation of five major eudicot lineages in Macaronesia. Inter-archipelago dispersals into Madeira and the Cape Verdes appear to be quite recent without major subsequent diversification in these archipelagos. The tempo of adaptive radiation of major Macaronesian plant endemics varies from moderate to relatively rapid speciation rates.
Materials and Methods
Selection of plant groups
The flora of the Macaronesian Islands , which encompasses five Atlantic archipelagos, is exceptionally rich and diverse. The number of flowering plant species is approximately 3200, of which some 680, or 20%, are endemic , , . Among the five archipelagos, the Canary Islands (percentage of endemics, 25.5% of the whole flora and 40% of the native flora) are by far the richest and most diverse group of islands followed by the Cape Verde (15%), Madeira (8%), the Azores (5.2%), and the Salvage Islands (2.2%) . Three archipelagos, Madeira, The Canaries, and the Azores, share most of these taxa ,  and the Cape Verde group are shared largely by the Canaries , . The Salvage Islands (area of <15 km2 with highest altitude of <200 m) are intermediate in their floristic character between the Canary Islands and Madeira. Selection of plant groups for this study was based on three criteria: (1) availability of molecular phylogenetic study based on DNA sequence, (2) phylogenetic position in the Angiosperm classification system, and (3) monophyletic assemblage of groups in the Macaronesian islands. Based on these criteria, we selected five core eudicot lineages that were previously shown to be monophyletic in Macaronesia (Supporting Information, Figure S1). Monocot representatives were not included since none of them represent diverse monophyletic groups in Macaronesia. The largest endemic plant genus found on volcanic islands in the Atlantic Ocean, Argyranthemum (Asteraceae), was also excluded due to lack of available DNA sequence data; previous studies used chloroplast DNA restriction-site variations and allozyme frequency data to infer the evolutionary history of the group . In addition, several other plant groups with available molecular phylogenetic studies based on DNA sequence were excluded because they represent multiple colonizations into Macaronesia, are comparatively small plant group, are restricted to one archipelago, and/or they are considered closely related to groups already sampled (e.g., Saxifraga , Bencomia Alliance , Gonosperminae , Euphorbia , Asteriscus , Lavatera , Broom species , Convolvulus , Lotus , Bystropogon , Limonium ).
The selection of five plant groups, thus, best represents the most diverse monophyletic plant groups in Macaronesia in which adaptive radiation is a primary explanation for morphological and ecological diversification. All five lineages display predominantly woody life forms in Macaronesia and are considered Tertiary relicts and ancestral to modern Mediterranean relatives . They are distributed in more than one archipelago, primarily in the Canaries, Madeira, and the Cape Verde Islands. Recent molecular phylogenetic studies –,  demonstrated that the initial colonization and diversification occurred recently on the Canary archipelago from the western Africa/Iberian Peninsula and Mediterranean region, and refuted the relictual nature of the woody-life forms.
Sequence data and phylogenetic analysis
For the woody Sonchus alliance (Asteraceae, subgenus Dendrosonchus and five allied genera), the data matrix based on the internal transcribed spacer (ITS) of nuclear ribosomal DNA (nrDNA)  was used. Approximately 4000 base pairs (bp) of chloroplast DNA (cpDNA) coding and noncoding sequences were highly invariable and the combined data analysis showed almost identical tree topology as the one based on ITS only . Therefore, we used the ITS data matrix only to estimate the absolute age and diversification rate. The closest continental relatives of the alliance turned out to be Sonchus subgenus Sonchus the Ibero-African section Pustulati , and thus we used a representative of this section, Sonchus palustris, which occurs widely in western non-Mediterranean region, as an outgroup. The data matrix included three noncoding cpDNA gene regions and nrDNA ITS 1 sequences  was used for genus Echium (Boraginaceae). Five continental species were used as outgroups based on the previous study  and five additional species, primarily Iberian and Mediterranean, were used as closest continental species for the Macaronesian Echium species. For the ITS data matrix of genus Crambe (Brassicaceae, subgenus Dendrocrambe), two species C. kilimandscharica and C. orientalis, were used as outgroups , while C. kralikii which occurs in Morocco, was used as sole continental closest relative. For Sideritis (Lamiaceae, subgenus Marrubiastrum), four widespread annual and eastern Mediterranean perennial species were used as outgroups, while five primarily western Mediterranean perennials and one annual species from Morocco were used as closest continental species. The ITS data matrix  was used for this genus since ITS tree was better resolved, more strongly supported, and reflected the relationships based on morphology better than the cpDNA based tree. Lastly, for the Aeonium alliance (Aeonium, Aichryson, Monanthes, and Greenovia), we used the same ITS and cpDNA (psbA-trnH and trnL-trnF) data set ; however, matK sequences were excluded because they were not highly variable. Two species, Sedum clavatum and Echeveria fulgens, in the Acre clade, which is sister to Aeonium  were used as outgroups, while two other species of Sedum, S. jaccardianum and S. modestum, which occur in northern Africa, were used as closest continental relatives. All five of the Macaronesian lineages included in this study have complete or nearly complete species sampling. Life history effects on ITS substitution rate is likely negligible since all five plant groups have similar life forms, i.e., long-lived woody perennials.
