Citation: Maitland K, Akech S, Gwer S, Idro R, Fegan G, Eziefula AC, et al. (2007) Phase III Trials Required to Resolve Clinical Equipoise over Optimal Fluid Management in Children with Severe Malaria. PLOS Clin Trial 2(2): e2. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pctr.0020002
Published: February 9, 2007
Copyright: © 2007 Maitland et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: The authors received no specific funding for this article.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
There is a consensus among paediatricians that outcome of children presenting with life-threatening infections, irrespective of the infecting pathogen, can be improved by timely recognition and prompt intervention to correct disordered physiology using simple approaches to resuscitation [1–3]. These approaches include the provision of oxygen and the correction of fluid, electrolyte, and glucose deficits [4,5]. Indeed, studies have shown that most of the recent gains in survival of children with severe infections have come through the application of this approach by non-specialists during the initial hours of management [6,7]. Correction of hypotension and volume depletion through fluid administration is a fundamental component of resuscitation in most critically ill children [8,9], but its role in severe malaria remains uncertain and thus represents one of the most important theoretical gaps in our understanding of supportive treatments in this condition.
Many children with severe malaria have signs of cardiovascular compromise or compensated shock on presentation to hospital and a smaller proportion are hypotensive . One of the major unresolved aspects of management is whether volume expansion should be undertaken in children displaying signs of compensated shock, as is recommended in other paediatric disorders. Intravascular volume depletion (hypovolaemic shock) results in impaired cardiovascular function and inadequate tissue and organ perfusion, and would usually be corrected rapidly. Simple dehydration, predominantly affecting the intracellular compartment, can be safely corrected gradually. The choice of the optimum fluid for resuscitation is also unclear. Colloidal solutions, although more costly, are less likely to precipitate cerebral and pulmonary oedema due to their oncotic properties.
Recognising the importance of adequate fluid management to the outcome of the critically ill child, the group at Kilifi has conducted a staged series of studies over the last 15 years to address each of these questions. In a collaboration that included specialists in paediatric intensive care, neurology, and clinical trials, the group demonstrated the importance, prognostic implications , and clinical correlates of metabolic acidosis in children with severe malaria  and provided clear evidence of intravascular hypovolaemia by using standard methods for studying critical illness . We have undertaken two randomised trials to assess the safety of and response to volume expansion, and to determine whether colloid replacement offers any advantage over crystalloid replacement [13,14]. We hypothesised that administration of colloids such as human albumin solution with volume expansion would help to retain fluid in the intravascular compartment and may also improve endothelial function. In each of these trials we observed that albumin administration was associated with a lower mortality than saline. Although this data suggested the need for a large clinical trial of albumin, in view of the cost of albumin we thought that cheaper synthetic colloids should be assessed before embarking on a phase III trial. The intention in the small phase II trial, recently published in PLoS Clinical Trials , was to provide sufficient physiological data on succinylated gelatin to inform the design of the next phase, rather than to establish statistical superiority of one colloid over the other. For this purpose the trial was most instructive. Again we observed the same benefits of albumin: only one child who received albumin died, out of a group of participants that included children treated as emergencies who were subsequently found to be ineligible for the trial. The results for Gelofusine, however, were not encouraging. The combined findings that death, severe allergic reaction, and acute neurological events were more common in the Gelofusine group suggested that albumin, rather than a cheaper substitute, should be taken forward into the next phase. This was supported by the analysis of the combined data from three trials, including 238 children receiving volume expansion. While this small phase II study was not powered to prove that Gelofusine was superior to saline or albumin, the results suggest that Gelofusine is unlikely to offer any advantage over the cheaper saline solution.
Given the continued controversy over the use of resuscitation fluids in the management of severe malaria, we suggest that this can only be resolved through a definitive clinical trial. Woodrow and Planche  have chosen a different interpretation. The evidence presented from two studies conducted in Gabon, one which assessed volume depletion in only 12 survivors  and the other larger study conducted in less critically unwell children , supports a position of equipoise—the basis which usually prompts the need for a definitive clinical trial.