Maximum likelihood (ML) analysis was performed for each group (see Supporting Information, Figures S2, S3, S4, S5 and S6). The best fit model based on the Akaike Information Criterion (AIC) implemented in ModelTest  was chosen. Model parameters were then imported into PAUP* , and heuristic searches were executed. ML bootstrap analyses with 100 replicates were conducted using the same parameter values obtained from ModelTest.
Divergence time estimates
Maximum likelihood trees (as described above) of each of the five Macaronesian clades were used to estimate divergence dates using Bayesian methods implemented in Multidivtime , . ML parameters were estimated for each tree using the F84+G model in PAUP*. The estbranches package was employed to estimate branch lengths and generate a variance-covariance matrix using these parameters. Multidivtime was then used to produce a posterior probability distribution to calculate the mean and standard deviation of divergence times using default settings for burn-in length and sampling frequency of the Markov chain .
Molecular dating calibration
Unfortunately, paleobotanical and paleoclimatic data do not provide irrefutable evidence for the ages of the Macaronesian flora. Terrestrial plant fossils dated at 13 My before present (BP) have been recorded from Gran Canaria, and fossils of several plant taxa that are currently restricted to or have distributions centered on Macaronesia have been discovered in continental Europe , , ; however, the precise taxonomic identification of these fossils has proved inconclusive .
Given the lack of reliable fossil and/or paleoclimatic data, we used well-documented geological estimates of island ages as our calibration points. The oldest Macaronesian island, Fuerteventura, is a member of the Canary Islands, and is estimated to be approximately 21 million years old (Early Miocene). Older seamounts surrounding Macaronesia have been dated to 68 myr , but these are much too old to date divergences within plan families that originated in the Tertiary: Asteraceae, mid Oligocene, ca. 30 Myr , ; Brassicaceae, Oligocene, ca. 30 Myr 64, 65; Lamiales s.l., late Eocene/Oligocene, ca. 35 Myr , ; Boraginaceae, subfamily Boraginoideae, Oligocene, ca 32 Myr ; Crassulaceae, mid Eocene, ca. 40 Myr, split between Sedum/Dudleya and Kalenchoe, <30 Myr . Therefore, 21 My serves as a conservative maximum age for the most recent common ancestor of the clade comprising the Macaronesian endemics and their continenetal relatives. The upper limit of 21 My is within the range of the Miocene and Pliocene fossil flora in southern Europe that are present today in Macaronesia ,  and some of the dramatic paleogeological/paleoclimatic events in northern Africa and Europe (e.g., the Betic crisis [15–16 mya], the Messinian salinity crisis [6.5-5.5 mya], –, and the Sahara desertification [7 mya], ). Both purported ancestral islands of each group (Tenerife and Gran Canaria, 12 and 14 Ma, respectively) and the oldest Macaronesian islands (Fuerteventura, 21 Ma) were used as root calibration points; the date of the oldest island (21 Ma) was used as a hard upper bound at the root of each tree.
Species diversification rate
Species diversification rates were estimated using a simple pure-birth macroevolutionary model given by the formula D = (ln Ni−ln N0)/T, where Ni equals the number of extant species and N0 equals the number of species at time T, the estimated age of the most recent common ancestor in millions of years.
Phylogenetic classification of the flowering plants and the position of five plant groups studied. The tree is from the Angiosperm Phylogeny Group (version 7, June 2007) (http://www.mobot.org/MOBOT/Research/APweb/).
(3.06 MB TIF)
Maximum likelihood phylogram (model: SYM+G, -ln = 1579.7311) of the woody Sonchus alliance (Asteraceae) based on ITS sequence of nrDNA. Gray circle represents calibration point. (S. = Sonchus) (1 = dispersal to the Canary Islands, 2 = dispersal to Madeira, 3 = dispersal to Cape Verde).
(0.96 MB TIF)
Maximum likelihood phylogram (model: GTR+I+G, -ln = 3228.8472) of Echium (Boraginaceae) based on ITS and cpDNA sequences. Gray circle represents calibration point. (1 = dispersal to the Canary Islands, 2 = dispersal to Cape Verde, 3 = dispersal to Madeira).
(0.79 MB TIF)
Maximum likelihood phylogram (model: TIM+G, -ln = 2110.9453) of Sideritis (Lamiaceae) based on ITS sequence. Gray circle represent calibration point. (1 = dispersal to the Canary Islands, 2 = dispersal to Medeira).
(0.89 MB TIF)
Maximum likelihood phylogram (model: K80+G, -ln = 1176.8682) of Crambe section Dendrocrambe (Brassicaceae) based on ITS sequence. Gray circle represents calibration point. (1 = dispersal to the Canary Islands, 2 = dispersal to Madeira).
(0.83 MB TIF)
Maximum likelihood phylogram (model: TIM+I+G, -ln = 12034.2559) of the Aeonium alliance (Crassulaceae) based on ITS and cpDNA sequences. Gray circle represents calibration point. (1 = Canary Islands, 2 and 2′ = dispersal to Madeira, 3 and 3′ = dispersal to continent, 4 = dispersal to Cape Verde).
(0.93 MB TIF)
We thank D. J. Crawford and Norm Ellstrand for comments and suggestions on an earlier version of the manuscript. Two reviewers and J. Stajich also helped to improve the manuscript. We dedicate this paper to Sherwin Carlquist, who made significant contributions to our understanding of island plants and inspired us to work on the fascinating plant groups in the Macaronesian islands.
Conceived and designed the experiments: SK JB. Performed the experiments: MRM JB MEM. Analyzed the data: SK. Wrote the paper: SK. Other: Involved in the study design: PL. Assisted in the field work: AS.
- 1. Sunding P (1979) Origins of the Macaronesian flora. In: Bramwell D, editor. Plants and Islands. London: Academic Press. pp. 13–40.
- 2. Carracedo JC, et al. (2002) Cenozoic volcanism II: The Canary Islands. In: Gibbons W, Moreno T, editors. The Geology of Spain. London: Geological Society Publishing House. pp. 439–472.
- 3. Humphries CJ (1979) Endemism and evolution in Macaronesia. In: Bramwell D, editor. Plants and Islands. London: Academic Press. pp. 171–200.
- 4. Santos-Guerra A (1999) Origen y evolución de la flora canaria. In: Fernández-Palacios JM, Bacallado JJ, Belmonte JA, editors. Ecología y Cultura en Canarias. Santa Cruz de Tenerife: Organismo Autónomo de Museos y Centros. pp. 107–129.
- 5. Aldridge AE (1979) Evolution within a single genus: Sonchus in Macaronesia. In: Bramwell D, editor. Plants and Islands. London: Academic Press. pp. 279–293.
- 6. Francisco-Ortega J, Santos-Guerra A, Kim S-C, Crawford DJ (2000) Plant genetic diversity in the Canary Islands: a conservation perspective. Am J Bot 87: 909–919.
- 7. Juan C, Emerson BC, Oromi P, Hewitt GM (2000) Colonization and diversification: toward a phylogeographic synthesis for the Canary Islands. Trends Ecol Evol 15: 104–109.
- 8. Emerson BC, Kolm N (2005) Species diversity can drive speciation. Nature 434: 1015–1017.
- 9. Emerson BC (2002) Evolution on oceanic islands: molecular phylogenetic approaches to understanding pattern and process. Molec Ecol 11: 951–966.
- 10. Vargas P (2007) Are Macaronesian islands refugia of relict plant lineages?: a molecular survey. In: Weiss S, Ferrand N, editors. Phylogeography of Southern European Refugia – Evolutionary perspectives on the origins and conservation of European biodiversity. Netherlands: Springer. pp. 297–341.
- 11. Francisco-Ortega J, Jansen RK, Santos-Guerra A (1996) Chloroplast DNA evidence of colonization, adaptive radiation, and hybridization in the evolution of the Macaronesian flora. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 93: 4085–4090.