- 1. Mackway-Jones K, Molyneux EM, Phillips B, Wieteska S, editors. (2004) Advanced paediatric life support: The practical approach. London: BMJ Publishing Group. K. Mackway-JonesEM MolyneuxB. PhillipsS. Wieteska2004Advanced paediatric life support: The practical approachLondonBMJ Publishing Group
- 2. European Resuscitation Council 2000 Pediatric Life Support Working Group (2002) Guidelines of the European Resuscitation Council 2000 for advanced pediatric life support. A statement of the Pediatric Life Support Working Group following approval by the executive committee of the European Resuscitation Council. Anaesthesist 51: 406–408.European Resuscitation Council 2000 Pediatric Life Support Working Group2002Guidelines of the European Resuscitation Council 2000 for advanced pediatric life support. A statement of the Pediatric Life Support Working Group following approval by the executive committee of the European Resuscitation Council.Anaesthesist51406408
- 3. Zaritsky A, Nadkarni V, Hickey R (2002) Pediatric advanced life support provider manual. Dallas (TX): American Heart Association. A. ZaritskyV. NadkarniR. Hickey2002Pediatric advanced life support provider manualDallas (TX)American Heart Association
- 4. Carcillo JA, Fields AI (2002) Clinical practice parameters for hemodynamic support of pediatric and neonatal patients in septic shock. Crit Care Med 30: 1365–1378.JA CarcilloAI Fields2002Clinical practice parameters for hemodynamic support of pediatric and neonatal patients in septic shock.Crit Care Med3013651378
- 5. Goldstein B, Giroir B, Randolph A (2005) International pediatric sepsis consensus conference: Definitions for sepsis and organ dysfunction in pediatrics. Pediatr Crit Care Med 6: 2–8.B. GoldsteinB. GiroirA. Randolph2005International pediatric sepsis consensus conference: Definitions for sepsis and organ dysfunction in pediatrics.Pediatr Crit Care Med628
- 6. Han YY, Carcillo JA, Dragotta MA, Bills DM, Watson RS, et al. (2003) Early reversal of pediatric-neonatal septic shock by community physicians is associated with improved outcome. Pediatrics 112: 793–799.YY HanJA CarcilloMA DragottaDM BillsRS Watson2003Early reversal of pediatric-neonatal septic shock by community physicians is associated with improved outcome.Pediatrics112793799
- 7. Booy R, Habibi P, Nadel S, de Munter C, Britto J, et al. (2001) Reduction in case fatality rate from meningococcal disease associated with improved healthcare delivery. Arch Dis Child 85: 386–390.R. BooyP. HabibiS. NadelC. de MunterJ. Britto2001Reduction in case fatality rate from meningococcal disease associated with improved healthcare delivery.Arch Dis Child85386390
- 8. Carcillo JA, Davis AL, Zaritsky A (1991) Role of early fluid resuscitation in pediatric septic shock. JAMA 266: 1242–1245.JA CarcilloAL DavisA. Zaritsky1991Role of early fluid resuscitation in pediatric septic shock.JAMA26612421245
- 9. Wills BA, Nguyen DM, Ha TL, Dong TH, Tran TN, et al. (2005) Comparison of three fluid solutions for resuscitation in dengue shock syndrome. N Engl J Med 353: 877–889.BA WillsDM NguyenTL HaTH DongTN Tran2005Comparison of three fluid solutions for resuscitation in dengue shock syndrome.N Engl J Med353877889
- 10. Maitland K, Levin M, English M, Mithwani S, Peshu N, et al. (2003) Severe P. falciparum malaria in Kenyan children: Evidence for hypovolaemia. QJM 96: 427–434.K. MaitlandM. LevinM. EnglishS. MithwaniN. Peshu2003Severe P. falciparum malaria in Kenyan children: Evidence for hypovolaemia.QJM96427434
- 11. Marsh K, Forster D, Waruiru C, Mwangi I, Winstanley M, et al. (1995) Indicators of life-threatening malaria in African children. N Engl J Med 332: 1399–1404.K. MarshD. ForsterC. WaruiruI. MwangiM. Winstanley1995Indicators of life-threatening malaria in African children.N Engl J Med33213991404
- 12. English M, Waruiru C, Amukoye E, Murphy S, Crawley J, et al. (1996) Deep breathing in children with severe malaria: Indicator of metabolic acidosis and poor outcome. Am J Trop Med Hyg 55: 521–524.M. EnglishC. WaruiruE. AmukoyeS. MurphyJ. Crawley1996Deep breathing in children with severe malaria: Indicator of metabolic acidosis and poor outcome.Am J Trop Med Hyg55521524
- 13. Maitland K, Pamba A, Newton CR, Levin M (2003) Response to volume resuscitation in children with severe malaria. Pediatr Crit Care Med 4: 426–431.K. MaitlandA. PambaCR NewtonM. Levin2003Response to volume resuscitation in children with severe malaria.Pediatr Crit Care Med4426431
- 14. Maitland K, Pamba A, English M, Peshu N, Marsh K, et al. (2005) Randomized trial of volume expansion with albumin or saline in children with severe malaria: Preliminary evidence of albumin benefit. Clin Infect Dis 40: 538–545.K. MaitlandA. PambaM. EnglishN. PeshuK. Marsh2005Randomized trial of volume expansion with albumin or saline in children with severe malaria: Preliminary evidence of albumin benefit.Clin Infect Dis40538545
- 15. Akech S, Gwer S, Idro R, Fegan G, Eziefula AC, et al. (2006) Volume expansion with albumin compared to Gelofusine in children with severe malaria: Results of a controlled trial. PLoS Clin Trials. 1. S. AkechS. GwerR. IdroG. FeganAC Eziefula2006Volume expansion with albumin compared to Gelofusine in children with severe malaria: Results of a controlled trial.PLoS Clin Trials1e21.
- 16. Woodrow C, Planche T (2007) Inadequate evidence to support phase III studies of albumin in severe malaria. PLoS Clin Trials. 2. C. WoodrowT. Planche2007Inadequate evidence to support phase III studies of albumin in severe malaria.PLoS Clin Trials2e04.
- 17. Planche T, Onanga M, Schwenk A, Dzeing A, Borrmann S, et al. (2004) Assessment of volume depletion in children with malaria. Plos Med. 1. T. PlancheM. OnangaA. SchwenkA. DzeingS. Borrmann2004Assessment of volume depletion in children with malaria.Plos Med1e18.
- 18. Jarvis JN, Planche T, Bicanic T, Dzeing-Ella A, Kombila M, et al. (2006) Lactic acidosis in Gabonese children with severe malaria is unrelated to dehydration. Clin Infect Dis 42: 1719–1725.JN JarvisT. PlancheT. BicanicA. Dzeing-EllaM. Kombila2006Lactic acidosis in Gabonese children with severe malaria is unrelated to dehydration.Clin Infect Dis4217191725