- 12. Böhle U-R, Hilger HH, Martin WF (1996) Island colonization and evolution of the insular woody habit in Echium L. (Boraginaceae). Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 93: 11740–11745.
- 13. Kim S-C, Crawford DJ, Francisco-Ortega J, Santos-Guerra A (1996) A common origin for woody Sonchus and five related genera in the Macaronesian islands: molecular evidence for extensive radiation. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 93: 7743–7748.
- 14. Barber JC, Finch CC, Francisco-Ortega J, Santos-Guerra A, Jansen RK (2007) Hybridization in Macaronesian Sideritis (Lamiaceae): evidence from incongruence of multiple independent nuclear and chloroplast sequence data sets. Taxon 56: 74–88.
- 15. Mort ME, Soltis DE, Soltis PS, Francisco-Ortega J, Santos-Guerra A (2002) Phylogenetics and evolution of the Macaronesian clade of Crassulaceae inferred from nuclear and chloroplast sequence data. Syst Bot 27: 271–288.
- 16. Percy DM, Cronk QCB (2002) Different fates of island brooms: contrasting evolution in Adenocarpus, Genista, and Teline (Genisteae, Fabaceae) in the Canary Islands and Madeira. Am J Bot 89: 854–864.
- 17. Fuertes-Aguilar J, Ray JM, Francisco-Ortega J, Santos-Guerra A, Jansen RK (2002) Molecular evidence from chloroplast and nuclear markers for multiple colonizations of Lavatera (Malvaceae) in the Canary Islands. Syst Bot 27: 74–83.
- 18. Francisco-Ortega J, et al. (2002) Phylogeny of the Macaronesian endemic Crambe section Dendrocrambe (Brassicaceae) based on internal transcribed spacer sequences of nuclear ribosomal DNA. Am J Bot 89: 1984–1990.
- 19. Carine MA, Russell SJ, Santos-Guerra A, Francisco-Ortega J (2004) Relationships of the Macaronesian and Mediterranean floras: molecular evidence for multiple colonizations into Macaronesia and back-colonization of the continent in Colvolvlus (Convolvulaceae). Am. J. Bot. 91: 1070–1085.
- 20. Allan GJ, Francisco-Ortega J, Santos-Guerra A, Boerner E, Zimmer EA (2004) Molecular phylogenetic evidence for the geographic origin and classification of Canary Island Lotus (Fabaceae: Loteae). Mol Phylogenet Evol 32: 123–138.
- 21. Francisco-Ortega J, Crawford DJ, Santos-Guerra A, Sá-Fontinha S (1995) Genetic diversity among Mediterranean and Macaronesian genera of the subtribe Chrysantheminae (Asteraceae). Am J Bot 82: 1321–1328.
- 22. Kim S-C, Crawford DJ, Francisco-Ortega J, Santos-Guerra A (1999) Adaptive radiation and genetic differentiation in the woody Sonchus alliance (Asteraceae: Sonchinae) in the Canary Islands. Pl Syst Evol 215: 101–118.
- 23. Baldwin BG, Sanderson MJ (1998) Age and rate of diversification of the Hawaiian silversword alliance (Compositae). Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 95: 9402–9406.
- 24. Klak C, Reeves G, Hedderson TH (2004) Unmatched tempo of evolution in Southern African semi-desert ice plants. Nature 427: 63–65.
- 25. Hughes C, Eastwood R (2006) Island radiation on a continental scale: exceptional rates of plant diversification after uplift of the Andes. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 103: 10334–10339.
- 26. Jolivet L, Augier R, Robin C, Sue J-P, Rouchy SM (2006) Lithospheric-scale geodynamic context of the Messinian salinity crisis. Sed Geol 188-189: 9–33.
- 27. Schuster M, et al. (2006) The age of the Sahara desert. Science 311: 821.
- 28. Hsü KJ (1977) History of the Mediterranean salinity crisis. Nature 267: 399–403.
- 29. Thompson JD (2005) Plant Evolution in the Mediterranean. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- 30. Carine MA (2005) Spatio-temporal relationships of the Macaronesian endemic flora: a relictual series or window of opportunity? Taxon 54: 895–903.
- 31. Lledó MD, Crespo MB, Fay MF, Chase MW (2005) Molecular phylogenetics of Limonium and related genera (Plumbaginaceae): beogragraphical and systematic implications. Amer J Bot 92: 1189–1198.
- 32. Silvertown J (2004) The ghost of competition past in the phylogeny of island endemic plants. J Ecol 92: 168–173.
- 33. Eriksson O, Bremer B (1992) Pollination systems, dispersal modes, life forms, and diversification rates in Angiosperm families. Evolution 46: 258–266.
- 34. Stanley ES (1979) Macroevolution. W. H. Freeman, San Francisco, CA, USA.
- 35. Vrba ES (1987) Ecology in relation to speciation rates: some case histories of Miocene-Recent mammal clades. Evol Ecol 1: 283–300.
- 36. Rosenzweig ML, Vetault S (1992) Calculating speciation and extinction rates in fossil clades. Evol Ecol 6: 90–93.
- 37. Good-Avila SV, Souza V, Gaut BS, Eguiarte LE (2006) Timing and rate of speciation in Agave (Agavaceae). Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 103: 9124–9129.
- 38. Hulbert RC Jr (1993) The rise and fall of an adaptive radiation. Paleobiology 19: 216–234.
- 39. McCune AR (1997) How fast is speciation? Molecular, geological, and phylogenetic evidence from adaptive radiations of fishes. In: Givnish T, Sytsma KJ, editors. Molecular Evolution and Adaptive Radiation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. pp. 585–610.
- 40. Magallón S, Sanderson MJ (2001) Absolute diversification rates in Angiosperm clades. Evolution 55: 1762–1780.
- 41. Borgen L (1984) Biosystematics of macaronesian flowering plants. In: Grant VF, editor. Plant Biosystematics. Toronto: Academic Press. pp. 477–496.
- 42. Sunding P (1973) Endemism in the flora of the Cape Verde Islands, with special emphasis on the Macaronesian flora element. Monogr Biol Canar 4: 112–117.
- 43. Francisco-Ortega J, Crawford DJ, Santos-Guerra A, Jansen RK (1997) Origin and evolution of Argyranthemum (Asteraceae: Anthemideae) in Macaronesia. In: Givnish T, Sytsma KJ, editors. Molecular Evolution and Adaptive Radiation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. pp. 407–431.
- 44. Vargas P, Morton CM, Jury SL (1999) Biogeographic patterns in Mediterranean and Macaronesian species of Saxifraga (Sasifragaceae) inferred from phylogenetic analyses of ITS sequences. Am J Bot 86: 724–734.
- 45. Helfgott DM, Francisco-Ortega J, Santos-Guerra A, Jansen RK, Simpson BB (2000) Beogeography and breeding system evolution of the woody Bencomia alliance (Rosaceae) in Macaronesia based on ITS sequence data. Syst Bot 25: 82–97.
- 46. Francisco-Ortega J, Barber JC, Santos-Guerra A, Febles-Hernández R, Jansen RK (2001) Origin and evolution of the endemic genera of Gonosperminae (Asteraceae: Anthemideae) from the Canary Islands: evidence from nucleotide sequences of internal transcribed spacers of the nuclear ribosomal DNA. Am J Bot 88: 161–169.
- 47. Molero J, Garnatje T, Rovira A, Garcia-Jacas N, Susanna A (2002) Karyological evolution and molecular phylogeny in Macaronesian dendroid spurges (Euphorbia subsect. Pachycladae). Pl Syst Evol 231: 109–132.
- 48. Goertzen LR, et al. (2002) Molecular systematics of the Asteriscus alliance (Asteraceae: Inuleae) II: combined nuclear and chloroplast data. Syst Bot 27: 815–823.
- 49. Trusty JL, Olmstead RG, Santos-Guerra A, Sá-Fontinha S, Francisco-Ortega J (2005) Molecular phylogenetics of the Macaronesian-endemic genus Bystropogon (Lamiaceae): palaeo-islands, ecological shifts and interisland colonizations. Mol. Ecol. 14: 1177–1189.
- 50. Bramwell D (1972) Endemism in the flora of the Canary Islands. In: Valentine DH, editor. Taxonomy, Phytogeography, and Evolution. New York: Academic Press. pp. 141–159.
- 51. Lee C, Kim SC, Lundy K, Santos-Guerra A (2005) Chroloplast DNA phylogeny of the woody Sonchus alliance (Asteraceae: Sonchinae) in the Macaronesian Islands. Am J Bot 82: 2072–2085.
- 52. Kim S-C, Lee C, Mejías JA (2007) Phylogenetic analysis of chloroplast DNA matK gene and ITS of nrDNA sequences reveals polyphyly of the genus Sonchus and new relationships among the subtribe Sonchinae (Asteraceae: Cichorieae). Mol Phyloget Evol 44: 578–579.
- 53. Bromham L, Woolfit M (2004) Explosive radiations and reliability of molecular clocks: island endemic radiations as a test case. Syst Biol 53: 758–766.
- 54. Mort ME, Soltis DE, Soltis PS, Francisco-Ortega F, Santos-Guerra A (2001) Phylogenetic relationships and evolution of Crassulaceae inferred from matK sequence data. Am J Bot 88: 76–91.
- 55. Posada D, Crandall K (1998) MODELTEST: testing the model of DNA substitution. Bioinformatics 14: 817–818.
- 56. Swofford DL (2003) PAUP*, Phylogenetic Analysis Using Parsimony (*and Other Methods). Version 4.10b. Sunderland: Sinauer Associates.
- 57. Thorne JL, Kishino H, Painter IS (1998) Estimating the rate of evolution of the rate of molecular evolution. Mol Biol Evol 15: 1647–1657.
- 58. Kishino H, Thorne JL, Bruno WJ (2001) Performance of a divergence time estimation method under a probabilistic model of rate evolution. Mol Biol Evol 18: 352–361.
- 59. Frahm JP (2004) A new contribution to the moss flora of Baltic and Saxon amber. Review of Paleobotany and Palynology 129: 81–101.
- 60. Vanderpoorten A, Rumsey FJ, Carine MA (2007) Does Macaronesia exist? Conflicting signal in the bryophyte and pteridophyte floras. Am J Bot 94: 625–639.
- 61. García-Talavera F, Sánchez-Pinto L, Socorro S (1995) Vegetales fósiles en el complejo traquítico-sienítico de Gran Canaria. Revista de la Academia Canaria de Ciencias 7: 77–91.
- 62. Geldmacher J, Hoernle K, van den Bogaard P, Zankl G, Garbe-Schonberg D (2001) Earlier history of the ≥70-Ma-old Canary hotspot based on the temporal and geochemical evolution of the Selvagen Archipelago and neighbouring seamounts in the eastern North Atlantic. J Volcanol Geotherm Res 111: 55–87.
- 63. Graham A (1996) A contribution to the geologic history of the Compositae. In: Hind DJ, Beentje HJ, editors. Compositae: Systematics. Kew: Royal Botanic Gardens. pp. 123–140.
- 64. Cronquist A (1981) An Integrated System of Classification of Flowering Plants. New York: Columbia University Press.
- 65. Koch MA, Jaubold B, Mitchell-Olds T (2000) Comparative evolutionary analysis of chalcone synthase and alcohol dehydrogenase loci in Arabidopsis, Arabis, and related genera (Brassicaceae). Mol Biol Evol 17: 1483–1498.
- 66. Magallón S, Crane PR, Herendeen PS (1999) Phylogenetic pattern, diversity, and diversification of eudicots. Ann Missouri Bot Garden 86: 297–372.
- 67. Wikström N, Savolainen V, Chase MW (2001) Evolution of the angiosperms: calibrating the family tree. Proc R Soc Lond B 268: 2211–2220.
- 68. Moore MJ, Jansen RK (2006) Molecular evidence for the age, origin, and evolutionary history of the American desert plant genus Tiquilia (Boraginaceae). Mol Phylogenet Evol 39: 668–687.
- 69. De Jong H (1998) In search of historical biogeographic patterns in the western Mediterranean terrestrial fauna. Biol J Linn Soc 65: 99–164.
- 70. Veith M, Mayer C, Samraoui B, Barroso DD, Bogaerts S (2004) From Europe to Africa and vice versa: evidence for multiple intercontinental dispersal in ribbed salamanders (Genus Pleurodeles). J Biogeogr 31: 159–171.
- 71. Barrón E, Pierrot D (2006) La vegetación forestall en el Terciario. In: Carrión JS, Fernández S, Fuentes N, editors. Paleoambientes y Cambio Climático. Murcia: Agencia de ciencia y Tecnología de la Región de Murcia. pp. 55–76. eds Carrión.
- 72. Schuster M, et al. (2006) The age of the Sahara desert. Science 311: 821.